My plan to take the Cowboys to the SB.
Everyone else was doing it, so I thought I would too.
Obviously we need OL depth. And I don't mean depth like serviceable backups, I mean guys who can legitimately challenge a starter. Stop drafting guys who can adequately play 2 OL positions and instead draft a guy that you know is dominant at one. If a LT that is truly superior to Doug Free is available through trade, the Cowboys need to look into acquiring him. If not, they will need to get some help in the draft. I'm also wondering if Colombo could play guard, and eager to see what kind of ability Brewster has. In my perfect world, we find a starter for LT, Free takes Colombo's spot and Colombo takes Kosier's spot, instantly upgrading our power on interior runs.
At WR, more than anything else, Dallas needs RW to play to his ability and for Ogletree to take his game to the next level, challenging Crayton. I think Ogletree can be both a deep threat and a Wes Welker type slot receiver, but he is still raw. Williams has size and leaping ability that is hard to find, and just needs to learn how to make the right reads, and run his routes properly. This will be Williams' third season with the Cowboys and 2nd offseason, so hopefully he will make a leap mentally.
If they do anything with the TE/FB situation, which I think is solid, they need to find a true annihilator at FB. Cricket is a good guy, but I want someone that is a guaranteed pancake on every run. He touched the ball once last year, so I don't buy that we need someone who can also catch passes and/or be an effective short yardage runner. We use our TEs in that role if we do want someone to catch. Obviously Bennett needs to step up, but I think being called out by the owner and this being his 3rd season will enable him to show that growth. If not, Phillips has shown that he is good 2nd TE.
At RB, they need to reshuffle the current work load. Ignoring their contracts, Jones should be the starter, Barber the 3rd down and short yardage back, and Choice the backup for both roles. Barber is an animal as a pass blocker, is highly effective on dump off passes on 3rd and long, and not being the starter would save wear and tear on him over the season (and his career). That’s the role that earned him the big contract, so why not put our aces in their places?
At DL, they need to find a legitimate backup for Ratliff. As difficult as it is to find a space eating monster that fills the role of traditional NT, it is even more so to find someone with Ratliff's skill set. As a backup, they would likely have more success finding a guy who can just be a rock in running situations and relieve Ratliff on first and second down for some series. DE is solid if not spectacular, but there are very few spectacular 3-4 DEs, and that doesn't seem to be a need.
The biggest help at LB would be if the rookies from this year prove to be capable. They offer athleticism at ILB that none of the current top 3 can match. It might not be a bad idea to try to find a couple more potentials mid to late in the draft, because Brooking isn't going to last forever and Carpenter and James are average. OLB is our strongest position, and if the rookies can show growth and Curtis Johnson can develop, we are probably set here for years.
Orlando Scandrick showed improvement throughout the year, and if he can make a similar leap this year that Jenkins made last year, he may be able to challenge Newman as the starter. I think that would also allow Dallas to move Newman to covering slot receivers where he always excelled in years past.
The problem at S is that Hamlin isn't an athletic playmaker, and that guys with his field generalship and communication are rare. If you're going to replace Hamlin, you have to be sure that it's with someone that can line the other guys up as well as him. This will be Ball's 4th season, so I think this is the year where he shows that he can either take Hamlin's spot or if he will be a career backup. The key for him is film study and communication, in my opinion, because he's a great athlete.
I sincerely hope that Buehler hired a personal kicking coach and is developing his FG skills, because devoting 2 spots to kicker hurts both our depth and ability to develop other young players. However, if not, Dallas needs to find someone who can reliably make FGs. If no one in training camp establishes themselves as that guy, then just go with Buehler, because it's not like we're having success there anyway. Why waste the roster spot on a specialist that can't fulfill his role?
This is the first year that I go into the next season honestly believing that we have one of the top 5 QBs in the league. Kitna is about as solid as you're going to get for a backup.
How 'bout them Cowboys?!
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
54 comments
|
6 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I totally agree about K
I don’t know why they didn’t just turn the FG kicker position over to Buehler last year. I mean, what does he even have to do at practice. It seems like a guy that can really kick the ball and who kicked FG’s in college should be able to figure it out.
"The last time the Eagles visited Cowboys Stadium, they were spitting on the star. This time they left Cowboys Stadium pissing their pants."- Mike "Fish" Fisher
DE is a need
I bet you’ll see Dallas take one in the first 3 picks.
"Emotion is highly overrated in football. My wife Corky is emotional as hell but can't play football worth a damn."
- John McKay, the first coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Which DE do you see them replacing?
