Not a secondary priority
Howdy. In lieu of other things to fill my head this offseason (bashing on patrick Crayton doesn't count, I've yelled at him several dozen times internally in the last week) I've taken it upon myself to write up a rundown of every facet of this team's roster; evaluating the current players, their performance, expectations, and salary impact. I will also look at prospective additions to that facet of the roster. I will start with the most oft-lamented portion of this squad: The coverage team.
The format I will use is as such: I will begin by listing the relevant players, going from the one I value most to least. After running through the current performers, I'll turn to the potential newcomers.
Terrence Newman, cornerback. Honestly, there is only one fault I can find with T-New. He's only played for five years, yet he'll be thirty next year. Newman is the truest definition of 'shutdown corner', and he put forth, when healthy, his best season yet. I honestly cannot bring to mind the last time a wide receiver truly burned him in a game; the dropoff between a lead receiver covered by our #2 corner and a lead receiver covered by Newey is incredibly pronounced. He doesn't put up the greatest of numbers, but this can be attributed to the fact that quarterbacks simply don't throw his way. While it's true that he doesn't have the best hands, he can take advantage of a badly thrown pass often enough. If not for his (relatively)advanced age, N would be looking a huge deal in the eyes after next season. Keeping him is a priority, as the secondary is in shambles without Terrence.
Ken Hamlin, safety. I am still shocked by the contract Ham got last season. He was barely 26 years old, going into his fifth year in the league, and had established a stellar track record both in pass and run defense, showing the ability to play at either safety slot. Yet he settled for a contract worthy of someone trying to prove his worth; 1 year at 2.5 million. Needless to say, Hamlin has more than lived up to expectations. He was centerfielder in a defensive unit that sorely needed one, a big hitter and an opportunist with more awareness of the goings-on in his vicinity than we've seen since Darren Woodson. Keeping him will be a big priority, but we can't account for some team not changing its tune from last year and giving Ken a contract beyond his value. I see him getting four years at approximately sixteen million, and he's worth every penny of that to this team.
Anthony Henry, cornerback. The antithesis of Terrence Newman, Henry gambles regularly, gets thrown at even moreso, and therefore gets beat a lot but can also turn the tide of a game. He's still a usable second corner, but at 31 he won't be for much longer. While not a liability, he gets beaten fairly easily by most receivers who exhibit a semblance of speed. Henry is capable in run support, a decent tackler with good instincts. He's under contract for two more seasons at a reasonable rate, so don't expect a cut- but he could see his role on the team decrease through the time he has left with America's team.
Roy Williams, safety. Frankly, he earns a spot above Jacques Reeves purely on his past performances. Roy was a terrifically impactful player in college and in his first few years in the bigs, but has fallen off drastically since then. Still more than capable in run support, Roy can make the occasional big hit. But the frequency of the hits has decreased as his attempts at executing them have increased, and this is unacceptable. Too often he makes powerless tackles that fail to even impede the ballcarrier. Roy needs to return to the player he once was; we've all come to accept that he's a liability in pass coverage. But the least he can do is wrap people up once he gets there, knock out the occasional fumble when the situation calls for it, and capitalize with an interception every now and then. He's changing his number next year, in a straw-graspingly desperate move for a new beginning. Let's hope changing the 31 to a 38 is not a solitary move; that Williams actually makes an effort to return to the star player he once was.
Jacques Reeves, cornerback. A 4 year vet from Purdue, the seventh round draft pick has performed beyond expectations during his time here. That, however, is not necessarily an indication that he's a great asset. Reeves is a third corner; he has decent speed and coverage skills, is mediocre against the run, and can't cause turnovers with a great deal of regularity. The 25 year old is the magnet that must exist in the Cowboys' scheme; when Newman's receiver only gets a throw or two per game, the QB has to put it somewhere. Playing alongside Terrence can swell your tackle and INT numbers; Reeves hasn't taken much advantage of this. It will also cast you as the goat who gives up tons of plays; and he certainly has been typecast that way. Reeves is not terrible, every team has a third corner. He's a nice piece to have, and should be retained.
Nathan Jones, cornerback. Selected 18 slots ahead of Reeves in the '04 draft, the Rutgers alum has seen limited time throughout his tenure here. Keep in mind; 18 slots ahead of Reeves still leaves him a 7th rounder. Jones is not someone you want to hang out to dry, he's a backup and recognized as such. You need guys like this, look what they've done for the Giants and their incredible ruin of a secondary. When you create constant pressure, an inadequate secondary suddenly becomes sufficient. Jones will likely be back at an affordable rate.
At this point we move to prospective additions. This free agent crop is tremendously rich with high-level cornerbacks but almost devoid of safeties other than our own. The problem: The three elite guys (Asante Samuel, Nnamdi Asomugha, and Marcus Trufant) will probably cash in to the tune of a long term deal at about 10 million per annum. This is far too much for the Cowboys to afford; they have their own needs to address. They likely will look to an inexpensive veteran , such as Drayton Florence or Shawn Springs, to fill a cornerback slot.
This year's draft is absolutely overflowing with first-round DBs. There are foreseeably six who should earn that distinction, and only one of them (Hurricanes safety Kenny Phillips) is widely projected to go off the board before our first selection at #22.
Mike Jenkins is the best of the rest. Jenkins has terrific size and speed, can force turnovers, sticks with receivers in both man and zone coverage. He's likely the most experienced of this group. He does, however, lack the sure tackling displayed by most and has some character issues. It may seem like a bit of a leap, but PacMan Jones' skill set and resume jumps to mind (Keep in mind, I wouldn't dare insinuate that Jenkins is ^&*@-ed up to quite that degree). Fun fact: He was born in Germany.
Malcolm Jenkins (no association) is probably the most talented defensive back in this draft. He's huge, runs a supposed 4.3 40, and QBs usually don't look his way. On the other hand, Jenkins is lacking in complementary tackles, does not break up many passes, and hasn't made many interceptions. Strangely, he has trouble with smaller receivers.The Ohio State grad could make someone very happy if things go right, but there is a big bust factor. A good comp doesn't come to mind, but Antonio Cromartie is the absolute best case scenario.
Antoine Cason is the 2007 Thorpe award winner. He's got decent size, good quickness, shows great awareness and terrific hands. He has home-run ability, having run back several of his picks for Six. He is, however, a bit lacking on bulk and struggles at bringing his man down. Despite his height, he has displayed difficulty in coping with large receivers. Best case comp: Marcus Trufant.
Aqib Talib is one of my personal faves. He's not quick, he's not one to turn an INT into a TD, but he makes plays of every kind. One of the larger cornerbacks you'll see, Talib displays excellent coverage ability, footwork, and hands. He's very stout against the run and has done great things against some very good receivers. One glaring problem is his lack of big-time speed, and that could come back to bite him down the road. My first thought when considering Talib was Ronde Barber, but that may be a bit steep. He's actually quite a bit like our very own Anthony Henry.
Reggie Smith is a very interesting prospect. The Oklahoma junior is a tandem safety-cornerback, and as one would expect is drawing many critics. There are those who say that his lack of a clearly defined role will hurt him in the long run, that in the NFL you must specialize in a single position to be truly good at it. I, for one, believe that knowing how to play in two (or in this case, three) spots is a major asset. Smith is the classic jack of all trades. Good in coverage, good timed speed, good change of direction and footwork, stellar at recognizing how the play breaks down and stout against the run. He won't cause sensation with anything he does, however, and that wil deter some people come draft day. I'm having a hard time finding a comp for this guy, to be honest. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Leodis McKelvin is yet another player who is useful because he fills multiple roles. McKelvin is fairly diminutive, not known primarily for his abilities as a cornerback, and comes from a small program. However, he's absolutely electric on kick returns and has shown all that one can show at Troy as a DB. Demarcus Ware's one-time teammate is shooting up draft boards, and rightfully so. He hasn't been tested to the extent of the big-conference coverage guys, but as I said-shown all he can. Comp: I'm having a hard time with this one too. I thought Devin Hester, but McKelvin brings more than that on defense.
That was exhausting. It's about time I found a use for the intervals of time between my classes, though =D
If you're looking for further information on all this stuff, I'd strongly recommend Scott Wright's NFL Draft Countdown and Football's Future.
Next on the docket: The linebacking corps!
