NFL Power rankings - Week 10 - Final Edition
Here's the early edition of our weekly power ranking roundup heading into week 10. Special preview guest this week: The Packers.
As usual, the final update should be up by Wednesday night.
1. Major Media Networks & Affiliates
SportingNews.com: 6th (+1). "Wade Phillips is smiling these days. His seat is not so hot, but his team definitely is."
Pete Prisco at CBSSports.com: 7th (+2)."Dallas is suddenly a hot team in first place. Where did all those problems go? The defense is really coming on. How do you contain Miles Austin?"
NationalFootballPost.com: 7th (+2). "Tony Romo looks like the best quarterback in the NFC East and he has a first-place team to show for it."
Michael Silver at Yahoo Sports: 8th (+2). "Is Miles Austin too good to be true?"
NFL.com's Brain Trust of Experts: 8th (+-0). Two Cowboys make it to Vic Carucci's top five:
- Top Five Defensive Players: "No. 4: Jay Ratliff, DT, Dallas. He led a sterling performance by the Cowboys' defensive line vs. the Eagles. Besides helping to stop a diving Donovan McNabb short on fourth-and-1, he was credited with five tackles, two sacks, and a pair of tackles for loss."
- Top Five Coaches: "No. 4: Wade Phillips, Dallas. Can we put to rest, once and for all, the silly talk that this guy doesn't know what he's doing and that the Cowboys must replace him as their coach" Amen.
[update] Fox Sports: 8th (+2). "First Half Blessing: Duh. No-brainer here, as WR Miles Austin has come out of nowhere to seemingly save the Cowboys' season and possibly Wade Phillips' job over the last four games. First Half Curse: Until Austin's emergence, the Curse of T.O. lingered with an offense that couldn't find itself. Looking forward, Tony Romo now only faces his own cursed Decembers of the past."
ESPN: 8th (+-0). "A maturer Cowboys team is atop the NFC East. (Clayton)"
[update] SI.com lets loose with a flurry of Cowboys related stuff this week:
[update] Don Banks' Power Rankings: 8th (+1). "There are a pretty fair group of 6-2 teams in the league right now, and I wanted to jack the Cowboys up into the middle of them after their gutsy win at Philly Sunday night. But there's plenty of time left for them to climb, and the Broncos did beat Dallas head-to-head in Week 4. If the Cowboys can get past Green Bay on the road in a rather tricky game this week, they're well-positioned to roll into December at 9-2 and then take their chances with the month that has bedeviled them for most of this decade." He also weighed in with these pearls of wisdom in his Mid-Season Report:
- "Best performance under the gun -- Tony Romo, QB, Dallas: They were all but writing Romo's obituary after a Week 4 loss at Denver dropped Dallas to 2-2, with seemingly every former Cowboys star shy of Duane Thomas coming out of the woodwork to critique the quarterback's inconsistent game. But one four-game winning streak later, the first-place Cowboys are being led to some pretty big things by their efficient (one interception in four games), big-play-making quarterback."
- "Breakout player of the year -- Miles Austin, WR, Dallas: Who needs T.O.? Not the Cowboys. Not when they've got M.A. In the four starts he has made since replacing Patrick Crayton in the Dallas lineup, Austin has exploded for six touchdowns, almost all of them of the long ball variety."
- Peter King in MMQB: 6th (+5)."I thought long and hard about putting Jay Ratliff on my Midseason All-Pro Team, and I'm even more of a Ratliff guy after watching last night. Two sacks, five tackles, constant disruption. That's a franchise defensive tackle, even if he doesn't have the pedigree." Peter King also has an extended piece on a potentially season-altering win for Dallas.
- Jim Trotter has this to say in his 2nd half predictions: "The Cowboys will be one-and-done in the playoffs. With all due respect to Cowboys fans, I just can't get excited about their sudden surge to the top of the NFC East. That little thing called "December" keeps popping into my head. QB Tony Romo has lost five of his last seven starts during the Christmas month, throwing nearly twice as many interceptions (11) as touchdowns (six) in those games; my crystal ball says his struggles will continue down the stretch this year." Well Jim, your crystal ball ain't so crystal clear.