Spears and Olshansky are both inexpensive, as is the developing Bowen. Hatcher is a career backup that could be upgraded, but is your #4 DE in the 3-4 really a need? If they were going to go after a DE, I think they should go for Richard Seymour. He is one of the few guys out there that might be able to offer not just DE, but a similar NT style as Ratliff. That would really bolster the rotation.
by Baked Potato Soup on Jan 31, 2010 4:48 PM CST up reply actions
I think Hatcher is probably leaving
Spears might leave depending on his market value. If it’s close to Drago’s they should keep him, but if it’s closer to Canty’s let him go. Bowen could be the replacement, with Marcus Dixon and a draft pick competing for backup.
I agree with going after Seymour if possible. He would be at the top of my FA list.
Drago says, "We must break you!"
by APerfectStar on Jan 31, 2010 10:47 PM CST up reply actions
All the DLine guys are restricted under the 2010 year rules
I think JJ will try to keep them all, at least for 1 more year.
But I do think we need to develop new DLine prospects behind the current rotation.
"Where's Woody? - We need another Darren Woodson
I think they know they need more pressure from their DE spot
We saw how disruptive the Jets were with their pressure packages, and they don’t have anyone nearly as good as Ware (or Spencer). It allowed them not to blitz, which kept more players in coverage. When they did blitz, teams like Cincy and San Diego had no answer.
Answering your question, I’m not a Spears guy. Too many promises made by him about how he would finally show off his quickness and ablility to penetrate. What I saw? Not so much.
"Emotion is highly overrated in football. My wife Corky is emotional as hell but can't play football worth a damn."
- John McKay, the first coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers
well if we draft one its prolly cause a RFA is most likely gone and we got a compensatory pick
so it would seem like that pick earned itself
+1
I can’t see us taking one unless he is the BPA and there isn’t anyone else that fills a more pressing need available if we have all our Dline back again
by nicholas.rodriguez on Feb 5, 2010 11:09 PM CST up reply actions
I don't see him being a "horse"...
maybe leading in carries, but I doubt he’s ever going to get 30 carries in a game.
by The Immortal Iron Fist AKA AFB on Jan 30, 2010 4:11 PM CST up reply actions
Yeah...
you’re right, but that’s what I would call a horse.
Felix isn’t going to be a workhorse back, but he should get the majority of the touches.
by The Immortal Iron Fist AKA AFB on Feb 1, 2010 11:15 AM CST up reply actions
It puzzles me
How every year alot of people call for Kosier’s replacement to improve the o-line and every year he grades out as one of our better linemen.
MacGruber!
I agree. He’s better than Colombo and might be better than Davis. You don’t play musical chairs with linemen.
"On a journey to anywhere you can draw your own map."
He has sound technique...
but he is so limited by his physical skills that he gets totally whipped by biggere defensive linemen.
Not just beat, destroyed.
And I don’t think he’s better than Columbo.
by The Immortal Iron Fist AKA AFB on Jan 31, 2010 12:50 PM CST up reply actions
I think saying 'totally whipped' and 'destroyed' is going way overboard of an assessment of Kosier.
That would fit Corey Procter better.
Kosier is consistently solid on an Oline that is woefully inconsistent (and penalized). He does struggle some with huge NT types but often does well. Think back to the Giants Playoff loss, how many sacks did Tuck (who had a monster postseason) have going against Kosier? Zero. How many tackles? One. The problem was, as it usually is when the Oline crumbles, the Tackles Colombo and Flow getting whipped by Osi and Strahan.
I’m not saying Kosier can’t be upgraded, I think he can and possibly will be this offseason, but it won’t matter any if late next year Flow and Colombo do what they always do (although Flow gets a slight reprieve because he was actually playing well until injured this year). I guess the injury concerns (with both our old Tackles) raises even more urgency to get another young Tackle in here.
I just hope the coaches can finally make the tough decision they couldn’t before the Vikings game and actually start Doug Free at one spot for good.
You do when that is your glaring area of need.
Is there really a guy on that line that couldn’t be upgraded? I would say Davis, and Kosier might be more consistent, but I can’t agree that he’s better. Dallas needs to upgrade their interior line push, and between Gurode, Davis, and Kosier, who do you feel is most lacking in power?
In all likelihood, Free will beat out Columbo. If Columbo can make the switch to guard, he has more power, can move fairly well when healthy, and has a mean streak. That’s an instant upgrade at 2 of 5 positions, in my opinion.
by Baked Potato Soup on Jan 31, 2010 4:56 PM CST up reply actions
Colombo will never play Guard,
Colombo is 6’8" with major flexibility/mobility leg injury issues and he’s always struggled (like the other real tall guys Davis and Flow) at the point because smaller faster guys get underneath them on short yardage and they’re not flexible and quick enough to counter.
