A Look At The Impact Of The Cowboys Recent Roster Moves
On Saturday, the Cowboys trimmed their roster down from 75 players to 53. Some of the cuts/trades were foreseen, but others came as a great surprise to the players, as well as to fans and critics alike. Of the 22 players cut/traded, four may have a profound impact on the outcome of the Cowboys 2010 season due to their departures...
Patrick Crayton was shipped to the San Diego Chargers on Saturday for a conditional seventh-round pick in the 2011 draft that can become a sixth if he catches over 40 balls. Crayton's departure was not a surprising one, as the Cowboys were never going to carry six receivers - especially with Dez Bryant fully recovered from a high ankle sprain he suffered in San Antonio.
With Crayton leaving, Romo loses one of his most trusted receivers. Crayton is a very crafty and intelligent receiver that knows how to find the holes in the opposing secondary's coverage. Romo knows this, and is why he always looked for Crayton when he was either flushed from the pocket or under duress. Think back to the second game against the New York Giants in 2008; Romo is flushed out to his right, finds Crayton down the field for a touchdown. Against the Atlanta Falcons in 2009; Romo avoids four would be pass-rushers, and then finds Crayton open in the end zone for the touchdown. Or, the first game against the Washington Redskins in 2009; Romo is flushed out of the pocket, runs left, and finds Crayton sitting between two defenders for the game-winning touchdown.
Crayton might not be the most physically gifted receiver, but he is a crisp route runner that makes timely plays and brings a level of consistency to the field each and every week; a level that the Cowboys may no longer have.
After the jump, the three other key departures.
Defensive tackle Junior Siavii was released on Saturday. While Siavii is not necessarily the most dynamic player, he brought something to the Cowboys that they do not have much of along the defensive line: a big body. Siavii tips the scales at 325lbs. The heaviest player on the Cowboys roster after Siavii is Josh Brent (DT), who currently weighs in at 315lbs (but reportedly played at 320lbs in college). After Brent, every player along the defensive line is sub-310lbs. This is not necessarily a bad thing, but still, somewhat surprising. One would think that it would be advantageous for a defense to carry a ‘bigger' defensive lineman on the roster in case the smaller linemen are overwhelmed by an opposing teams' much larger offensive line.
The loss of Siavii is not a particularly worrying one, yet it still removes an experienced veteran and puts the onus of backing up Jay Ratliff on an unproven rookie, Josh Brent.
Cornerbacks Cletis Gordon and Bryan McCann were both - surprisingly - released on Saturday. Gordon had performed quite well in training camp and preseason games, but was victimized, as was McCann, in the final preseason game against the Miami Dolphins first-string players.
The release of these two players leaves the Cowboys with only three ‘true' cornerbacks - Terence Newman, Mike Jenkins and Orlando Scandrick. Of course there are the two cornerback converted safeties, in Alan Ball and Akwasi Owusu-Ansah; could they provide the necessary depth?
Owusu-Ansah, while immensely gifted - athletically, is still a rookie from a Division II college that has only played in three NFL preseason games, and is currently trying to learn the free safety position.
Alan Ball could fill in at corner quite adequately. However, by moving Ball to corner, instead of one positioned being weakened, now two are adversely affected: cornerback and free safety, as Mike Hamlin would have to step in at free safety to replace the void left by Ball moving to cornerback.
It is great that the Cowboys believe Ball and Owusu-Ansah have the versatility necessary to play both positions (cornerback and safety) adequately. Yet it isn't out of the realm of possibilities that the starting secondary lineup could look like this at some stage during this season:
Orlando Scandrick (CB)
Alan Ball (CB)
Mike Hamlin (FS)
Gerald Sensabaugh (SS)
Now try and tell me that doesn't scare you.
These decisions may or may not affect the Cowboys 2010 season and their Super Bowl aspirations. With a bit of luck you may never have to know. If Miles Austin continues to perform at a high level and Dez Bryant plays the way he trains, Patrick Crayton will become a distant memory. If Jay Ratliff stays healthy and Josh Brent is only asked to play a handful of snaps a game, no one will remember who Junior Siavii is by season's end. If all the cornerbacks stay healthy, we'll never have to see what happens if the starting secondary lineup was as aforementioned.
And even if everything doesn't go as smoothly as one could hope, find solace in the fact that Jerry Jones and Co. haven't made many mistakes - personnel-wise in the last couple of years.