2. Blogs & Other Media
[update] ColdHardFootballFacts.com: 6th (+3). "The Cowboys’ starting offensive line has 540 combined career starts, most in the league. But that hasn’t stopped them from being whistled for 19 flags in eight games, well above NFL average. But they do rank No. 6 in our Offensive Hog Index."
ProFootballWeekly: 7th (+2). "Austin proves it's not important how many passes you are thrown."
SBNation: 7th (+2). "Just when you thought it was safe to ignore the Cowboys, the Ewing Theory strikes with a vengeance. Absent the drama that is TO, the Cowboys have quietly begun clicking on both sides of the ball, climbing to the top of the NFC East standings."
Mike Florio at ProFootballTalk.com: 7th (+4). "No matter what Tony Romo does the rest of the regular season, the pressure will be crippling when he plays his next playoff game."
Weii.com: 8th (+1). "There is a lot of confidence in the Cowboys locker room. That is what a four-game winning streak will do for a team. In this stretch of wins, Dallas has managed to beat two solid teams in the Falcons and Eagles. If Tony Romo can continue to protect the football, this team can compete with the best in the NFC."
Walter Football: 8th (+5). "I'm not going to praise the Cowboys for their win over the Eagles. I'm not going to say anything about their 6-2 record. If you want to hear analysis like this, tune into ESPN. Winning in November has never been an issue for the Cowboys. They have to prove to me that they can avoid choking in December and January. Once they come up big late in the year, I'll give them credit."
Zac Wassink at AssociatedContent is missed this weeks deadline.
3. Statictics & Computer based rankings.
tom slick publishes his Rankings on SBNation's The Falcoholic: 4th (+-0). He currently weighs offensive and defensive points scored/allowed relative to all other teams to determine his rankings.
[update] FootballOutsiders: 5th (+4). Offense ranked No. 5, Defense No. 20, Special Teams No. 5. These guys adjust their rankings for opponent strength and have a long long and increasingly obvious history as notorious Eagles (No. 2) & Patriots (No. 1) lovers.
Great Blue North Draft Report: 6th (+1). This site calculates rankings by first round draft selection order based on own and opponent W/L record if the season were to end today.
[update] AdvancedNFLstats: 6th (+-0). Offense ranked No. 2, Defense ranked No. 24. This ranking model includes offensive and defensive passing and running efficiency, offensive turnover rates, defensive interception rates, and team penalty rates.
WhatIfSports: Cowboys 6th (-1). These guys simulate every possible matchup in the NFL 100 times, and use the winning percentages from those nearly 50,000 games to evaluate every team, with updated rosters and depth charts.
[update] Covers.com: 8th (+2). "Dallas is playing its best football of the season and the victory in Philadelphia can be huge for confidence. It has to be on upset alert in Green Bay this week."
Jeff Sagarin's NFL rankings: 10th (+3). These are rankings based on W/L record, points differential and schedule strength.
Here's how the NFC East - and our next opponent, the Packers - fared:
For a summary of all NFL teams using some of the same rankings, go to NFLpowerranks.com
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
74 comments
|
7 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
About Time!!!
Been waiting all day.
Oh, and first!!!
lol, yeah, already hard at work on the next nuggets, 2 nailed down so far and counting. But the best thing is I already have the Cheerleader pic (naturally, this takes up most of my time when “researching” the post) – she’s a stunner and the longer I look at it the more I am convinced she is winking at me …
by One.Cool.Customer on Nov 10, 2009 2:28 PM CST up reply actions
LOL
btw… thanks for the ptp, I’ll be testing it out this weekend :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
LUKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Whereya been brother?
Never wrestle with a pig. You both get dirty and the pig loves it.
dunk, honestly it's a long sordid story that started with chasing a rabbit down a hole...
well… it did start with chasing … and of course some “like rabbits” imagery … and without trying any kind of obvious “lost in the hole” metaphor … well, you get the idea :)
… throw in a general disgust with the quickly lightening bandwagon of nay-sayers, and I’ve found myself reading far more than posting. I actually wrote up a little fan-post with a decidedly optimistic slant, and wanted to post it before this last game … but, well… see above.
