Pretty ambitious to think the typical fan would be able to judge without discrimination. I am curious to see the train wreck.

do this biased stuff somewhere else. its getting close to crunch time and dont need this taking up fanpost space

behind Eli adn McNabb. Thats all the evidence I need to know this team is rubbish.

Please stop.

There are people on this board who don’t even speak English who make better posts than you.

You guys are mean….

1. Romo is the starter, for the reason stated above
2. Roy Williams is a starter, for many reasons the most obvious of which is the the other 3 receivers are all the same type (small, quick guys)
3. Leonard Davis is better than both of the starters, not to mention the back-ups, have to have him somewhere.
4. Jay Ratliff is better than Barry Cofield, have you seen what the guy can do at the NT spot?
5. Brady James is better than both Bradely and Fletcher, but I would settle for having him listed over one of them

I can’t argue too much on the rest of these, my first instinct was to raise hell about the running backs, but Westbrook and Portis are pretty good, I would personally take Barber. Can’t argue with the tackles too much although Andrews had a horrible year last year and everyone just assumes he will return to pro-bowl form—not a given. I really like Gurode, but O’Hara is pretty nasty. Can’t argue over DE’s when we don’t run that system. I really think one of or other 2 CBs should be there, they are at least as good as the overrated DHall. Thats about it.

I resisted responding to this thread (for many of the reasons stated above) but am bored so here goes.

Each “position” must be related to the entire unit. A collection of all-stars never plays as well as a team. But units can be judged vis-a-vis another, even though one unit can be killed by the other in overall terms (i.e., if you can’t generate a pass rush, your DBs will suck..see Denver).

So who has the best units?
QB – I’ll take Romo, but McScabb has an argument, Eli doesn’t.
RB – Giants lost their 1000 compliment, Westbrook is old and hurt, Cowboys are 3 deep.
WR – Cowboys easily. Giants start 2 new, Philthy has a couple of rookies & 2nd year guys.
TE – Please!
OL – Lines take a few years to gel. Giants and ’Boys are tied, edge to the ’Boys based on Pro Bowls.

Really, the entire Offense and Defense should be judged. If you say the Iggles have the best D, I’d debate but might agree. Gints are in the discussion as well. Skiz are not far behingd.

But Offense? There is little question that over the past 2 (and only) years of Romo’s career, the Cowboys have the best Offensive unit.

is because he doesn’t show conisitency. McNabb and Manning have shown there “clutch”.
Also Roy Williams hasn’t shown much since his 1 good year w/ the lions

I will add Leonard Davis and move up Jay ratliff

romo has managed 2.
u forgot to make a point.

so far i have heard that eli sucks and romo has no experience.
point jumps out that the giants bailed out their QB and cowboys didnt.