68 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Yeah, I'm in that boat with you
The YouTube of the Atlanta play shows Crayton’s football savvy.
While the cameras were focused on Romo ducking & dodging, over his shoulder you can see PC watching him move while PC matches Romo’s direction, but along the back of the endzone. And, then Romo sees him, PC’s open (because he made himself be open) and we get 6.
Who does that for Romo this season?
When in doubt, empty your magazine
I agree about Witten
But I think of the 3 you list, only JW has similar smarts as PC. Dez, maybe in a yr or 2.
Roy? Roy can catch the fade as long as he looks back and leaves the ‘frying pan’ hands in the locker room.
Gronk staying in the backfield to help block is the only thing I can see that would free Witten to roam the endzone like PC did. Or, since he has hands, maybe the dump off or shovel pass to save Romo’s life.
When in doubt, empty your magazine
No one knows yet.
Someone will have to step up and fill that void. Crayton was excellent at getting open and making himself an easy target for Romo. Without him, we may see a few more sacks and throw aways from no. 9.
Welcome aboard Martin.
The only one that worries me is the release of Gordon.
Here’s to our top 3 corners staying healthy this year.
No worries seeing Junior let go. Josh Brent is younger and looks to be a better back up for the future.
Off topic: But who we rooting for Thursday night?
Go Cowboys.....Go White Sox.....
Vikings
We want them to be feeling all good about themselves when we get up there so we can stomp them and wave our fingers in their faces and say, “ah, ah, ah, not so fast beeches, hope you enjoy the move to LA!”
Deaf as a stone, dumb as a Bohr.
Ill be rooting for the vikings.. i think
really it doesnt matter because Brees will succumb to the Madden Curse and Favre will get hurt there is no way he does another year like last year.
I just want a good game where each team beats each other up and it comes down to a 31-28 victory.
Really?! Really?!
Saints
After the stupid running up of the score, I’ll be rooting for Favre to run out of bounds and straight into Childress’ alien-shaped egghead, taking them both out for the season.
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
lol good one hehehe
woman !, dont try to understand em, dont try to make them understand you, for they are a breed apart ! lol
refs !!! loil
woman !, dont try to understand em, dont try to make them understand you, for they are a breed apart ! lol
I thought getting of Crayton was dumb.
He was the 2nd best WR on this team last year. Letting McCann go ain’t real smart either IMO, I guess the Cowboys don’t buy in the thought " you can’t have to many good CBs".
Lock n Load
i dont see how moving ball to CB adversely effects two positions
Given that our next best option at fourth corner was gordon and ball manned that spot better than him, and given the abundance of decent options at safety I think that this works out to keep the secondary as strong as possible with the given talent. So I think this move only really effects the FS position and does it by a smaller margin than the other options that we had a corner
I actively recognize my own stupidity, thank you!!!
by levcd on Sep 7, 2010 11:26 AM CDT via mobile reply actions
Release of Gordon and McCann...
…is the one that disturbs me the most.
It’s happened before where two — and sometimes three corners sustain injuries in one game.
Corner depth — with playmaking ability (which applies to BOTH Gordon and McCann as a possible 4th CB) — can only help a team.
I could understand keeping McCray OR Church for special teams — but BOTH?!?!
This move still perplexes me.
Btw, great post, Martin!
Is playing smart too much to ask?
McCray and Church are completely different players
McCray is a lights-out special teams gunner, but really has no chance of ever starting at safety in this league.
Church handled one of the toughest assignments a strong safety can draw in having to cover Antonio Gates and handled it as well as any rookie possibly could. In the same game, he performed as the most reliable run-stopper on the field. But his special teams play is nothing to write home about.
They’re not interchangeable, in fact, they’re really on quite opposite trajectories right now.
by Blue Eyed Devil on Sep 7, 2010 7:57 PM CDT up reply actions
One thing that's been bothering me,
is that we are stacked at the positions that don’t rotate much and thin on the outsides where there is more need for rotating. The O-line needs “continuity” and stuff and the D-line doesn’t rotate much. On the outside and TE, however, all those guys seem to need breathers, etc. and they seem to rotate more. Now they can’t rotate at all it seems and I worry this is gonna bite us in the butt big time. Especially later in the season when all the fast guys start getting nicked up. Happens every year doesn’t it?