I must say, there was one day I read the 100s of posts with the “CTRL-Find” set on DUNK :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
![]()
I can see for miles and miles and miles and miles and miles...
by Aaron Novinger on Nov 13, 2009 8:28 AM CST up reply actions
I take it I'm the SNOOP in this scene... yea, I'm cool like that
btw … nice signatures you two… and to think of all the clamoring for an early WR draft pick … oh how times have changed!!!
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
Woodstock is Snoopy's inspiration.
I don’t think any other characters see him other than Snoop—much like Big Bird’s Mr. Snuffleupagus.
I can see for miles and miles and miles and miles and miles...
by Aaron Novinger on Nov 14, 2009 9:03 AM CST up reply actions
Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait...
Something’s gone terribly wrong here …
hmmm… on the other hand … me in a metaphysical role?
Yea, I can role with that … the mythical figure? Me? Okay …
If we’re dreaming here, can I have a small but growing harem? and … and … and … lots of whiskey… yea, yea, yea :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
That whole rabbit thing made me wonder...
And if you go chasing rabbits
And you know you’re going to fall
Tell ’em a hookah smoking caterpillar
Has given you the call
Call Alice
When she was just small
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
Grace Slick
mmmm…Goth before it was cool.
He who knows nothing is closer to the truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods and errors. - Thomas Jefferson
Wow, this is almost gettin' heavy
:)
I must admit, I miss me some BTB company :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
+ a million
But this place has become home.
He who knows nothing is closer to the truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods and errors. - Thomas Jefferson
I got to hear her belt this out
in Seattle in the 70s. It was (and still is) stuck in the 60s and Grace still had the voice. Man what a concert, They went nuts.
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
If i'm not mistaken..
OCC mentions a couple of weeks ago that the Walter guy is actually from Philly… and considered possibly removing him from his posts :)
Yep
but now I’m leaving him in – just out of spite.
by One.Cool.Customer on Nov 12, 2009 6:12 AM CST up reply actions
It'll be a thing of beauty to have the Iggs in their top 5 and watching the playoffs from afar :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
Thanks for the post.....
Great read as always. Helps get me through the afternoon work grind too.
Looks like the critics are coming around on this team.
Hope that is not a bad thing.
Anomoly............Finally here.........
Who the heck is Tom Slick?
The Cowboys beat the Iggles, AT HOME, and he still has them rated above the Cowboys? What game was HE watching.
yeah is that right? two teams played head to head ranked 3 and 4, 4 beats 3 in their own house and their ranks remain the same? lol i guess it didnt count.
by DavidLaFleur on Nov 10, 2009 3:04 PM CST up reply actions
LOL
My rankings are stats-based, don’t take them too literally or personally! You can learn how they’re calculated here.
Unless I’m reading the data wrong, I think my rankings grade the Cowboys higher than every other method listed this week! Still, 4th place (an eyelash out of 3rd) is not enough for some people, LOL! I’m having visions of Rodney Dangerfield tugging at his necktie, muttering “Tough Room!”
You gain tremendous respect for sticking your neck out around here :)
And good point … #4 aint all that bad!
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
Thanks, I just hate misconceptions
There’s a huge difference between stats algorithms, and those “composite poll” rankings that largely march in lockstep with W-L records. Cheers!
Statistics & Computer based rankings
The reason why these rankings are included is because they are not opinion driven pieces like all the others. You can argue whether the numbers make sense, but not about the math that gets them there.
Tom uses points for and points against, and unfortunately, that gives the Eagles a tiny edge on the Cowboys.
by One.Cool.Customer on Nov 10, 2009 3:05 PM CST up reply actions
Good stuff OCC
Sagarin may need to be replaced on your NASDAQ top 22. We win our 4th in a row and go (3) while the Giants loose their 4th in a row and go (3) too? Must be one heck of a curve he grades on.
Drinking the Blue Kool-Aid since 1980. "Ohhhhhh yeeeaaaaahhhh!"
I won’t pretend I have a clue how Sagarin calculates his rankings, but strength of schedule obviously plays a part and ours has been rather soft, relative to some of the teams ahead of us.
by One.Cool.Customer on Nov 10, 2009 3:10 PM CST up reply actions
What Trotter doesn't realize ...
is that he’s mistakenly picked up a snow globe, instead of his crystal ball, for his prognostication.
