Saw this posed as a comment in the DMN Blog yesterday and tried to get a response as a comment in a thread. With little feedback, believe this needs more visibility to get better response.

I feel the premise puts a very contentious, long simmering issue into stark relief - Tony Romo's perception as a championship-caliber QB. The device to do this is both clever and telling, allowing proponents and opponents a context for the evaluation. Nebulous designations, such as elite, are eliminated; impossible to prove concepts such as leadership, become irrelevant as they are implied in the response

Without further ado: