• Google+

FanPost

Evaluating the 2004 Draft...

Stay connected for news and updates

On the theory that it takes about three years to evaluate a draft, here is a look back at the 2004 draft class:

OVERALL:  When only ONE of your first 5 picks are even with the team after 3 years, you can't be satisfied.  When you factor in the JJ vs Stephen Jackson decision, the draft looks even worse (and I am still hopeful JJ shines this year, but you cannot argue with production to-date).  While our three 7th round picks are looking good, only Patrick Crayton has demonstrated Pro-Bowl potential.  You gotta give this draft extremely poor marks.

2nd round-43rd overall  RB-Julius Jones -- This pick stands out as much for who we didn't take: namely Stephen Jackson.  It is interesting how JJ is STILL a bit of a mystery as to his value, yet Jackson is a proven workhorse.  Until proven otherwise, gotta call this one a mistake.  Certainly not a bust, and JJ can still shine, but at this point, this decision looks BAD.

2-52 OT-Jacob Rogers, USC  -- HUGE mistake, and I hope I don't see this guy's name again for a while, it gives me a headache.  BUST.

3-83 OG-Stephen Peterman, LSU  -- While he may still prove otherwise for the Lions, anyone released within two years must be called a BUST.

4-121 CB-Bruce Thornton, Georgia -- Again, didn't make the team and was signed by the 49ers off the practice squad.  BUST.

5-144 TE-Sean Ryan, Boston College -- Traded for a 7th rounder this year.  BAD.

7-205 CB-Nathan Jones, Rutgers -- A 7th round pick still on the team, contributing in the nickel and on special teams.  GOOD PICK.

7-216 WR-Patrick Crayton, NW Oklahoma State -- Outside of JJ, the only stand-out of this class.  Continues to improve.  GREAT PICK.

7-223 CB- Jacques Reeves , Purdue. -- Played in 15 games as a rookie, stepped in when Henry was hurt last year.  Also a special teams asset.  GOOD PICK.

Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.

There are 9 Comments. Load Now. Loading

Shortcuts to mastering the comment thread. Use wisely.

C - Next Comment
X - Mark as Read

R - Reply
Z - Mark Read & Next

Shift + C - Previous
Shift + A - Mark All Read

Comment Settings

Live comment alert: Hide it!

Comments for this post are closed.