SB Nation Dallas Editor's Pick
Wade filled the roster through FA: that needs to change
I think there is a point that is being missed. Here is the starting roster on opening day 2010:
Doug Free: 4th round, 2007
Kyle Kosier: FA
Andre Gurode: 2nd round, 2002
Leonard Davis: FA
Marc Colombo: FA
Tony Romo: UDFA, 2003
Marion Barber III: 4th round, 2005
Jason Witten: 3rd round, 2003
Martellus Bennett: 2nd round, 2008
Roy Williams: Trade
Miles Austin: UDFA, 2006
Igor Olshansky: FA
Jay Ratliff: 7th round, 2005
Marcus Spears: 1st round, 2005
DeMarcus Ware: 1st round, 2005
Anthony Spencer: 1st round 2007
Keith Brooking: FA
Bradie James: 4th round, 2003
Gerald Sensabaugh: FA
Alan Ball: 7th round, 2008
Terence Newman: 1st round, 2003
Mike Jenkins: 1st round, 2008
Parcells stunk up the second round, but look at the starters that were either drafted or recruited as undrafted free agents (UDFA). Every one was drafted under the Parcells regime with the exception of Andre Gurode (Campo), Doug Free, Anthony Spencer, Martellus Bennett, and Alan Ball.
I would argue that Ball should not have been the starting free safety last season, and doubt many will disagree. That means that under Wade Phillips' tenure, the Cowboys only drafted Free, Bennett, and Spencer as starters over the last four drafts. In order not to be viewed as strictly bashing Wade, add Felix Jones to that list instead of Marion Barber III.
Under Bill Parcells (whom I am not a huge fan of either) the Cowboys drafted or acquired as rookie free agents, eight players (Barber III excluded again) over a four year span of drafts. Wade added next to nothing to this team over the last four seasons through the draft: one starter per draft.
Parcells averaged two starters per draft. Not great, but much better than Wade and Jerry. Wade built this starting unit by acquiring free agents. Every free agent (FA) noted above save Kyle Kosier and Marc Colombo, was brought in with Wade as coach.
Only Leonard Davis has made a Pro Bowl as a Cowboy after being acquired under Wade via free agency. I believe that these big names give the national illusion of just how talented this team is, when in reality, it is just a hodge-podge of over-priced, underperforming, old free agents...
Much like the Redskins!
Trust me...that hurt to write...A LOT!
It seems obvious to me that Jerry relies heavily on the input of the head coach when making draft decisions. If this is true, then this draft will be as successful as Garrett is as a talent evaluator. Listening to the rumblings coming out of Valley Ranch (via Matt Mosley), the scouts are thrilled with the autonomy and importance Jason is giving them.
This team needs to build through the draft, as past champions have. The window for these players is closing, and it would truly be a shame to have Witten, Austin, Romo, Ware, and Ratliff leave the hallowed halls of Valley Ranch without a championship because of poor coaching and poor drafting: both of which are on Jerry.
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
37 comments
|
4 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
What makes the situation even worse
is that many of the guys drafted during Wade’s tenure will be free agents after this season, or already are, like Doug Free.
Anthony Spencer, Felix Jones, Martellus Bennett, Tashard Choice, Orlando Scandrick are all free agents after the season (if the new CBA brings back free agency after four years).
Doug Free, with one good season, will want to be paid like a top ten tackle this year. Imagine if every one of the above free agents has a breakout year in 2011. Will the Cowboys give them an extension based on their 2011 play – which they’ll be asking for – or a contract based on the rather less spectacular early years of their contract.
That’s a major issue with the way the Cowboys develop their talent.
by One.Cool.Customer on Apr 22, 2011 3:09 PM CDT reply actions 1 recs
VERY Well said OCC!
And good work ScarletO…
I can only imagine how hard that Redskins line was to write and I absolutely (though disheartedly) agree with you. We need to start using the draft better in countless ways. Championship Teams are made through great drafting and great coaching. I feel we have and will be taking big steps in both categories
"I am a true believer. Anthony Spencer will have 7 or more sacks in 2011 and Stephen Bowen can ball!" - Kegbearer
"Football is an incredible game. Sometimes it's so incredible, it's unbelievable."
- Tom Landry
I'll give you coaching
I’m completely sold on Garrett as a coach and I have no doubt he will do well but, the Cowboys as a whole still need to prove they can consistently draft well and that starts at the top with the final decision maker.
