NFL Power Rankings - Week 4 - Final
Mike Fish weighed in on the topic of power rankings.
I think wringing our hands and gnashing our teeth over where some national sportswriter "ranks the Cowboys'' [...] is a terrible waste of time (not to mention a waste of hands and teeth). The team ranking would matter ... if this was college football.
And while he's basically right, give me your thoughts in the poll attached at the end of the post.
Here's a look at the various power rankings out there heading into week 4.
Top spot this week goes to WhatIfSports who have us at 4th, behind only the Ravens, Saints and Colts. No further comments provided, but I'm ordering their flavor of Kool Aid today.
Michael Silver at Yahoo Sports put us in 8th, but moves the Eagles ahead of us again: "Following two weeks of criticism, is it fair to say Terence Newman and the other 10 guys in the huddle got a little defensive Monday night?"
ProFootballWeekly has us up a notch at No. 9. "This NFC East race is going to be fun."
ColdHardFootballFacts move us up two to 10th. "Last week: 21-7 win vs. Carolina. If the Cowboy tailbacks were one person, he'd be the easy front-runner for MVP. Mariofelix Barchoice has 515 yards on 75 carries (6.9 average) and four TDs."
NationalFootballPost ranks us 10th (+2). "No one is running the ball like the Cowboys—and we don’t expect it to stop." Amen.
Pete Prisco @ CBS Sports moves us down one spot to 11th: "Yes, they beat the Panthers on Monday night. Did it look good? For a half, it was bad. They finally got it going, but we'll know more about them when they go to Denver this week."
Zac Wassink at AssociatedContent ranks us 11th, up one vs. last week. "I've had far more faith in the Cowboys than many during the 2009 NFL regular season. That faith gets tested this Sunday as Dallas heads to Denver."
Mike Florio at ProFootballTalk.com keeps us in 13th. "With Marion Barber, Felix Jones, and Tashard Choice, maybe the Cowboys don't need a quarterback at all."
SI.com. Don Banks moves us down a notch to 14th. "Why is it that Dallas seems to be the only NFL city where the team's former stars or coaches seem to come out of the woodwork to incessantly comment on its current stars? Tony Dorsett, Emmitt Smith, Troy Aikman, Michael Irvin, Jimmy Johnson, Roger Staubach, they all have something to say about Tony Romo, good and bad. It's got to make it even tougher to play in Dallas with all those living legends around to critique you. If I'm Romo, I'm tempted to tell them to "analyze this."
NFL.com's Experts drop us to 15th. Joe Theisman, one of the experts, drops us from 5th to 11th, but still has us higher than all the other 'experts'.
Fox Sports has us at No. 15: "Tony Romo concerns aside, the Cowboys should be in the playoff hunt thanks to their renewed focus on the running game. But really, all answers about the Cowboys will have to wait until Romo's allergic month of December as Dallas will face the Chargers, Saints and Eagles down the stretch."
Weii.com has us at 16th, down 3: "Tony Romo did not turn the ball over on Monday night and the Cowboys running game rose to the occasion with the absence of Marion Barber. Dallas still needs to improve on defense." They're based in Boston. Don't expect any handouts to the NFC East.
SportingNews.com drops us two spots to No 17. "If they keep running the ball effectively, it will take pressure off Tony Romo."
Covers.com drop us 5 places to No. 17 after winning a game. "Dallas improved to 2-1 but the win over the Panthers was hardly impressive. Dallas' play calling was clueless for most of the game. Two road games are up before the bye." At least he's consistent and drops the Giants and Eagles as well after wins.
ESPN lowers us a further two notches to 17th: "Tashard Choice and Felix Jones prove the Cowboys can still have a running offense when Marion Barber is injured. (Clayton)". No love lost there.
Walter Football keeps us at No. 19. No comments provided, as they only provide comments for the top and bottom 10.
Here's how the NFC East fared:
Hat tip to Eaglesgrl5 for the Weii link.