I want these guys to have reservations about the Cowboys. I want them to
devalue the team and demand proof that this isn’t a flash-in-the-pan. I want the Cowboys to play with chips on their shoulders and with something to prove. Great motivators.
Yep
the only cheese I want them eating is Packer cheese.
That didn’t sound right.
Never wrestle with a pig. You both get dirty and the pig loves it.
I tried Spam for the first time in like 20 years yesterday.
It still belongs tucked away in its own folder.
I can see for miles and miles and miles and miles and miles...
by Aaron Novinger on Nov 13, 2009 4:18 PM CST up reply actions
This is the dessert of the posts for me
As always thanks to OCC.
(And to the Walters football rankings moron, as always, go blank yourself)
You can't stop Patrick Crayton, you can only hope to contain him.
Whats the guy
from Whatifsports smoking. How do you win a game like that on the road and lose a spot in the rankings. BTW a cheerleader or two wouldn’t hurt this post either. Great Stuff OCC.
#7 in Green Elevator
another one you might consider adding is the “Green Elevator” on ESPN Football Today podcast with Jeremy Green.
He has the Cowboys at #7 this week.
http://sports.espn.go.com/espnradio/podcast/archive?id=2544457
OM(freakin')G! What a shocker?!
The Mediots doubting the ’Boys until December?
I’m dumbfounded.
He who knows nothing is closer to the truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods and errors. - Thomas Jefferson
That's their non-weighted rankings.
Their weighted rankings are slightly different, although they still have the Eagles higher:
1. NE
2. NO
3. IND
4. PHI
5. DAL
They claim that their weighting system gives more emphasis on recent games, but there is clearly some sort of problem with their system, though, since Cincinnati beat Baltimore twice in the past 4 weeks, has a better record, and is still 7 spots lower. It’s almost as if they are giving teams more credit for playing good teams close than they are giving those good teams for winning the same game. Maybe I just don’t understand their system. And any time you have rankings like these, teams like New England that run up the score on lesser teams always fare better.
by Baked Potato Soup on Nov 11, 2009 4:46 PM CST up reply actions
yep and also consider
The Eagles have looked poor offensively against oakland, washington and us their past four weeks while we have exploded.
I don’t see it defensively either – we shouldn’t be as low as we are. Maybe cause we’ve let up 2 tds while ahead big in games against atlanta and seattle?
OH how the Mighty have fallen...
Well fellow Cowboy fans and fannetts, we have arrived when none thought we could…we have delivered, to the Cowboy faithful, what we lost somewhere between the Gnats win in Dallas in 2007 and the ass whipping we took in 2008 in Philthy…We have delivered ourselves of the evil that was TO, Tank, Pac-Rat, and the likes, and we have once again ascended to the top of the NFC-East…The once mighty Gnats, have fallen again to the almost pit of despair that they were in before their rise to SuperBowl flukenessdom…The vaunted Giggles are rightly set to the underdogs status that has been their roles since they were so Blessed with the title of an NFC-East team…The humble Cowboys went into the land of the Giggles and came out on top again, as they have for the past 50 years the majority of the time…We DO NOT need stats, numbers or star gazers to tell us what we already know, and that is that the “Road thru the NFC-East runs thru the city of Dallas”…I am not a learned soul, but when I hear the pundits, and the so-called experts talk, and how they know so much more than I do about numbers, and dates, and cycles I want to run across the intersection of I-10 and I-35 in the middle of rush hour traffic…I have determined therefore to give what they have to say henceforth no creedence…What, I ask you do they know about Heart, determination, and un-daunted courage in the face of overwhelming numbers?…NOTHING, NADA, ZILCH, ZERO…If what they say were half true, then we would all be under German rule yet today…If the Allies had believed half of what the Germans claimed , WWII would have probably ended with the takeover of Poland…and the NE Patriots would have their perfect season, had the Gnats been listening to the “experts”…But neither happened and so today we can enjoy the sport of football in Liberty, and with English subtitles…The Giggles all claim that it was sorry officiating that gave the game to the Cowboys…I beg to differ on all points, because 1)…we all know they are full of shite, and 2)..because I have every right to do so under the Constitution of the United States of America…The Gnats have one more shot at retrieving some of the Glory that was heaped on them by all the pundits with their, charts, graphs, and crystal balls, already crowning them NFC-East Champions…(and great has been the fall thereof)…Now we sit at the crossroads of our Destiny…and though we have diverse, and many options to choose from, we must choose to either serve in the NFL heaven, or rule in what is known as the Hell of the NFC-East…To the victor doesnot always the spoils reap, the GoodBook tells usWell, from my point of view, it does say “not always” and refrains from saying" does not ever "…but try telling that to a Giggles fan whos team has just been beaten by a Dallas Cowboy team…Christian or otherwise he will cuss you like he owns you…The once mighty Giggles have suffered the same fate as all the rest of theNFC birds team(with the exception of the Red-Birds)..they have been shot down…and devoured, like the scrumptious chicken, and turkey we all love…LMAO….FEAR THE STAR
by Hawgz, Bugz, and FilthyFowl Hater on Nov 11, 2009 8:55 AM CST reply actions
OK, I really tried to read this one since it seemed shorter
It’s just not possible.
