Pro Football Weekly Player Rankings
by nicholas.rodriguez on Jun 2, 2009 3:32 AM CDT
Email
Print
Saw the magazine at the store and just had to buy it and wanted to share just the NFC East Rankings they got.
Gonna put overall number, and name
Qb:
6. Tony Romo
11. Eilsha Manning
22. Jason Campbell
RB:
13. Brandon Jacobs
16. Marion Barber
( I hated writing that)
TE:
2. Jason Witten
6. Chris Cooley
WR:
19. Santana Moss
24. Roy Williams
( If the NFC East has one black mark, this is it)
Centers:
1. Andre Gurode
12. Jamaal Jackson
Guards:
3. Chris Snee
14. Todd Herremans
Tackles:
7. Jason Peters
11. Flo Adams
14. David Diehl
21. Kareem McKenzie
Defensive Ends:
5. Justin Tuck
8. Trent Cole
20. Mathias Kiwanuka
25. Andre Carter
Defensive Tackles:
10. Jay Ratliff
13. Fred Robbins
15. Mike Patterson
17. Broderick Bunkley
18. Chris Canty
24. Rocky Bernard
Inside LB:
10. London Fletcher
15. Bradie James
16. Antonio Pierce
19. Stewart Bradley
Outside LB:
1. Demarcus Ware
19. Michael Boley
Corners:
13. DeAngelo Hall
14. Aaron Ross
16. Carlos Rogers
Safeties:
7. LaRon Landry
16. Ken Hamlin
21. Quintin Mikell
Looking at the Rankings their isn't too much to gripe about besides maybe Igor getting left off the DE list and Columbo not getting in but all in all it seems pretty accurate for right now. Felix and Tashard both made the top veteran prospects for any who were wondering.
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
26 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
pretty good
I 100% on qb. Witen should be 1, i don’t see how hes not. But I think Roy will be around 15 or so at wr. The list loses legitimacy imo with gurode and andrews at the top of their center and guard rankins. Andrews hasn’t been healthy/great in over 2 years, and gurode makes so many comically (for other teams’ fans) dumb ass plays that its a joke to have him at 1. Snee, Davis and Herrmans are properly ranked though. I guess i mostly agree with their tackle rankings. But injury aside, Flo has outplayed Peters the last 2 years. And columbo absolutely deserves to be there. He has shut down so many elite players at RT.
Defensively…their wrong on mikell. He is a legit player, much moreso than hamlin. At corner, WAYYY too much credit for Hall. I’d take both jenkins and scandrick over hall. I’m fine with their defensive line rankings, after igor got benched last year he needs to earn his stripes again. I think bradie should be a little higher, he played damn well over the last 3 months last year.
clearly Witten should be #1
Easily better than any TE in the game and the QB rankings look dead on.
In Romo we Trust
My thoughts:
- As I read the responses, my feelings almost exactly mirror foyesboyes. That’s one smart dude.
- QB ranking are right on, in my opinion.
- Witten is 2nd to no one. I guess they have Gonzalez there?
- Gurode as the best Center in the NFL is a joke. He should barely crack the top 10.
- The Sporting News ranked Olshansky as the 11th best DE in the NFL. Cant believe he doesnt make the list at all here.
- Ratliff is probably a little low here at #10, but then again tackles in a 4-3 will put up better numbers.
- The most glaring mis-ranking (besides Gurode) is putting Mikell at 21st. If that’s the case, can we please offer Ken Hamlin for him straight-up?
haha thanks
give us mikell for hamlin and we’d be golden. Hes not a playmaker but hes a very solid, reliable player.
Why the hate for Hamlin
just a year ago he went to the pro bowl, and this year, he missed Training camp and had to deal w/ Watkins/Davis most of the year at SS
"We play to win the game" - Herm Edwards
by nicholas.rodriguez on Jun 2, 2009 2:40 PM CDT up reply actions
+1
Hamlin > Mikell
Is it too early to ask what round I should aim for Felix in my fantasy football league?
by Aaron Novinger on Jun 2, 2009 2:46 PM CDT up reply actions
Since when is...
Ken Hamlin: 16gms 74 tackles 53 solo 1 sack 2 passes deflected 1 int
better than…
Quintin Mikell: 16 gms 93 tackles 68 solo 2 sacks 9 passes deflected 3 ints (2nd Team All-Pro)
Whoever thinks Hamlet is better than Mikell. Get your head straight.
Taking Route 36 will bring you to Touchdown,PHI
Hamlet...
There is someone who needs to get their head straight
by aussie_cowboy on Jun 3, 2009 3:52 AM CDT up reply actions
Soooooooo, Hamlin had a bad year and Mikell had a good year?
Big F’ing deal! Our team has had an overachieving year, too—in ‘07. Don’t get too excited about last year. Could be your guys’ turn to implode.
Is it too early to ask what round I should aim for Felix in my fantasy football league?
by Aaron Novinger on Jun 3, 2009 10:10 AM CDT up reply actions
Not really
Mikell played the same way the year before when he had just 11 starts. Last year was his first full year starting. He is the real deal. Jim Johnson’s defense never implodes. Even if he is not on the sideline, its his defense.
Taking Route 36 will bring you to Touchdown,PHI
He's gonna be playing next to Sean Jones this year, though.
While Jones isn’t all that bad, is perhaps Mikell’s rise some of the reasoning for letting Dawk leave?
At least now you have 2 young safeties for Brian Stewart to coach up down.
Is it too early to ask what round I should aim for Felix in my fantasy football league?
by Aaron Novinger on Jun 3, 2009 1:14 PM CDT up reply actions
Gurode is listed as a good center because he is the best run blocking center in the NFL
no other center can match his power. That’s not a joke – would love to see an end to the mistaken snaps of course, but there is a reason some people love Gurode
by AustonianAggie on Jun 2, 2009 2:52 PM CDT up reply actions
Maybe Ratliff could get more Tackles
but few DTs ever reach 8 sacks
by AustonianAggie on Jun 2, 2009 2:53 PM CDT up reply actions
plus he plays NT in the 3-4
DTs in the 4-3 rack up tackles because of the scheme.
by CowboysFanatic on Jun 4, 2009 12:10 PM CDT up reply actions
Not Bad
This list is not that bad, but like everyone else I think Hall is way too high for CB’s (just like Gurode is too high for centers) and that Witten and Ratliff are too low.
I also would say that there is no way Webster is the #7 in the league and Rogers is #16. Webster isn’t bad, but #7 is too high for him based off the fact that I don’t think he possesses the elite cover skills of a top corner. As for Rogers, he is aguy who has never shown me enough considering he was never trusted enough to cover T.O.
Still though, the list is prettty good compared to some of the lists I have seen.
There are lots of people that go to church on Sundays to get in touch with God. Personally, my church is on Sunday as well, it just happens to involve watching the Dallas Cowboys.
Good to see T-New get his proper love
WELCOME HOME SEVEN!!
by Carl Shelton (GloryDayz88) on Jun 2, 2009 10:26 PM CDT reply actions
Comments For This Post Are Closed
Secondary Sidebar
User Tools
FanPosts
Community blog posts and discussion.
Certain photos copyright © 2012 by Associated Press or Getty Images. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Associated Press and Getty Images is strictly prohibited.
