Mid-Season Grades

I have to preface this post by saying that I got the idea from listening to the Randy Galloway radio show (yeah, I know, but he is not nearly as bad in radio form.)  They were going all of the starters this year and giving them grades on their performances this year.  There were a lot of the grades that they were giving out that I didn't agree with (big suprise) but it made me really think about what grades I would give out.  So here is my list.

  • A's are given if the player has consistently met and exceeded my expectations for the majority of the first 8 games of this season.
  • B's are given if the player has met expectations or exceeded expectations, but may have had several "off" games.
  • C's are given if the player has been average and just barely meeting expectations.
  • D's are given if the player has played poorly and not lived up to expectations at all.
  • F's are given if the player hasplayed far below expectations.


  • Romo- I give him a B or a B+.  I think Romo has been playing well, but has had a couple of games where he hasn't played quite to the level of last season.  However, I think that it's hard to tell how much has been Romo and how much has been the O-line.
  • Barber- I would give Marion a B.  He's played pretty well, but he's had a few games where he's struggled to get yardage.  Again, not sure how much is Marion and how much is the O-line.
  • Witten- A.  Need I say more?
  • T.O.- At this point I would have to give him a C- or D+.  I still think that TO can be a beast, but the press coverage and double teams have been killing him this year.  He can not consistently get open.  Again, is this a product of the crappy O-line not giving the QB enough time?
  • Crayton- I had a hard time grading Crayton.  Based on expectations I would give him a C.  I didn't have high expectations for him, but I don't want to give the impression that he is playing better than TO.  Still I think a C is fair.  He hasn't shown up in a lot of games, but he has had some clutch performances.
  • Adams- Flozell deserves a big fat F.  He has been a human turnstile this year.  I hope that this isn't Flozell taking a break after getting his big contract, but I don't see how his game can drop off so much in such a short time frame.
  • Proctor- This is another hard one to grade.  I didn't have high expectations for Proctor, but I would probably have to say a F or D-.  I think that Kosier being out is the major problem with the line.  While not everyone is coming through the line at LG, I think he has thrown off the rhythm of the entire line.
  • Gurode- Probably a C or C+.  He hasn't been terrible, but he's had a few bad games and bad snaps.
  • Davis- I am giving Bigg a B.  He has played pretty well overall, but I don't think anyone on the line deserves any great grades.
  • Colombo- After the TB game, I am giving Colombo a B+.  While he was beaten badly in Arizona, he has played good and shown some heart on a unit that needs a leader.


  • Ratliff- The Rat has been playing lights out and definetely deserves an A.
  • Spears- While Spears hasn't been playing great, he has definetely done more than I've expected.  I would have to give him a B- or C+.
  • Canty- I am really disappointed in Canty this year.  After showing tons of promise last season, he has shown almost nothing this year.  He is getting a D.
  • Ware- Another beast, deserving of his A.
  • James- Bradie has been pretty decent overall.  I'll give him a B-.
  • Thomas- Zach has been playing better than Ayodele in every facet of the game.  He seems to sometimes get pushed around in the run game, but I think he deserves a B.
  • Ellis- After playing at a pro bowl level last year, he hasn't done a whole lot this year.  I'm giving him a C.
  • Hamlin- He hasn't been making a lot of big plays, but has been pretty decent and our QB in the secondary.  I give him a B.
  • Henry- A big fat F.  He has been a liability in the secondary this season and even once he get's healthy, I would prefer to leave one of the rookies in the starting lineup to get them meaningful playing time.


  • F. Jones- I almost gave Felix an A for his work so far, but felt it wasn't fair as he has only seen playing time in 6 games, and one of those he didn't get any carries at RB.
  • Bennett- I like what I've seen from Tellus so far and he's had a few good plays for us.  The next game should tell quite a bit because I don't see Witten playing much if at all.
  • Scandrick/Jenkins- I think both of these guys have played pretty well so far and have been more impressed with Scandrick's work so far.  Again, I think this next game especially will be telling as to how they can hold up under the pressure

Well, I know that was a long winded post, but I felt like it would be interesting to put everything down on paper.  Some of the grades I gave I don't feel 100% postive about, but let me know what grades you guys feel everyone deserves.

Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Blogging The Boys

You must be a member of Blogging The Boys to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Blogging The Boys. You should read them.

Join Blogging The Boys

You must be a member of Blogging The Boys to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Blogging The Boys. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.