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
0 recs |
25 comments
Comments
outstanding job Or Moyal
by Deke on Jan 22, 2008 5:47 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Malcolm Jenkins not
entering the NFL Draft. He made the annoucement recently to stay in college.
I've been hawking the CB's in this draft for some time and there aren't many to take a first round flyer on. There will probably be only 3 CBs taken in the first round, the best being Mike Jenkins who will be a 7-10 pick.
So, I'll disagree that this class "Overflowing". In fact, it's the opposite. It's a very weak draft for CBs as so many scouts have pointed out.
I think a FA CB is in order and draft a rookie CB in the second round.
by Cowboys81 on Jan 22, 2008 5:58 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
My apologies on the Jenkins front
I haven't been as studious as I should be in keeping up with that news.
As far as CBs, there are a few other guys I didn't mention, most notably Antoine Cason and DeJuan Tribble. All of those guys could go in the first round, and will be selected no later than the middle of the second.
by Or Moyal on Jan 22, 2008 6:12 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
anything can happen
after the NFL Combine. Some of these projected 2nd and 3rd rounds CBs could creep into the first round based on workouts. These players are overdrafted because of that. Those are the players we have to be cautious of.
For example, Matt Jones of Jacksonville was grossly overdrafed based on his 40 time at the combine. Subsequently, he moved into the first round. Look how that turned out.
by Cowboys81 on Jan 22, 2008 6:24 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
thanks for the insight
as many other I agree this is a top priority, and it will be interesting to see who we end up with.
by scottmaui on Jan 22, 2008 6:02 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
the REASON the CB position is a priority
He's still a usable second corner, but at 31 he won't be for much longer. While not a liability, he gets beaten fairly easily by most receivers who exhibit a semblance of speed
we need young guys who can play the game
it not Reeves or Jones IMO
Draft Two new CB - Leodis McKelvin or Reggie Smith at 1a
in the 2 we could get
CB Dwight Lowery – 6- 1 #190 San Jose St
CB Terrell Thomas 6-1 #200 USC
CB Charles Godfrey 6-1 #210 Iowa
my draft
1a CB Reggie Smith OK - Mckelvin
1b RB Felix Jones 6 #200 - Mendenhall
2 CB Dwight Lowery – 6- 1 #190 San Jose St
CB Terrell Thomas 6-1 #200 USC
CB Charles Godfrey 6-1 #210 Iowa
by Arkcowboys on Jan 22, 2008 6:11 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
I'm on board with Ark...we need 2 CB's
Although I am leaning more towards Leodis McKelvin than Reggie Smith.
Although Reggie Smith wouldn't be a bad consilation, he can play various positions....3rd CB, eventual starter at FS.
I really can't imagine Felix Jones lasting till 28th pick,...we may need to move up alittle to secure him, our first, a fifth, and a conditional 09 pick.
2nd round would produce a nice CB as well, Lowery may be there at our spot (61) overall. Terrell Thomas will be gone in the first 50 picks.
If our targeted guy is there in the 50 pick range, we should jump up in the second to get him, our second and a 6th or something.
by BoyzRback07 on Jan 22, 2008 7:19 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Good post
One of the best diaries I've ever read.
Like I've told many friends, Reeves is not nearly as bad as every announcer makes him seem, especially when compared to other 3rd corners or Nate Jones. He does give up catches, but rarely gets beat deep and rarely has help over the top that many other 3rd corners in the league get.
by JacquesReevesForMVP on Jan 22, 2008 7:24 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Are you serious?
The reason:
He does give up catches, but rarely gets beat deep
Is because he gives them a nine yard cushion,and he's never in position to make a play on the ball.He really is as bad as they say....Sorry...
by TrueBlue24 on Jan 22, 2008 7:29 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Good work
However I highly disagree with your assessment on Reeves:
Reeves is not terrible, every team has a third corner. He's a nice piece to have, and should be retained.
