Blogging The Boys: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Follow the @sbnation MLB Twitter List

Cowboys Draft '09: Are Bust Factors Now Conventional Wisdom?

Two years ago, I looked at first-round draft tendencies, on offense and defense, to answer two questions.  First, I wanted to clarify that some positions rise on draft day --quarterbacks,running backs, offensive tackles, wide receivers on offense --  while others, like centers, guards, fullbacks and tight ends, tend to fall.

I also wanted to gauge the relative risks of drafting one of the "high priority" positions over others. I did this for defense and offense, but want to focus on offense, since these results were so dramatic and because current trends suggest NFL teams are reaching similar conclusions -- and acting upon them.

Here's the 2007 chart, which shows hits or misses from 2000 through 2006

Position 1st Rd Top 10 Busts Bust %
Quarterbacks 27 15 8 30%
O-Tackles 27 11 3 11%
Receivers 41 16 21 51%
Running Backs 30 11 7 23%

Star-divide

I have not updated the data to include the '07 and '08 drafts, but I'll provide some newer data to compensate.

First, note that through much of this decade, receiver was the most drafted offensive position -- by a lot. Teams selected receivers at least 25% more often than RBs, QBs and OTs.

Now, look at the awful return on those receiver investments. The "hit" rate for a 1st-round wideout was just under 50%. Look at the hit rate for offensive tackles, by comparison. Now, think back to 2008. Not a single receiver was selected in the first round, though ten were taken in the 2nd. By contrast, eight offensive tackles were picked in the first round.  From Ryan Clady's selection at pick 12 to Sam Baker's selection at the 21st spot, six tackles flew off the board.

And many provided an immediate return on their investments.  Top pick Jake Long stabilized Miami's o-line.  Clady was a big reason Denver allowed the fewest sacks last season.  Carolina's running game exploded in '08 and many big runs were behind Jeff Otah, whom the Panthers picked 19th overall.

Left offensive tackles are now sexy picks, because they're safe picks.  The trend should continue this year.  The NFP's Mike Lombardi today said his sources tell him the top ten will be filled with QBs and LTs.    A source told me a couple of weeks ago that another half dozen left tackles could hear their names in the first round next week.

And the receivers?  Michael Crabtree and Jeremy Maclin will go high, but then?  Percy Harvin has dropped off Dallas' draft board and may be off others.  Darrius Heyward-Bey and Kenny Britt might sneak into the first, but have you noticed the actions of teams in the 20-30 range who need receivers?

Let's start with our own Cowboys, who flipped the 20th overall pick for Roy Williams last year.  The Jets at 17, the Eagles at 21 and 28, the Ravens at 26 and the Giants at 29 are strongly considering swapping those picks for Anquan Boldin or perhaps Braylon Edwards.  The contract for a rookie receiver is much, much less than the $9 to $10 million a year these veterans command, but teams seem willing to pay more to lessen their risks.

Bust factors appear to have become conventional wisdom around the league.  Expect a lot more jockeying for big linemen and a lot less -- at least in the 1st round -- for wideouts.  "Speed kills" is an adage as true in war rooms as it is on the field.  Too many organizations have been burned by too many receiver busts.

1 recs  |  Comment 23 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Interesting Observations

I would like to see the updated numbers. One thing I noted from your earlier article was that Aaron Rogers was counted as a bust (although you admitted it might change). However, you had not counted Alex Smith as a bust back then (how could you — for a QB you need at least two years to even provide a preliminary grade).

Thanks for an interesting analysis.

Keep Moving Forward.

by ColoradoOwl on Apr 17, 2009 11:25 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I'm interested to know the defensive trends

Do FSs and SSs rise or fall?

And how will that affect pick #51 for us?

by BishopWest on Apr 17, 2009 11:59 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

If Delmas falls to the early second round

I expect that we will trade up for him

by quincyyyyy on Apr 18, 2009 10:47 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

+1

In Romo we Trust

by Terry on Apr 19, 2009 9:30 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

After reading Raf's bust factors defense

from the old site (blueandsilverreport.com) I notice that the only position drafted less than FS and SS in Round One is NT.

If that holds true – We should be able to get a pretty good Safety at #51 or maybe we should move up just a little to make sure.

by BishopWest on Apr 18, 2009 12:39 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Just a note about John Madden retiring. I've always liked Madden. My sister and broinlaw were big Raiders fans back

when Madden was coaching them. He was always in the game, and he showed real emotion on just about every play. I wondered how long he could possibly last iwth his ‘vibrant’ personality. Long enough to win a SB and get in the PFHOF, as it turn out. I wish him well, and hope he has a long and prosperous retirement. I’ll miss you John.

Family, Friends, Cowboys, Beer & BBQ. Life is good!

by CowboyMan on Apr 18, 2009 12:44 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I was dissapointed

When i first heard the news, I was just shocked. I mean, i know he can’t do it forever, but why so unexpected and why now? When i found out that he didn’t fly because he was afraid of heights (therefor he takes the bus) and that his grand kids where starting to miss him when he was away, then that was the real selling point. They would practically never see him during the football season as he would be riding a bus back and forth between destinations all of the time, spending more time on the road than at home or in the booth. Now I support his retirement but I will definitely miss “the voice of the NFL” on sunday night football. I just wonder what is going to happen to the Madden videogames and the traditional “horse trailer player of the game”?

YOOOOOOUUUUUU, crank that cowboys YOOOOOOUUUUU, Crank that cowboys (Soulja boy Cowboys Remix)

by ProBowlFactory on Apr 18, 2009 11:52 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

He'll still make stops around

As a guest he’ll make appearances, but probably more at halftime analysis. You don’t just stop doing something you love. So I wouldn’t doubt him making an appearance at the new stadium sometime down the road.