The thing about Kosier is something that the eye ball test shows
when going up against bigger DTs or NTs he gets whipped, and we will see Haynesworth twice next year, Pat Williams again as well, I think he is very good against smaller but not strong enough to handle those big boys…IMO Gurode should take those bigguns anyways but they can scheme it to where its mostly Kosier taking them… why have a liability in there when we don’t have to have one
by nicholas.rodriguez on Feb 5, 2010 11:13 PM CST up reply actions
His intelligence is often dismissed by critics
However, he lacks the ability to get good push in the run game.
"Emotion is highly overrated in football. My wife Corky is emotional as hell but can't play football worth a damn."
- John McKay, the first coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers
He just can't hold up physically
I saw him get ran over by Jeremiah Trotter. A linebacker, not even a lineman. That can’t happen.
"Champagne for my real friends, real pain for my sham friends."
by DatNguyenNguyenScenario on Jan 30, 2010 10:12 PM CST reply actions
I don't recall
Koze getting badly run over but I do remember every other lineman we have having a bad game. HE might have a bad play every now and then but he is consistant.
MacGruber!
But consistently what?
consistenly overpowered by lineman and big linebackers? I don’t need that kind of consistency. They put Kosier on the move and have him pull so he can overpower the SAM who is likely going to be smaller than the middle linebacker.
"Champagne for my real friends, real pain for my sham friends."
by DatNguyenNguyenScenario on Jan 31, 2010 1:11 PM CST up reply actions
Well he's not consistently overpowered, he's consistently good at pass protection is what.
From the breakdowns I’ve seen he listed as having given up 1 sack all year. Colombo let in three times that many sacks in the playoff game alone! Davis gave up 5 sacks during the season at RG.
I want Oline change as much as anyone (I’ve been saying it for years) but lets not scapegoat Kosier for all the Lines woes because clearly the real problem lies in the Tackle spots.
He got whooped by Pat Williams
and beat by Haynesworth as well, I guess most guards get beat by them but if there is a position that can be upgraded on the Oline right now its both Flo and Kosier
by nicholas.rodriguez on Feb 5, 2010 11:14 PM CST up reply actions
Nice one BPS
On RW and the need to "run his routes properly [and] make a leap mentally. I don’t know whether it’s because he got sloppy in his years in Detroit or whether somebody has told him he is ‘a playmaker’, but RW needs to realize that in Dallas, there is no room for improvisation in route running. In Dallas, the offense is focused around Romo, not around a physically gifted WR, and Romo throws to where he expects WRs to be, not where they happen to end up because of free-form route running.
It is no coincidence that Miles Austin’s breakthrough come via focus on executing every play exactly right.
Sherman harped on Austin about it over multiple seasons. And the message sank in, which at least partially explains why he was able to put his considerable athletic skills on the track to fulfilling potential.
“It’s running the right route at the right depth all the time,” Austin says. “Don’t float upfield. Stay flat. Catch the ball every time. Look the ball in at practice.” From usatoday.
Somebody with access to gametapes should look at all the incompletes to RW, I’m pretty sure half of these were due to faulty/ wrong routes.
On trades, draft and free agency: With the Superbowl coming to Arlington this year, you can bet that Jerry will do whatever it takes to field a team that can make it to the SB in Cowboy Stadium. I expect a flurry of trades, FA acquisitions and moves up and down the draft boards that will have our collective BTB heads spinning in utter disbelief by the time it is over. This year, I think Jerry will out-Jerry himself.
by One.Cool.Customer on Jan 31, 2010 4:36 AM CST reply actions
I don't think it is
a sloppy thing. I believe he has a problem on the routes where sight adjustments are required. I have seen Roy pull up on a route when Romo thought he should have gone deep as an example. That is a typical difference in the west coast quick passing game versus the vertical passing game of the Cowboys. Michael Irvin once said those routes are a 50-50 proposition because you are depending on two people seeing the exact same thing at the exact same time to make the proper adjustments. It is not as easy as it looks.
That's why I hope that a second offseason will bear more fruit.
If he works as hard this year as everyone claimed that he did last year, I think we will see dramatic improvement. I think if he could contribute around 60-900-10, plus continued development of Ogletree as a speed receiver and slot receiver, plus steady-eddy Patrick Crayton, this passing offense will be much more efficient and dangerous.
by Baked Potato Soup on Jan 31, 2010 5:06 PM CST up reply actions
Interesting statistic
No team has ever played a Super Bowl in their home stadium.