I expect AOA to concentrate on corner this year and get the most rookie playing time outside of Dez, and Ball to go back and forth a bit in practice. This seems to be the plan, and I’m sorta ok with that. Nervous, because there’s nothing worse than having a great defense and yet giving up crushing long bombs. But I’m optimistic we’ll be just fine.
As for Crayton, I’m an Okie and a big fan of his, it’s disappointing but Dez and Bennett can more than make up his production and hopefully earn the trust of Romo on 3rd downs also. If that works it’s a major upgrade.
Deaf as a stone, dumb as a Bohr.
Our D-line rotates a lot.
During passing downs, Spears and Olshansky go out and Bowen and Hatcher come in. Last season, Bowen and Hatcher played nearly as many snaps as Spears and Olshansky.
Rabid and luvin' it
True
But my feeling is that those 2 are just about the only ones that rotate (much). The rest of them seem to play a lot of snaps to me. Hopefully the new guys can be good enough to force them all to rotate even more than they have. It would be great to see Brent, Butler, Hall of Fame and Lee et al really make an impact. I also wouldn’t mind if just ONE of the Williams guys would step it up a bit…
Deaf as a stone, dumb as a Bohr.
I can't take credit for that,
I think Lissyyy coined that one. I like it though, hope it sticks.
Deaf as a stone, dumb as a Bohr.
He didn't use it as a nickname
He is just convinced Lissamore is already destined for greatness.
If at first you don't succeed - blame someone else.
Our D-line rotates like Crazy
5 of our 7 D-linemen are bascially starters. And the team has stated they want a nose tackle that can allow Ratliff to rest more.
Another goal of this team was to rest Spencer and Ware more often which is a place we are the deepest at with Victor Butler and Brandon Williams.
TE and WR do rotate a lot, you’re right. But they rotate for eachother. You don’t need a 3rd TE to spell Marty B. When Dez Bryant steps on the field, Marty B steps off. Marty B will probobly never get more snaps in this offense than he got last year and didn’t show any signs of fatigue.
Backup CBs and safeties don’t see the field much… at least we all HOPE they don’t see the field much.
I can’t remember a time where rotational depth was less an issue than right now.
by Blue Eyed Devil on Sep 7, 2010 8:03 PM CDT up reply actions
Yeah, there's a lot making me nervous right now, particularly losing
Crayton. The first thing I thought of when I read about his trade was that Atlanta play; it was one of Romo’s great moments made greater by the fact that someone had gotten open to catch the pass.
Welcome to the Star-shaped Octagon, Martin
Wait, is that possible?? I hated geometry.
Anyway, key point with Crayton was his smarts in finding an open spot for Romo when things broke down. Not only did he have a good feel for the angles and lanes to get to the right spot, but he didn’t give up on plays once things got chaotic. Not sure who else besides Witten can do that for Tony now… Let’s hope Dez or The Tree can become that guy…
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
Nothing "profound"....
regarding these cuts. I’m sorry, it’s a fantasy. You can worry about any set of injuries, the immediate issue is the oline at any level. Aside from out of shape Holland doesn’t know the snap count. and doesn’t block that well when he does.
Columbo? Kosier? Gurode? L. Davis? All are worth concern.
Agree
We were all screaming post-draft about OT depth…Cowboys kept lots to provide the patchwork necessary this year and build for future years. A small sacrifice at CB/S is worth it.
Besides, all these “surprising” cuts had to be made, right? Would there have been any cuts that didn’t hurt?
I sort of think Cowboy managment.....
reflects the fan base which is so status quo and over appraising of the field talent as a tradition. Maybe this is the nature of all fans but it’s out of control regarding the Cowboys.
Clearly the oline is middle of the pack at best with some recent disasters that tell you the direction of things. Try talking about trading an older starter on this forum. The culture of hanging on and the many over valued contracts is clear. This is a self-destructive fan base that enables poor management decisions. So you should be upset by Cletis Gordon getting cut when the Cowboys are going to start Holland who is clearly out-of-shape and doesn’t know the snap count?
Part of it is the suck-up nature of would-be sports writers who dish out stories like this that flatter the core of cowboy decision making and focus on the margin that few care about and that will not change the field results at all. It’s the deadwood still on the team that is going to get killed this year.