YOOOOOOUUUUUU, crank that cowboys YOOOOOOUUUUU, Crank that cowboys (Soulja boy Cowboys Remix)

by ProBowlFactory on Apr 18, 2009 11:57 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

OK I KNOW I WILL GET FLAMED BUT....

Who cares about John flippin Madden, quite possibly the most uninspiring, most obvious, word fumbling stutterer ever to be on prime time television. He never had anything to say that was not as obvious as the sky is blue, and the sun is hot. This is just ridiculous, I tried to let it go, but you guys act like he was something so special. Uh did you ever really listen to his commentary? I mean I cant tell you how many times I muted my TV just so I would not be dumbed down to that comic book analyzing. I AM OFFICIALLY OFF MY SOAP BOX!

by TONYINCC on Apr 18, 2009 12:30 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

If you're younger, you may have missed his prime.

At the beginning, he was different, brought some energy, and gave credit to the trenches that most announcers ignored.

For the last 5 or so years, he’s been a parody of himself, and his partner has been senile.

by Realist Larry on Apr 18, 2009 5:12 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Great Info Raf

It confirms what many of us have thought all along. I believe those percentages would be constant thoughout the draft’s early rounds. The later rounds would probably be a crapshoot entirely. With this years pick being at 51 the thought of going OT or S, NT on defense certainly fits right into our wheelhouse. I’ld have no problem with any of those positions.

 About the defensive numbers shown. I wonder if this years numbers will be messed up with so many teams switching to the 3/4 and NT position being so key. They will be drafted way higher than normal leading to likely more busts.

BWT both articles great.

by oldboysfan on Apr 18, 2009 7:05 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

You have to wonder how these numbers will change over time...

If only a few WRs are drafted in each of the coming years, you could see their status begin to look more like the current OT numbers – and vice-versa… as OLDBOYSFAN states above:


They will be drafted way higher than normal leading to likely more busts.

Great article, and really useful information that allows incite into the psyche of NFL draft rooms.

Tar Heels started this college Bball season with one goal in mind - that loss to Kansas in last year's final 4 will make this team all bid-ness!

by DalaiLuke on Apr 18, 2009 9:32 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

I'm not a fan of all the grammar / usage / spelling mistakes ... so I'll correct my own!

incite = to stir, encourage, or urge on; stimulate or prompt to action: to incite a crowd to riot.

insight= seeing underlying truth

… the second one is the correct usage.

thanks dictionary.com

Tar Heels started this college Bball season with one goal in mind - that loss to Kansas in last year's final 4 will make this team all bid-ness!

by DalaiLuke on Apr 18, 2009 9:36 AM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

That OT class was one for the ages tho ...

I watched that 08 OT class come through college since 06,and had been touting the O lineman quality and quantity of that class. (So I was disappointed that the cowboys went a year early and got Marten and Free.)

If you take that exceptional class out, does the premise still hold true?

by alanTdot. on Apr 18, 2009 5:52 PM CDT reply actions   0 recs

Why Do WRs Bust at Such a High Rate

I think the data is interesting, and I wonder what causes WRs to bust out at such a high rate. Is it due to playing with inferior QBs? Are they overrated from the get go based on how they did at the college playing against inferior DBs? Are they thrust into the lineup before they’re ready? A combo of all of the above? I think an article that explores WHY WRs bust out so frequently would be an interesting read indeed.

by egtuna on Apr 20, 2009 9:15 AM CDT reply actions   0 recs

WRs have a high bust rate for a couple of reasons

First of all, WRs in college rarely if ever face press coverage as they always get free releases in college. In the pros they have an extremely difficult adjustment having to learn to beat press coverage. It takes a lot of technique and strength and a lot of college WRs just don’t possess the physicality to do so.

Also, route running in the pros has to be much more precise than in college, rounding off cuts and freelancing won’t cut it in the NFL.

Finally, the CBs in the NFL are really fast and good, so you’re not going to beat a CB in the NFL on athletic ability alone, like so many college WRs got away with doing. It takes more discipline and technique and film study to beat quality NFL CBs.

In Romo we Trust

by Terry on Apr 20, 2009 2:16 PM CDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Dallas Cowboys blog for the SB Nation network. We talk Cowboys 24/7/365. Join the discussion but follow the community guidelines.
Start posting about the Cowboys »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

09_bar-refaeli_08_small
Why The Eagles Game Is Not About Romo
Small
Cowboy / Eagle game analysis - using Drives instead of pure stats
Captain_small
NFL Power Rankings - Week 9 - Final Edition
Sadie_eagles__small
Since we're all looking forward to it:
Captain_small
Seven Statistical Nuggets To Ponder

Recent FanPosts

Captain_small
Pigskin Pundits Predictors Picking Philly
Cowboy_small
We go big or we go home...
Small
great article from Philly writer
Small
Bench Roy Williams
Arnold_small
Matchups? Cowboys and Eagles looking to beat each other
Small
Roy - Your Dirty Laundry Stinks!
Small
10 Keys to the Eagles game
Tom-landry-at_small
Relax Dallas Fans; Roy Williams Isn’t Turning Into T.O.
Small
Should Wade's contract be extended???
Profilepicbtb_small
The true reason I hate Philly more than any other team...

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Turf Show Times
Rams get ratings; TST joins Sprint's NFL Mobile Live
Cincy Jungle
The Cincinnati Bengals should think about lower ticket prices to close the home schedule
Mile High Report
Broncos add Ty Law, Waive CB Jack Williams

SPONSORS


Editor

Head_shot1_small Dave Halprin

Lead Writer

Small Rafael Vela

Contributing Writers

Villaronga_small Raul Villaronga

Hotdoglu_small Aaron Novinger

Landry_and_fish_small Mike Fisher