Will the Dallas Cowboys draft an offensive lineman in the first round?
A few of the so-called "experts" have put together some mock drafts that have Dallas taking an offensive lineman in the first round of this year's draft. At first I was incredulous, especially seeing that these mocks came well after the Cowboys had re-signed Flozell Adams. The Cowboys will be fielding the same starting offensive lineman two years in a row for the first time in a long while this year. The Cowboys also have three Pro Bowl linemen and it is arguable that Marc Columbo could have gone as well. Yet for some reason this scenario has been picking away at my football subconscious until I cannot ignore it any longer. Might the Cowboys draft an offensive lineman in the first round? Well, I think they could. Now before everyone goes and starts breaking out the straight jackets for me, there are some sound arguments to support this crazed notion.
The draft could just work out that way. If the Cowboys end up signing Adam Jones, which is becoming a distinct possibility, then the overwhelming need to rush out and grab a corner with the #22 pick may no longer exist. If Jones is a Cowboy, Dallas would only need to look for depth at corner and could wait until the second round to do so. Dallas also is in need of a running back to work behind Marion Barber. While some mock drafts have the Cowboys waiting until #28 to pick a RB, if Jonathan Stewart falls to #22 the Cowboys would be more than happy to scoop him up in a heartbeat. So now the Cowboys have picked a running back and would not need to draft a 3rd down corner in the first round. I will also contend that the Cowboys will not draft a receiver in the first round. The team is confident in the receiving corps they have now and it just does not seem they will go for one early in the draft. So what to do with the #28 pick?
The Cowboys will go for the best player available or trade the pick away, depending on who exactly is the BPA. Some mocks have Branden Albert sitting there as a late round draft choice and if he is still there, he might be one the Cowboys would draft. Albert is a natural guard but also has the ability to play right tackle. Albert would be a safe pick and one who the Cowboys could use in the future as a starting guard or offensive tackle. I'm sure some of you are still thinking I'm crazy, saying to yourself that the Cowboys already have good to great tackles and guards. That brings me to the next point:
Marc Columbo may not be a Dallas Cowboy in 2009. Columbo was signed to a two year deal last offseason and will become a free agent following the 2008 season. There are no guarantees that he returns. Dallas has Flozell Adams, Andre Gurode and Leonard Davis all locked into long term contracts with Kyle Kosier having three years remaining on his. Terence Newman, Terrell Owens and Demarcus Ware will also be looking for new contracts, as well as tendered free agents Marion Barber and Cris Canty and franchised safety Ken Hamlin. There will be just too many mouths looking for a payday and someone will be the odd man out. With all that money already locked into the offensive line, Columbo might be the man the Cowboys let go. If that happens, are there any backups on the current roster the Cowboys are sure can step in and take over at tackle? Right now, I would say that answer is no.
Let's say the Cowboys were 100% percent confident in their young offensive linemen; re-signing Flozell Adams would not have been such a high priority. Adams is one of the leagues best left tackles but he is also getting older. The Cowboys could easily have let him go and counted on one of the backups to step in; this would have freed up cap space and possibly allowes the Cowboys to have made a play for some of the free agents they passed on. Yet the Cowboys worked overtime to get a deal done and that could be a tell on just how they feel about the backups. Doug Free and James Marten have only had a year to develop as NFL players and it typically takes a few years for offensive lineman to reach their full potential. Yet if the Cowboys were to let Columbo go next year, is Doug Free, James Marten or Pat McQuistan able to step up in his place? McQuistan is more of a guard although he has played tackles in spot relief duty. Free and Marten are still unknowns.
If the Cowboys wanted to take the safe route and play for the future, drafting an offensive lineman in the first round is a safe move to make if one is there at the #28 pick. Granted, many pieces would have to fall into place for this scenario to work out perfectly, but the draft is never an exact science. Jerry Jones has never drafted an offensive lineman in the first round however, and hasn't drafted one in the second round since 2004. If certain things happen the Cowboys might be looking at the possibility of drafting an offensive lineman in the first round. Don't be surprised if it happens.