Reeves proved to be a target for every QB we faced in the last quarter of the season.He needs to be replaced.
by TrueBlue24 on Jan 22, 2008 7:26 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Nah, I wouldn't replace him
I would, however add another guy and move him down to where Nate Jones is now, leaving Jones as your #5. If you've got Jacques Reeves as your fourth corner, you're not doing badly.
by Or Moyal on Jan 22, 2008 7:51 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Roger That, TB24
I don't want Jacques Reeves on the roster next season.
by kcbrett5 on Jan 23, 2008 9:39 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
why does
Reeves get all the bad press on the Giants game when it was Henry's (and Ellis) missed tackle that led Directly to a TD. Reeves facemask gave them a first down but the missed tackle led to a 50 yard score, an easy TD for the Giant. Gave them momentum and nullified our long drives.
I can't figure out why Henry gets a pass and everyone complains about Reeves in that game.
by cosbie84 on Jan 23, 2008 12:58 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Not just talking about that game, but also...
And guess what?
They always succeed, and yes, Reeves usually makes the tackle... but after the catch where he gives the WR about a five yard cushion.
In the playoff loss to the Giants, how many times did Eli complete passes to Steve Smith to keep drives alive? Anyone care to take a wild stab at who's man that was?
If you guessed Jacques Reeves, you da winner!
Regarding Henry (no pun intended btw), yes, he blew plays in our last game, but he's also made a boatload of plays over the course of the season.
Not giving Anthony Henry a free pass either, however. Like I've said time and time again, this was a TEAM loss.
by kcbrett5 on Jan 23, 2008 3:19 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Yep
Not just based on one game. It happened all through the season. And when the opposition states up front that they will attack Reeves whenever they get a chance, you have got to get him off the team. I'm sorry, I think some other team will pick him up and he can try to stick on their roster. But I'd hate to see him back as our 3rd CB option next season.
by APerfectStar on Jan 23, 2008 7:40 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Correction to what I stated in my post
I suggested that Reeves was a useful enough commodity to be brought back, but now I'm looking around at a lot of free agent rankings-and I've seen him as high as 4th on the list of cornerbacks. If some GM is blind enough to agree with that, there is not a snowball's chance in hell Reeves gets an offer of that caliber from JJ.
by Or Moyal on Jan 23, 2008 10:37 PM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Great Work
I agree.
Our offense is exceptional, we need to replace JJ but history shows that is a 3rd or 4th rd task.
We should take 2 CB's in our first 3 picks. 1st round CB's can contribute immediately (see Aaron Ross drafted #20 last year) and are cheaper than Free Agents. If we draft 2 we should get one solid CB.
We need better corners to compete with the Pats and Colts. Plus it having a bevy of cover guys gives more room to pin ears back and blitz.
I would love to see us go after several DB's in the first 3 rounds.
by 325424 on Jan 22, 2008 7:44 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Mike Mayock from NFL Network has Leodis McKelvin
rated as the best CB in the draft ahead of guys such as Mike Jenkins and Talib because he has elite cover skills and is a great return guy.
The only weakness he sees in McKelvin is that he doesn't have good ball skills and doesn't come up with the INT when he's in position to make it.
I'm hoping we make him a Cowboy on April 26 with our first pick at #22.
by Terry on Jan 22, 2008 8:33 PM CST reply actions 0 recs
Great diary Or Moyal
At least one of the following CB's needs to be from the first.
Aqib Talib
McKelvin
Reggie Smith
It sounds like D.Rogers-Cromartie might be a good pick up in the second.
I don't see a FA CB being brought in. I think Florence wants to start and be paid as a starter. That won't happen in Dallas.
by APerfectStar on Jan 23, 2008 2:43 AM CST reply actions 0 recs
Rodgers-Cromartie
I agree entirely. I don't like pronouncing players as 'sleepers' in general; I think knowledge has spread to a point where if you're pronounced a 'sleeper' you're not so much a 'sleeper' anymore. Just like Vladimir Guerrerro was 'The Most Underrated Player in Baseball' for so long that people started ranking him up there with A-Rod and Pujols.
However... If Cromartie's physical gifts are as great as some say, he could be picked far higher than some projections have him now. The dude's supposedly a freak.
If we could get him in the second round, I would be beyond elated.
by Or Moyal on Jan 23, 2008 7:46 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs
Is he related to Antonio??
by Terry on Jan 23, 2008 10:05 AM CST up reply actions 0 recs



