It is concerning
Holland is not very athletic and struggles to move in space. Colombo & Kosier will be fine as long as they’re healthy. But as they’re not, there is a question mark hovering over both of them. Gurode and Davis are both good offensive lineman. However, they can be inconsistent. And last year in a few games — against the Vikings, Packers, Broncos — they looked terrible. Earlier this offseason, both players admitted they didn’t have their best seasons in 2009. Gurode looked rather good in training camp and preseason games. Davis, on the other hand, is never going to be an ultra-athletic guard, and that will always be his weakness. This offensive line — while not perfect — should be effective for at least one more season. But, yes, new blood is needed.
What?
I’m sorry, Scott, I just don’t understand math problems. I tried dividing by the 4, but that didn’t help, so then I subtracted 2 As from each side. What does it all mean? OCC
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
I could tell you what it means
But then the Wolf would hunt me down and neutralize me with extreme prejudice.
by One.Cool.Customer on Sep 7, 2010 2:05 PM CDT up reply actions
I sleep in different houses every night now
not knowing when the Wolf will be at my door. We all saw what happened to DalaiLuke. Dude disappeared for WEEKS just for one humorous comment.
I hear a helicopter. Gotta go!
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
and with Gordon
does he fit into the class of the veteran player who if he’s on the roster on week 1 he’s guaranteed his full season salary, so does the fact that despite being projected by almost everyone to make the Cowboys’ 53 he still hasn’t signed with another team mean that perhaps they’ll bring him back after week 1, so they can have him on the roster but not owe him for the full season in case they need to make room for someone else later?
I hope he signs somewhere else....
if that’s a “plan”. How Petty is My Valley? Should be a book title if that is what the managment thinks about.
Finding better players should be the goal, watching them sit with this oline is annoying.
So if no other team thinks he's good enough to sign him, we snap him back up?
I don’t quite follow that logic.
If at first you don't succeed - blame someone else.
well
if he knows the Cowboys are planning to sign him next week, he may turn down any offers from other teams and wait for next week to resign with the Cowboys. He could still get the same pay, it’s just not guaranteed for the season. Not saying it is going to happen, but it could be what’s happening.
Yeah, forgot he could refuse an offer
Still a risk of someone else putting a little more money on the table and taking him. I am just thinking that Campo or Wade sees something different in the secondary than us fan types.
If at first you don't succeed - blame someone else.
I heard...
That he’d be the fourth corner, but would still be focusing on making the transition to free safety. The rookie is going to have a lot on his plate.
What, no Redskins fans over here stirring the pot?
This is Dallas week, it’s like their SB.
Lock n Load
Unfortunately...
Foreskins territory extends deep in VA. I have to put up with it in Richmond too.
When in doubt, empty your magazine
Ain't it the truth...
Stand back-to-back and defend the Star!
OORAH
When in doubt, empty your magazine
Roy Williams' presence continues to negatively impact The Cowboys.
I look forward to the day when the Roy nightmare is over. I would have loved to have seen Roy leave instead of Patrick. The secondary does concern me. Any injury to our top corners or regression in the pass rush could be disastrous.
Work is the scourge of the drinking classes.-Oscar Wilde
I'm not sure if RW is a negative influence on the team
as much as he is to the fans. All accounts have Roy as a great teammate and person. He still has the ability to be explosive and opposing defensive coordinators have to gameplan against him and every minute they focus on him is a minute they can’t plan against Miles, Witten and Dez
Miles Austin: Covered
Jason Witten: Covered
Roy Williams: Wide Open
Trusting Your Wide Receiver To Make The Catch: Priceless
I tend to agree
I think he’s a non-factor to the team. If he performs well, great. If not, they have too many other weapons to worry about Roy’s lack of production.
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
18 dropped 3rd down passes
Would seem to indicate he’s an extreme liability.
by Blue Eyed Devil on Sep 7, 2010 8:07 PM CDT up reply actions
And 7 touchdowns
which was considerably more than Witten. Just saying, he’s not detracting from the team because they have other options. And we saw how that worked – Garrett put other guys on the field and Romo looked for other WRs running routes.
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
Welcom Martin....
For those that want to know, Jamar Wall and Byran McCann were offered practice squad positions. Wall was taken by Houston and McCann by Baltimore. Junior Savaii went to Seattle and Marcus Dixon went to the Jets.
And...