0 recs |
25
comments
Read Related
Comments
I dont buy it!
Even if ther not sure about 1 of those guys being able to handle LT, I think there would not be as much dought in them taking over at RT.
by Badknees on Mar 22, 2008 9:06 PM CDT 0 recs
no chance of an offensive linemen being taken
in the first round by the cowboys, Free, McQ, Marten on the roster, sorry its not happening.
McQuistan is the swing tackle, not better suited as a guard, imo.
It's all going to depend on what happens before dallas is on the board, if a top rated corner is there they like, I dont care if Pacman is signed as a free agent or traded for, dallas still needs to take a top cover corner, I think this upcoming season will be Henry's last year in a cowboy uniform. So even if Pacman is on the team, with another young corner to develop, like Cason, Dallas would be set the next year if Pacman works out and Henry is cut after the 2008 season.
If a running back or corner isn't the value on the cowboy board at 22, look for dallas to trade down or put a call into detroit to see the availability of Williams if philly didn't do that trade when they were on the board at 19. I'd rather give Detroit our 22nd pick for a proven receiver instead of drafting any of these receivers in this draft in the first round.
by Deke on Mar 22, 2008 9:08 PM CDT 0 recs
Plus, Pacman's uncertainty
Even if they get Pacman, another reason they will want depth is the uncertainty that comes with him. If he pulls an even slightly stupid move he could be suspended, and the team will need a decent corner as insurance behind him. If he is there, the need to get one in the first round might not be as high, but I would think it would still be among the top priorities.
by scottmaui on
Mar 23, 2008 1:22 AM CDT
up
0 recs
No chance agreed
If Colombo is not resigned his replacement is on the team. It will be either Free or Mcquistan.
by Cowboys81 on
Mar 23, 2008 10:29 AM CDT
up
0 recs
no way will Albert last until #28
If there is truly a no brainer in the first rd, its the Steelers taking Albert at #23. Only way this won't happen is if one of the stud tackles slides down this far, which is extremely doubtful.
by Terry on Mar 22, 2008 9:20 PM CDT 0 recs
I think Seattle might take Albert
Steelers signed Justin Hartwig and moved Sean Mahan to guard, so they might go a different direction, might see Pittsburgh take a receiver in the first round.
by Deke on
Mar 22, 2008 9:29 PM CDT
up
0 recs
I strongly disagree, those OL you mentioned
are garbage, they need some real talent on the OL which is by far and away their biggest need.
WR isn't a need because they have Ward, Holmes and Washington.
I think Pittsburgh taking an OL is pretty much a guarantee unless all the 1st rd studs are gone.
by Terry on
Mar 22, 2008 9:36 PM CDT
up
0 recs
I read that same report Deke did
They discussed Big Ben wanting a tall receiver like Sweed, Kelly, or Hardy.
But you live in the area so you probably hear a lot more about what's going on.
by APerfectStar on
Mar 22, 2008 10:02 PM CDT
up
0 recs
they'll draft a tall receiver, but not until
the middle to later rounds.
by Terry on
Mar 22, 2008 10:34 PM CDT
up
0 recs
Good points, Brandon
And I am glad you poointed out Brandan Albert. We're conveniently located one spot ahead of Pittsburgh with our first pick, so could grab him if we felt the need. In what situation would I do so? If the talent available is either a reach at one of the three premium positions, or available at positions where we don't need them (i.e. Keith Rivers, as has occured in the BTB mock).
