Dallas Cowboys Notes: Phil Costa to Start Sunday at Left Guard
Lost in the doom and gloom of the Tony Romo injury and the defensive collapse against the New York Giants was the fact that a couple of other key Dallas Cowboys were injured in the game as well. While Terence Newman is likely to be a game-time decision after limited participation in practice with a rib injury, Montrae Holland (groin) and Jason Hatcher (groin) have been ruled out against the Jaguars on Sunday and could have just as much an overall effect on the Cowboys chances as the loss of Tony Romo.
With Holland out, and starter Kyle Kosier still suffering from an achilles injury, the Cowboys have decided to start rookie Phil Costa at left guard against the Jaguars according to Nick Eatman. This will be Costa's first career start yet the most alarming aspect of the decision is that Costa has had just one week of practice at the guard position in his entire pro career.
Costa, throughout training camp and the preseason, took snaps exclusively as the team's backup center to Andre Gurode. After beating out Travis Bright as the team's second center, Costa showed good instincts as a center both in calling the protections and as an effective blocker.
One theory, after Holland was injured, was that the Cowboys could move Gurode to guard (where he has experience) and put Costa in at center. This would keep Costa in a relatively safer comfort zone, yet it's obvious that the Cowboys are reluctant to have the injury affect two positions along the offensive line and would rather maintain some semblance of continuity by keeping Gurode at center.
This would make sense if Tony Romo were still the Cowboys starting quarterback. Yet backup Jon Kitna is now starting, who had extensive time working with Costa as the backup quarterback and center during the preseason and throughout practices in the season. While it's impossible for us to know exactly what comfort level exists between Kitna and Costa, it's safe to say it's likely that Kitna is much more familiar with the backup center than he is Gurode at this point.
All that being said, these are pro football players. Kitna is a veteran quarterback and Gurode -- despite his shortcomings -- is still at least an average center with significant experience under center. If neither can find a way to make their new partnership work, then there is nothing that could be done.
Wade Phillips talked with the media today and expressed concern over the change in snap counts and the differing rhythms between Tony Romo and Jon Kitna. [ESPN Dallas]
"His snap count is a little different," Phillips said of Kitna. "It bothers me a little bit in that we had some troubles with false start and those kinds of things. We had a couple in the ball game and having a new quarterback we work hard on that and trying to concentrate on that. We certainly don’t want penalties with a new quarterback and a different count everybody has to concentrate and focus more."
Rick Gosselin chatted with the readers over at the Dallas Morning News yesterday and had this to say about the decision on sticking with Kitna instead of turning to Stephen McGee:
I wouldn't punt on the season just yet. The Cowboys have lost five games -- but everyone else in the NFC has lost at least two. I see some 10-6 records winning division titles. That means 9-7 wild cards. Can the Cowboys go 8-2 the rest of the way? They certainly have the talent, even with Jon Kitna at quarterback.
[snip]
If this team is 4-5 at that point, then I'd continue with Kitna. If the Cowboys are 2-7 or 1-8, then I'd start Stephen McGee at home Nov. 21 against the Detroit Lions. If you can't be good, be young.
36 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I like what Rick Gosselin said.
People are giving up before it’s over.
My math tells me that the Cowboys have to lose 3 more games before the season is actually over.
My statistical knowledge and logic is on vacation until this happens.
If you can't be good, be young.
That about sums it up, and I fully agree with it.
Also, if you can’t be good, put Tony on IR and give him the time and peace to heal properly.
by One.Cool.Customer on Oct 29, 2010 3:27 PM CDT reply actions
What? Kitna hasn't had enough snaps in TC and practice
over the past two years for everybody to have a relatively smooth transition to his cadence and count?
Seems to me there’s a lot more potentially snafu things going on around Valley Ranch than snap count, Wade.
"We'll see." --Bill Parcells
Have to remember that Kitna practices with the 2nd team.
Throughout camp, the preseason and few snaps they get during practice. Before Romo was hurt, you’re not seeing Kitna get any meaningful amount of snaps with the majority of the starters.
Defending Big D - Dallas Stars news & analysis
Blogging The Boys - Dallas Cowboys, all the time.... since 2005
by Brandon Worley on Oct 29, 2010 4:47 PM CDT up reply actions
I presume you're right about this.
I hear it all the time. But it seems pretty short-sighted.
“We’ll have a backup in case we need him, but we won’t ever practice him with the unit he’d play with.”
"We'll see." --Bill Parcells
hasn't Kinta always had snap issue since coming to Dallas
iirc, this has been reported since his arrival. moving an at best average center to guard for a rookie to step in as the center is asking for a complete disaster. i couldn’t care less who takes what snaps with what unit, making 2 position switches when there only a need for 1 makes it twice as much work & bigger mess.
going against the Jags DL can’t get any easier for a rookie to start in & it’ll give them a good measuring stick to see if Costa has any potential. just as long as Free doesn’t decide to sit his stance & allow Kampman (sp) a clear path to Kitna they should be ok against one of the weakest DLs in the NFL
i agree with brandon's implication
i think it would be wiser to move gurode to G and let costa start at C. not only is kitna used to him, it puts the rook in a more protected position where he has more practice. since gurode has a lot of experience at G and is a vet, it seems like this would be an easier transition than asking a rookie with one week of practice at G start there.
as for continuity along the line, that was shot a long time ago. kosier, then holland. davis, then holland, then back to davis. i just don’t see how continuity is such a high value.