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
28 comments
|
3 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
foxsports lol
they got the eagles 4th…that must be a joke they got tooooooooooo many holes on that squad…There o line sucks and there defense was torn apart by the saints…Its easy to look good against the cheifs…
i want to see how your defense looks against the saints
and i want to see how your running game, which is nasty right now, i will say, looks in weeks 11-17
RIP JJ & HK
Let the future judge Michael Vick
heh.
Not sure you do want to see it…I’ll leave it up to you how to interpet that…
God Bless Texas
by dwarfknight64 on Oct 1, 2009 10:32 PM CDT up reply actions
You should have an option for...
I like to read these while I poop. Keep making them please.
Squish.
by Squishmytomato on Sep 29, 2009 3:04 PM CDT via mobile reply actions
These are the bomb...can I still use that term?
Great references and you do an awesome job at organizing them. With all the different resources you use, we get a good feel for how the Cowboys match up with teams that are considered “better”.
I like it, but I prefer to read hard-copied materials while I poop.
And the sign said long haired freaky people need not apply ...
http://twitter.com/BloggingTheBoys
Good for a laugh, some of them are.
I tend to scoffaw at most of them and find myself agreeing with the ones that rank us high.I still do not comprehend how you drop a team in the ranking after a win…just don’t get it.
I'm humored that most of these I have looked at have
the 1-2 Steelers in the top 10, but have the 3-0 Broncos outside of the top 15.
power ranking are a good read and convo piece
but they have no real meaning in pro football
RIP JJ & HK
Let the future judge Michael Vick
Keep them coming.
I appreciate that you compile these things so I don’t have to search al over for them. Yes, they are meaningless in the grand scheme of things, but my life is full of meaningless distractions.
I must say that I miss Dr. Z’s power rankings. The guy knew more about footbal than anyone alive, and he was also a humorous writer. He also admitted when his rankings were completely arbitrary, and he seemed to enjoy the give and take with fans who complained that their team was ranked too low
Lifetime Cowboys Fan from the Swamps of Jersey
This is a 'Middle of the Pack' team
The way we start so sluggishly on offense doesn’t look like it will change. The defense still is suspect against the pass.
8-8 or 9-7 look reasonable to me.
Maybe even worse as some of the higher octane offenses lay ahead on our schedule.
"Well, we didn't block real good but we made up for it by not tackling."
- John McKay, the first coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers
5Blings, are you a Cowboy fan or a troll?
Because you describe the Cowboys O as sluggish, and the ones on our schedule as “higher octane”
… higher octane than what? Jet fuel?
We turn the ball over 4 times and still almost beat the Giants, we woke up and DESTROYED the only other two teams we’ve played. Yet you remain quite certain we are mediocre? Oh my, I can only imagine the disappoint you will feel when we get on a winning streak.
Oh, the irony is thick
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
Sorry to just pick on you, as my comments are more for the entire Nay-sayer Bandwagon
But you do happen to be leading the parade, as evidenced from your big hat and that cute baton you throw around :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
I can't understand fans like 5Blings
How miserable being a fan must be for him if you think your team sucks all the time.
In Romo we Trust
As a footnote, did you ever notice that sympathy and pathetic come from the same latin origin?
or was it Greek? :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
I enjoy it
I came to btb.com just to look for your collection of rankings…keeps me away from bspn.com…keep em going we appreciate it! BTW I just have to scratch my head when we move down after a win. I can see keeping us in the same place if you weren’t convinced by the win, but to move us down is just annoying
Whooooo
cares about rankings and stats as long as this team win!!!
This is what went wrong with this team last year the media and bein stuck on there on hype.
We can be rank last and i dont care.
I'm way too lazy, but it would be interesting to do an analysis of Vegas's odds
The media rankings are entertaining, but the real boys are in Nevada. And these are the only rankings that actually count. They had the Boys favored against the Giants … favored by 9.5 against a desperate Carolina club… and this weekend we’re 3.5 point favorites ON THE ROAD!
Okay, I’ll get just a LITTLE unlazy… The real analysis here would be a logarithm that could actually produce rankings.
Cowboys Odds:
3.5 Away / Tampa Bay - Covered
2.5 Home / Giants - Lost
9.5 Home / Carolina - Covered
Giants Odds:
6.5 Home / Washington - Won/Not Cover
+2.5 Away / Dallas — Covered
7.5 Away / Tampa Bay — Covered
Eagles Odds:
+.5 Away / Carolina — Covered
1.5 Home / Saints - Lost
9.5 Home / Chiefs - Covered
Saints Odds:
11.5 Home / Detroit - Covered
+1.5 Away / Philly — Covered
5.5 Away / Buffalo - Covered
Minnesota Odds:
3.5 Away / Cleveland - covered
9.5 Away / Detroit - covered
7.5 Home / San Francisco - Won/Not Cover
Interesting to note: The Saints are not only the ONE team to Cover each week… but they’ve done it with three blow-outs. In fact, they’ve scored 17 more points than the next closest team (which is, shockingly, the Ravens!)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
Not to filibuster here, but ...
I voted:
It would be cool if you kept these posts going all year -TCBinNYC
… excellent work, One.Cool … it’s bloggers like yourself that make BTB second to none :)
Doomsday returns... Wade Phillips style.
I chose to keep em running
but i also read em while i poop =)
"We play to win the game" - Herm Edwards
by nicholas.rodriguez on Oct 1, 2009 11:36 PM CDT reply actions
Mosley: Cowboys most underrated team in the division
Mosley at ESPN NFC East blog has this take on their power rankings…
I’m pretty sure the Cowboys’ pass rush is overrated: The Cowboys are about to face one of the worst 3-0 teams (Denver Broncos) since the merger. After wins over Denver and Kansas City, Dallas will head into a bye with a nice-looking 4-1 record. But there are still some flaws that have emerged. A year removed from leading the league in sacks, the Cowboys were shut out the first two games. They had three sacks in the Monday night win over the Panthers, but two of them came after the game had already been decided.
The Cowboys won’t win many games scoring 14 points on offense, although they pulled it off against Carolina. Offensive coordinator Jason Garrett seems to be realizing that this team has a new identity. In the post-T.O. era, the Cowboys’ best chance for success is in a run-based offense. When Marion Barber, Felix Jones and Tashard Choice are all healthy, the Cowboys potentially have the most dangerous running attack in the league. Unfortunately, Jones and Barber appear to be injury prone at this point in their careers. This may sound crazy, but I think the Cowboys are actually the most underrated team in the division right now. Our power rankings specialists put them at No. 17, which seems ridiculously low.
If this team can find anyone to rush the quarterback opposite DeMarcus Ware (hello, Anthony Spencer?), the Cowboys could get on a roll.
Overall he says NFC East is overrated because of Eagles and Skins, but nice that he recognizes that the Boys are very underrated.
I mean, everyone seems to agree that the Giants are a good team, but they barely beat the Boys. We ran at will against their supposedly top defense, and put up 250+ rushing yards with 8.6 ypc (!). We were 4/4 in the red zone, Giants 0/5. We tore apart their run defense, they tore apart our pass defense, so both teams showed their strengths and exposed each other’s weaknesses. But the game came down to a last minute final goal, and just one or two bounces of the ball differently and we would be 3-0, and much higher in the rankings. It took Romo having a really bad day for them to beat us, and he has a lot more good days than bad ones. So I think despite losing that game, what it showed is that the distance between the Cowboys and the Giants is not that great.
But they’re going to have to earn respect. A mediocre win over Denver won’t do much to change it, but a dominating win will start to open some eyes.
But of course power rankings and respect don’t matter. What matters is wins, no matter how you get them, and no matter what anyone, fan or media, thinks.
im starting to think
its better being low on the radar
lets pretend to be middle of the pack all year … its not like the publicity is really helping
definitely better being underrated then overrated.
gives the cowboys one more reason each week to go out and prove something.
as long as they continue to get better each week and put all phases together consistently we should be fine enough.
teams like the cowboys and falcons can fly under the radar and make the playoffs while all the hype goes to teams like the saints and giants.
Into video games? Check out GamersBeyond.com for reviews/vids on latest video games from all platforms (PC, PS3, xbox, Wii)

by 
