If we can't find a player we like at 22, I expect Jerry to try trading the selection. If he can't get fair value, I hope he gives Albert a long, hard look. Kyle Kosier is arguably the weak spot of our offense, and fortifying the line with Albert for the immediate future at left guard and then at right tackle could make our line formidable almost to the extent it was in the early 90s.
by BudLight on Mar 22, 2008 9:49 PM CDT 0 recs
you can get good Guards
in the third and fourth round of this deep draft, we aren't drafting a guard in the first round, Kosier is a very solid guard, gets to the second level and thee best pulling linemen on the team and at the price we're paying him, its a steal.. very under rated on our O-line.
by Deke on
Mar 22, 2008 10:08 PM CDT
up
0 recs
this is the weakest draft for guards.....
an upgrade over Kosier would be welcomed with open arms....
that being said...I don't see a chance at all of us grabbing an offensive lineman in the first round.
by BoyzRback07 on
Mar 23, 2008 1:41 AM CDT
up
0 recs
He he
I was interested to see what you guys' response would be.
I'm not sitting here as a proponent of this move. And I think that it is very likely not to happen, especially since Jerry has never drafted an o lineman in the first round.
by Brandon W on Mar 22, 2008 11:38 PM CDT 0 recs
That's the stat
that I was going to bring up. Dubba J (rightly) believes that quality lineman can be found deeper in the draft.
However, I whole-heartedly agree with your analysis of the Columbo situation. I also think (as much as it would suck) Jerry is prepared to let Canty walk after this season as well. Ware, Owens, Newman, Hamlin and Barber ... that's five Pro Bowlers right there, and all will want long-term (or just multi-year in Owens' case) contracts that will no doubt break the bank. I hope against hope that 2009 is uncapped and Dallas can frontload a lot of contracts during that time. However, assuming we clear out some trash and sign those five, I think Dallas lets Canty walk, moves Ratliff to DE and Re-signs Tank to a multi-year deal.
I disagree though with your status report of the young lineman. I think Dallas has confidence in them ... they just need another year to develop. I think it's a two-horse race between McQ and Free to start at RT in 2009; if Free wins the job, he plays there for a year or two, gets his bearings and replaces Flozell mid-contract (there's no way he plays that baby out in full; I don't know the terms of Adams' deal, but I'm guessing there's a crucial roster bonus sometime in between the 2009-2011 seasons).
With all the quality lineman we have right now, I don't see who we'd cut if Jerry drafted a lineman ... especially in the first round. With the personnel we have, it just isn't a concern in the long or short term. WR, RB, CB, either S, NT and even QB (we need a backup who isn't geriatric after all) are much more pressing issues in this draft. If we draft an o-lineman before Round 4, if at all, I will be surprised.
by no1cowboysfan on
Mar 23, 2008 2:09 AM CDT
up
0 recs
Off topic
Congratulations on being chosen by the 5th down as guest bloggers. What I read was more enlightening and insightfull than what the national media churns out. As true fans I think we know our own teams better than the press.
by giants fan since 57 on Mar 23, 2008 5:56 AM CDT 0 recs
Thanks giants fan
I really appreciate that. Brandon and Tuna Helper did a great job of providing content for The Fifth Down! And I agree, we do know our teams better than most of the national press.
by Dave Halprin (Grizz) on
Mar 23, 2008 10:09 AM CDT
up
0 recs
I agree Grizz...there is no doubt....
And I'm telling everyone right now....Our opinions might not mean a thing...BUT...I assure you Cowboy reps do read this blog site...With thousands of eyes, and hard core fans watching every single play, researching several draft, mock, and nfl sites daily, they do log this data to gaugetheir own, and other teams needs, projected draft strategies, etc.. etc..I have no doubt, as I have seen write ups, and programs discussing the matter...hey almost have to get some feedback from post derived from team blog sites...It's like having
thousands of unpaid arm chair scouts at their diposal.I know it is a fact that they have personel that go through daily mock sites, teams sites, etc. etc...They try to comprise their own team boards utilizing info from various sites and sources...
SW keep it up....your dream pick may come true...
by BoyzRback07 on
Mar 23, 2008 10:55 AM CDT
up
0 recs
I think it would be less "WOW" and more "WTF?"