On the upside, if you squint really hard, you can see a mermaid and an old man smoking a pipe.
Never wrestle with a pig. You both get dirty and the pig loves it.
Priceless
You can't stop Patrick Crayton, you can only hope to contain him.
by APerfectStar on Nov 11, 2009 1:57 PM CST up reply actions
Cliff Notes Version
We won when nobody thought we could! I’m stoked! Go Cowboys!
Drinking the Blue Kool-Aid since 1980. "Ohhhhhh yeeeaaaaahhhh!"
Defense
Is still not getting the love, but that is fine. We will continue to sneak up on teams.
"No matter where you go, you are what you are playa"-Jay Z
Twitter Account
there was a point in the game just after
Newman dropped a pass, Hamlin dropped one, and the two INT’s McNabb had that look (0,0) you know the deer in the headlight look.
by Musiccitynorm on Nov 11, 2009 12:25 PM CST up reply actions
I agree
If we could capitalize on those turnovers we would be a great D. I swear if the Pitt secondary touches the ball it is pick.
"No matter where you go, you are what you are playa"-Jay Z
Twitter Account
yep
Polamalu is $$.
Maybe we’ll get there. Hopefully. Who knows. I do feel like the difference between us and an elite D is that
a. we have slightly less intnesity, we don’t hit as hard, although we’re doing a much better job of wrapping up than previously
we don’t come down with turnovers when we have the chance. Although Sensabaugh and jenkins may be the solution to this problem.And we seem to struggle on 3rd and long.
Our third down percentage is pretty good, but for some reason, we seem to struggle on 3rd and more than 7. I know that in that situation, you don’t need a sack, you just need a stop, but we don’t seem to be getting stops when we should. Maybe it’s time to ratchet up the pressure in those situations. I could be wrong, but that’s how it appears to me.
by Baked Potato Soup on Nov 11, 2009 4:36 PM CST up reply actions
We generally seem to refuse to blitz with more than 5 guys
that seems to be part of it. Teams like Philly aren’t afraid to send the house.
But 3rd and long conversions have to stop – they will cause a major momentum shift at some point that will kill us (like the AZ game last year).
36 MINUTES....
thats how long it took them to bann me from the BIG BLUE REVIEW blog…for what???…all I did was ask how their Qtr Back was doing considering the amount of money they obviously overpaid him?…and a little ribbing about the 4 games in a row they have lost…and how they are one and a half games in back of us in the NFC-East…geez, youd think I ridiculed their SB win in 2007(ok, ok, but i only used the word fluke once, I swear)…Oh yeah, and I likened their chances of making it to the POffs this year to the chances a whore has of entering Heaven…But is that any reason to bann a serious blogger, with oodles and oddles to say…Oh well cant please everyone…Whats the name of the CheeseCakes blogging spot?…Ill try my luck in there for a change?…Iff OOC was around Id like for him to do the statistical analysis on how i stack up against every other Cowboy blogger who has been banned from the BBR…FEAR THE STAR
by Hawgz, Bugz, and FilthyFowl Hater on Nov 11, 2009 12:38 PM CST reply actions
haha
and…
enjoy… probably have some better luck in the GB blog..BBR is a dark and lonely place right now.

by 


