Plus, you see Costa at his best position
We need some answers on the oline, and Costa is one of precious few prospects. Lets see him at his best position, which I assume is C (ie why he played there all camp). If he plays well, we know we have two pieces of our future line (Free/Costa) instead of just one.
If he sucks at guard, we still don’t know if he’s got a future as a starter.
Check out my movie - Standards of Ethical Conduct
by cowboysuberfan on Oct 29, 2010 4:37 PM CDT up reply actions
I agree
Looking back at our O-Line picks the last few years you can see why we’re in trouble.
2002
2nd round Gurode (Starting C)
6th – Tyson Walter OG (3 years with the Cowboys then jumped around to different teams and is currently a FA)
2003
2nd – Al Johnson C (IR as a rookie was on the team in 2004, currenlty a FA)
7th – Justin Bates OG (I don’t think he made the team)
2004
2nd – Jacob Rogers OT (Injured never made an impact and is out of football)
3rd – Stephen Peterman OG (2 seasons with Dallas currently with Detroit)
2005
6th – Rob Petitti OT (One season with Dallas currently with Carolina)
2006
7th – Pat McQuistan OT (5 years a backup with Dallas currently a starter with Miami)
2007
3rd – James Martin OT (1 year with Dallas, currently with Chicago)
4th – Doug Free OT (Starter with Dallas)
2008
None
2009
3rd – Robert Brewster OT (Cowboys practice squad)
2010
6th Sam Young OT (On the 53 man roster)
I expect an adventure out of the offense going forward:
a) False Starts
b) Lots of Sacks
c) Botched Snaps
d) Crappy/Non-Existent Running game
e) Errant throws that will be tipped and or picked off
However, I is it too much to expect the following:
a) That the special teams return units give us favorable field position since our offense is going to be riding the little yellow school bus without Romo at the helm.
b) That the defense finally grow a pair and prove that they have the mental toughness and intestinal fortitude to show up and dominate week in and week out like they have been billed to do so. Now more than ever, we need this defense to step up and carry the offense; it’s only fair since Romo has carried this team on his backs since mid-2006.
c) Sticking with comments about the defense: I am calling out Newman to step up his game and make some plays on balls, and not just intercept passes thrown directly at him. I am calling out Mike Jenkins to stop getting flagged for pass interference. Seriously, right now you are the Alex Barron of the secondary, and your weekly pi calls are coming at the most inopportune times making which becomes a buzz kill for whatever momentum we might have. I am calling out Sensebaugh, ever since you failed to make a play on that deep sideline throw to Sidney Rice in the divisional playoffs last year you have become a black hole at strong safety. Great, it’s one thing for it to be too much for you to be a ball hawk, but it’s another thing for you tackle worse than my 18 year old sister. Seriously, CMON MAN! For all the bone head plays Roy Williams 31 made, at least he hit people. Ball and Scandrick are too garbage to warrant being called out, however, that doesn’t mean Bradie James and Keith Brooking are beyond reproach. Seriously, you two are supposed control the middle of the field and not let tight ends and RBs kill us in the passing game. What gives? Especially Brooking, last year you were the emotional leader of this team, you killed yourself on every down and before every game in the pre-game chants to fire this team up and make plays. This year I don’t see that from you. This leads me to ask whether or not you’re a front runner with fake intensity that only manifests itself when the times are good. I thought you’d be the one person on this defense who did not want the unit to continue to be embarrassed after the Vikings ran up the score in the playoffs. However, outside of the Redskins and Texans game, where the hell have you and your defense been?
d) I am calling out Jason Witten. Seriously man, what gives with all these bonehead plays that seem to keep manifesting each successive week. Have you taken one too many hits to the head? Did that long catch and carry 3 years ago in Philly when you lost your helmet also result in lost brain cells? It’s not a good sign when in every game I think of ways in which your lapses in mental focus will come back to bite us. The ball either bounces off your ankle for a pick 6; the ball goes through your hands off your chest for a pick; a well timed throw goes incomplete cause you forgot to turn your head; or you get false start penalties; or you drop passes when we need to pick up a first down; or you fumble the ball when you’re going down to the ground and only have one hand securing it. As one of the team’s leaders, you are supposed to be less prone to bonehead plays than everyone else.
e) Wade Stop looking so derpy befuddled on the sidelines when something goes wrong, you’re the damn head coach, however, you make Mike Singletary more of a viable option than your portly woe is me display.
f) Campo, seriously, the next time one of your DBs screws up, instead of looking like you have no clue what’s going on, get into their faces and demand they play correctly.
It's only a dream till you write it down, and then it becomes a goal.