"He just LOVES to play the game!" Yeah, because apparently the other 1499 NFL players do not. (/sarcasm)
Yep
no team had lost three straight regular season games and then won a superbowl.
by The Immortal Iron Fist AKA AFB on Feb 10, 2010 11:50 AM CST up reply actions
Agree On Moves Will Be Numerous
Dallas has a wide open window to take the next step. The need is there at key spots and BPS’s plan identifies the holes. This is a very deep draft due in part to the rookie salary cap threat meaning undergraduates are flocking to the draft. The restrictions imposed by the last year of the CBA mean sign and trades are going to be necessary to add the level of veteran talent that I bet Jerry is looking for this offseason. In all, I hope to see three new olinemen as the foundation for the major changes this offseason.
If you're right, OCC
It’s unlikely an O-lineman will get picked first.
If Jerry takes a “win now” approach, a WR or NT seems more likely, because it’s highly unlikely a rookie OT will win a starting job.
I say NT, because that could remake the defensive front and a stud run stopper could get on the field a lot as a rook, letting Rat slide out to DE in obvious passing situations.
What I want to know is what Cincy (who everyone thinks will take a TE like Gresham) would give up now for Telly B? a 2nd?
"Emotion is highly overrated in football. My wife Corky is emotional as hell but can't play football worth a damn."
- John McKay, the first coach of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Dexter McCluster
If Felix becomes the starter he will be out as kickoff returner. I think Dexter McCluster is exactly what the Cowboys need. Instantly, upgrades Ogletree and Crayton at kick/punt returner. Another 10-15 plays a grade in a Harvin/Bush type role and you give the offense another legit homerun threat. I do not think you can pull the trigger in the 1st round, but he might not be there in round 2.
What is everyones opinion of how McCluster could fit in on the Cowboys? I really like him!!
I like McCluster
but I don’t think he really fits where Dallas is drafting.
Now if Dallas traded down a few slots….
by The Immortal Iron Fist AKA AFB on Jan 31, 2010 12:53 PM CST up reply actions
I was really impressed with him in the cotton bowl
that guy is a player. I would love to have him. He played WR for some of the year before taking over at RB. He has great hands and would be dangerous in the return game.
That being said, I think it is imperative to get OL/DL/DB talent in the bank to develop. If we went after McCluster, I would assume it’s because we got rid of Barber. If that is so, then we better get a draft pick for him or a lineman with talent.
Ich bin ein Berliner--JFK
As a Razorbacks fan..
I HATE Dex, but as a fan of the sport…holy crap is that guy fast. Like, Chris Johnson fast, like…you just see a blue and red blur when he runs by…i’d take that kid in a heartbeat, but I think we’d be under using his potential
Michael Irvin to Keyshawn Johnson "I know where me and Rice belong on the top ten receivers of all time list, but who do you have in the bottom 8?"
Chris Johnson has a nickname courtesy of KSK
“Cop Speed”
Ignore the Mainstream Media, EMBRACE THE HATE!!!!
Agree
I agree not in the 1st round where Dallas is currently picking, but I really think he is a difference maker as Jerry likes to say.
Hamlin is probably not coming back
But I don’t really want Ball to be the permanent starting FS. He’s been OK as a backup, but if they let Hamlin walk, I’d rather see them bring in a potential play making FS, like Nate Allen or Morgan Burnett.
Drago says, "We must break you!"
I'd feel comfy with Ball full time
he has a ton of talent and looked like he was getting closer to the ball all the time.
Ich bin ein Berliner--JFK
I'm not the biggest fan of..
Alan “where’s the” Ball. He didn’t really show me anything when he started, I don’t get where people see this from. He is NOT an upgrade over Hamlin. Hamlin aint great, but on pretty much any team under any coach Hamlin would start over Ball
Michael Irvin to Keyshawn Johnson "I know where me and Rice belong on the top ten receivers of all time list, but who do you have in the bottom 8?"
I'm with you Mark,
I’m not sure what Ball’s done to get people so high on him.
He’s a young guy who might develop further but currently he’s not the answer to anything.
Eitehr or...
on Allen or Burnett… I don’t care which one just get one
by nicholas.rodriguez on Feb 5, 2010 11:19 PM CST up reply actions
ps
i will admit I seen dramatic improvement from him, if it continues, then we’ll see..as of right now..no
Michael Irvin to Keyshawn Johnson "I know where me and Rice belong on the top ten receivers of all time list, but who do you have in the bottom 8?"

by 