I agree with your reasoning that for the long haul they have to start stockpiling O-linemenm but they'll do that with later picks as they usually have. Nice departure from the usual, though.
by dunkman on Mar 23, 2008 8:14 AM CDT 0 recs
Not so fast my friends....check it out...........
Although I find it highly unlikely they'll go O Lineman in the first..Don't for a minute think it's not possible. I was over at http://www.draftdaddy.com , checking out Pro Day results...Had interest in Vandy's Pro Day cuz some draft sites have us looking at Earl Bennett / WR with our 2nd rounder, who I'm not interested by the way, not that he sucks, but I don't see him being any better than Crayton, he's more of a possesion type like Crayton, not a speed merchant, deep threat like Glenn....I found this very interesting tidbit while reading the thread....
Vanderbilt (March 21)
Twenty NFL teams were present, including seven offensive line coaches, one wide receivers coach, three linebackers coaches and Panthers general manager Marty Hurney. The players worked out outdoors on FieldTurf.
» WR Earl Bennett (5-11 ¾, 206): Had a 32-inch vertical jump and kept his combine numbers for everything else. Broncos starting quarterback and former Commodore, Jay Cutler, threw 22 passes to Bennett during the workout and Bennett did not drop a single ball.
» OL Chris Williams (6-6 ¼, 320): Did position drills and kept his numbers from the workout. The Cowboys sent a two-person video crew to tape his workout.
Chris Williams would be one fine pick up, if he were to fall into the late first round..With Columbo's contract ending after this season, picking up Williams to start at Right Tackle next year may be high on their minds...OR do they stand pat and pay Columbo a 5-7 million/per salary to continueon, or just fork over the spot to one of our existing back ups, who obviously don't have the same talent as a Chris Williams...interesting...I do feel with the signing of Flo...It all but seals the fate of us not resigning Columbo....that is just way way too much free agent money locked into the O Line...Chris Williams would eventually transfer over to Left Tackle in 3 years, Free to Right Tackle.
On another not from Pro Day's....Dallas also sent a two man film crew to the workout of Dominique Rodgers Cromartie...
>(please Jerry, this is your WOW factor pick) .....I say trade both our first rounders to New England and grab him...
by BoyzRback07 on
Mar 23, 2008 8:40 AM CDT
up
0 recs
It's possible
but unlikely, given the two glaring needs they did not address in FA - CB and RB, with WR becoming a possible issue next year.
That said, I still believe that championship teams are built from the line of scrimmage out. You only have to look at the Giants to see how far a team with those two strengths can go. So I would never be disappointed in drafting a lineman on either side of the ball.
by dunkman on
Mar 23, 2008 10:00 AM CDT
up
0 recs
Interesting.
It's an unlikely scenario, but I never rule out anything as far as the draft is concerned. You never know...
by Nelson on Mar 23, 2008 9:13 AM CDT 0 recs
I'm just glad the Cowboys are keeping all options
open and doing their homework for any scenario that might play out in the 1st round of the draft.
If all their targets are gone at #28 and they cannot find a trade partner, I wouldn't have a problem if they nabbed a top rated lineman.
by APerfectStar on Mar 23, 2008 11:32 AM CDT 0 recs
If Albert could play center then it would be more
of a possibility. Everyone saw how much we missed Gurode (crazy snaps aside) and despite the public comments by the coaches I think a center will come the second day. We have 3 young tackle prospects=and I do not know WHERE you got the idea that McQ was more of a guard= BP, Sparano were both very high on him. AS A TACKLE.
by burmafrd1944 on Mar 23, 2008 11:51 AM CDT 0 recs
McQuistan has been moved around
Last offseason there was speculation that McQuistan would be moved permanently inside to guard, then in training camp he became the backup swing tackle.
McQuistan has played as guard and tackle. If anyone is the heir apparent to right tackle, it would be Doug Free who the Cowboys are pretty high on but needs more development.
Just ask Grizz.
by Brandon W on
Mar 23, 2008 2:17 PM CDT
up
0 recs