-Emmitt Smith
you made some great points an I haven't laughed that hard in a while
by 0k on Oct 29, 2010 6:03 PM CDT up reply actions
Honestly, this team needs Lou Brown from the Major League movies to rip into them
It's only a dream till you write it down, and then it becomes a goal.
-Emmitt Smith
I know man, it sucks
It's only a dream till you write it down, and then it becomes a goal.
-Emmitt Smith
lol Campo
I actually saw him b*tch out Newman last year and they Newman went after him
it worked though
either the Seahawks or Falcons game it was
by Archie Barberio on Oct 29, 2010 6:20 PM CDT up reply actions
Wade and Campo need to be fired at the end of the season
It's only a dream till you write it down, and then it becomes a goal.
-Emmitt Smith
the whole regime needs to be fired.
Jerry the GM, Jerry the HC, Wade the HC, Wade the DC, Garrett the assistant HC, Garrett the OC, Campo, JoeD. fire all of them & take Davis, Colombo, Barber, Bennett, Ogletree, Spears, Brooking, J.Williams, L.Williams ALAN BALL, SCANDRICK. i’m sure Sensabaugh is on that list also with his contract due & poor play but he looked like a solid SS when Kenny Hamlin was the FS last season. it might be a case where he’s trying to do more then his job with Brooking & Ball flat out playing horrible.
I have bought 7 new shirts and 2 new jereys to ensure that I can bring as much good "karma" or "mojo" to the boys for the next 10 weeks..
GO KITNA!!!!! KITNA’S COWBOYS CAN DO THIS!!!
Even a turd in the bowl can occasionally score a goal...
I bought 4 caps, an Authentic Romo, a Dez Replica, an Aikman throwback and Dorsett Throwback
And all I get in return is 1-5 with my favorite player basically out for the season. Well, at least I didn’t let teams in Fantasy Football hold me hostage in trading for Romo, otherwise my teams would be toast right now.
It's only a dream till you write it down, and then it becomes a goal.
-Emmitt Smith
yeah I feel yeah
I just got my white authentic Dez last week in the mail, its pretty fresh by the way
in May I got a authentic blue throwback Dez too
so thats like 500 bucks in jerseys and 1-5
well it is what it is
but I was right about Dez Bryant!
by Archie Barberio on Oct 29, 2010 6:15 PM CDT up reply actions
When I saw his reaction to being drafted by us I had a feeling we had the next Michael Irvin instead of the next Michael Crabtree
It's only a dream till you write it down, and then it becomes a goal.
-Emmitt Smith
yessir
I couldnt believe we got him
I disregarded all the Dez hype leading up to the draft, I thought he would be gone
then he kept getting passed on, then the Denver Christians I mean the Denver Broncos drafted Demariyus Thomas after Mother Theresa and Jesus were crossed off their board due to them being deceased and I was like man maybe the media was right
easiestly the happiest draft memory i will ever have
by Archie Barberio on Oct 30, 2010 12:10 AM CDT up reply actions
Thank you Tim Tebow, I mean Jesus, for McDaniels picking Thomas
As bad as Dallas fans think of Wade, he’s still better than Joshie boy. (Rod Woodson, who I dislike quite a bit, said McDaniels should write a book, “How to Completely Destroy a Team in 2 Seasons” which is probably the funniest thing the guy’s ever said, and totally accurate)
"I'm not gonna hold my head down. I'm gonna fight until this damn thing is over, period!" Jay Ratliff
by APerfectStar on Oct 30, 2010 4:22 AM CDT up reply actions
thats a nice choice of words when describing Denvers draft "Christians", "Mother Theresa" & "Jesus"
i don’t get how that translates to who they wanted to draft or the type of players they want representing there organization. D.Thomas is a player that has great character & the skillset to be a star WR in this league so it was win – win situation for both organizations. its like choosing A.Johnson or L.Fitzgerald, you couldn’t go wrong with either.
now, since they did pass on him then it was a no brainer to draft Dez, especially since Roy hadn’t shown signs of taking pressure off Austin & Dez was ranked a top10 talent. if Dez can handle the success without becoming a diva, distraction or another TO then look out bc he’s a freak. Dez reminds me a lot like A.Johnson but with a sightly better skillset & hopefully we see that player emerge without a bunch of drama.
If Kitna is a total disaster
Which I don’t think he will be, then I’d love for them to insert McGee and see how he does in a real game. It could speed up the timetable for deciding on his future, and more important, show how seriously Dallas should be looking for another young QB to groom. McGee has the ability to scramble which might be a necessity behind the OL.
Maybe Kitna gets injured, and they find out that way, although I’m not wishing anything bad on Kitna.
"I'm not gonna hold my head down. I'm gonna fight until this damn thing is over, period!" Jay Ratliff
Jerrys not waving the white flag before the middle of the season
Jerrys still trying to fill the seats & atleast keep the money flowing in. as bad as Kitna is atleast he’s a name people have heard of & they can still even win some games with him. once you see McGee its either bc Kitna got blown up or its a complete disaster & it doesn’t matter anymore. then you’ll see a bunch of young players sneaking into the game as it goes on…

by 