Curtis Johnson went to the Rams:
http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/players/playerpage/1599759/curtis-johnson
Rabid and luvin' it
On your disaster scenario in the D-backfield
It is scary, but I’d be no less scared if you had Ball remaining at safety and plugged in Cletis Gordon or Bryan McCann at CB. If we lose both of our Pro Bowl corners for any extended amount of time, we’re screwed no matter what.
And, welcome Martin. Nice post.
by East Bay Ray on Sep 7, 2010 2:38 PM CDT reply actions 1 recs
The Gordon cut doesn't bother me.
He got lit up in his last 2 pre-season games, and he was a journeyman to begin with. Keeping him as the 4th CB doesn’t help us any if he actually has to take some snaps. If Campo, et al., think we are better served with AOA (who was a corner in college) or Ball sliding over, then I will defer to their decision.
The Crayton cut was a little more surprising. I recognized his value to the team as a safety valve for Romo, but the more he plays, the more he holds Dez back, which doesn’t make any sense. Besides, I still haven’t forgiven Crayton for the Giants playoff loss in 2007. We win that game – and possibly go to the Super Bowl – if he either catches the ball from Romo on the left sideline with about 4 minutes left, or if he doesn’t pull up on his route in the end zone with 20 seconds left.
What about the dropped ball on the crossing route after Romo's houdini-style escape?
That would have gone for 20 yards.
I didn’t want Crayton to go, but I understand it. They have young talent they want on the field and PC was too expensive to be a 4th WR. Please don’t ask me why RW is still on the roster except that they hope he’ll come around.
FREE THE OGLETREE!!!
That's part of the problem...
it sounds like Campo wanted to keep Gordon:
http://espn.go.com/blog/dallas/cowboys/post/_/id/4671762/akwasi-owusu-ansah-is-the-fourth-corner
The release of Gordon stunned many.
“We thought he did fine, but I don’t make the final decision,” secondary coach Dave Campo said of Gordon. “We felt it was best for the team.”
Rabid and luvin' it
Good to see the new blood coming in.
Glad BTB didn’t decide to overpay its aging veterans and went instead with a youth movement, bringing in fresh talent and letting the vet who wanted a new team move on.
Wonder where you guys got the idea?
If at first you don't succeed - blame someone else.
by Tom Ryle on Sep 7, 2010 6:27 PM CDT reply actions 1 recs
welcome martin !
lookin forward to your thoughts on the boyz !
woman !, dont try to understand em, dont try to make them understand you, for they are a breed apart ! lol
your worrying about injuries is a bit useless
Orlando Scandrick (CB)
Alan Ball (CB)
Mike Hamlin (FS)
Gerald Sensabaugh (SS)
well so what?
what is our starting receivers were ogletree and manny johnson by the end of the year?what if jon kitna is the qb.
I don't think you understand, Pete...
One or two injuries to the CB position won’t just affect the CB position; it will affect the safety postion as well. Ball will have to move back to CB, which means an unproven safety, in Mike Hamlin, will have to step in.
Yet, if the Cowboys had kept McCann or Gordon, there would be no need for this re-shuffle. Ball could remain at FS and McCann, Gordon and/or AOA could fill in.
Wouldn’t you feel pretty bad if the Cowboys only carried three WRs. so if one went down, Witten had to permanently split out wide? It would be a hit to WR position, as Witten while a great receiving tight end, isn’t a Miles Austin or Dez Bryant in terms of being dynamic. Also, it takes Witten away from the TE position, thus weaking not one but two positions.
It isn’t about the injuries, per se, but the consequences of those injuries, and how profound they may be to the defense as a whole and not just isolated to one position.
http://www.twitter.com/BTB_Long
i see what you mean
but i think the chances of two going down in one game is slim and if there are any long term injuries free agency will have someone who we can use for a few games. i still think mike Hamlin could start so I’m not worried. but i wish there was a bit more experience in the secondary. would ease the concerns. good article though man welcome to the site.
by Pete Mccullagh on Sep 10, 2010 11:48 AM CDT reply actions
They are slim, yes
But as we saw with New Orleans last season, they lost both their starting corners. Fortunately for them, they had some good depth and signed a couple of free agents that did a good job filling in.
Anyway, thanks for welcome, man. Much appreciated.
http://www.twitter.com/BTB_Long

by 





