Yeah
I should have wrote respectively not both. Meaning, I feel we have (taken big steps in improving coaching) and will (take big steps to improve drafting – though primarily because of said coaching and JJ’s willingness to let Garrett lead this year and for JJ to hopefully have learned from his past mistakes)
"I am a true believer. Anthony Spencer will have 7 or more sacks in 2011 and Stephen Bowen can ball!" - Kegbearer
"Football is an incredible game. Sometimes it's so incredible, it's unbelievable."
- Tom Landry
Never a good way to build a team through FA
You end up in most cases with players, who are aging, whose previous team didn’t want them anymore, either because they were becoming less effective or were overpriced or a combination of both. They are merely stop gap measures until you finally draft young players to replace them. That is why the draft is so important. That is why team like the Pats and Eagles place such a premium on collecting high draft picks to fill their rosters. They trade aging good players to amass more picks. They are almost always good and almost always have young players developing to move into starting roles. They’ll sign a FA, to fill an occasional need, but do so cheaply and on a limited basis. We’re at the point where, unless we draft well and at the positions where we’re getting older, especially the OL, we’ll soon be in serious trouble. Can you imagine having to rebuild virtually the entire OL with FAs in the next year or 2. It will cost a fortune in contracts. So, unless we start drafting and drafting well, this vicious cycle will continue.
It May Be Too Late Already
. . . the oline is so old and in need of players (four out of five position are in dire need) – and, there are so few potential starters on the roster as backups – you could make the case that not one backup is a legitimate candidate to become a starter . . . even a good oline draft is not gonna fix the oline. This argument can be made about other positions like secondary or ILB corp or even the defensive line depending on what happens in free agency. Dallas is gonna be forced to hire free agencts to make up for the last four to five drafts. That is how Dallas ended up with Kosier, Bigg (and the expensive trade for Holland) – and don’t forget the total failure when Dallas paid big bucks for Rivera who had a catastrophic back injury the nanosecond after he signed and cashed his bonus check (gotta believe we got hose there no matter what conventional wisdom says). Bad drafting is what ails the Cowboys.
If you draft like the Cowboys,
you have no choice but to sign FAs. Finding O-linemen in the draft is Dallas’ achilles heal, Jerry could change that this year, but I wouldn’t count on it. They got kinda lucky with Free, but I’m not sure he’d be starting now if Colombo hadn’t got hurt.
Lock n Load
Take a close look at ScarletO's list
Notice all the players who are FAs that we’ll need to replace really soon. Kosier, Davis, Colombo, Brooking, Igor- we need to start drafting and drafting well.
This may be the most discouraging post/copmments I've read here the entire offseason
This is what happens when you miss on entire drafts so consistently, a single, apparently fluky decent Draft class becomes now indispensable. The team is then forced to retain some marginal talent or acquire FA’s with all their shortcomings instead of upgrading in the draft as good teams do.
As a bonus – you manage to have your only Above average OL at risk for as an UFA and potentially lose 3 DL FA’s in a single off-season? Stephen Jones, I am close to revoking your Franchise Savior designation, you gotta wear some of this along with your delusional Dad.
We live life forwards and understand it backwards
idk
to say we filled the roster with free agency is kinda wrong
just my opinion
almost every starter on this team is a draft pick or UDFA and I consider UDFA’s part of the draft class
the problem is we havent spent any money in free agency the past 3 years
one could argue we need to make some bigger moves in that department
by Archie Barberio on Apr 22, 2011 4:44 PM CDT reply actions
The big problem right now is the 2009 class
We should have just pulled a Ditka and traded the entire draft for 1 player, at least we would have gotten something out of it.
"Be great today" - Jason Garrett
Yaaaaaay!
To this day I have no idea what that woman was singing about. Like, literally no idea. I don’t know what a hollaback girl is. But I have to imagine it is a foul, disease ridden thing that wears too much make-up just to cover up the fact that it is a forty-seven year-old fish dog. – Family guy
by BlueNSilverBlood on Apr 23, 2011 12:04 AM CDT up reply actions
u forgot mike jenkins..
also i think we invest hardly any high picks on the offense.. besides dez bryant
look at all the first rounders Dallas drafted .. majority of the pick went on defense..so y is it that everyone say dallas needs this or that on D? T me it seem as if dallas needs to get players play there postion.. The safety and CB postion yea it needs helo put guys like spencer, igor,and sensi need to earn there keep
man that draft was a waste
just think who we could of had if we stayed pat..
man it sucks.. everytime JJ goes aganist the script he brings the team down
ratware
you agree right? I consider UDFA draft picks
by Archie Barberio on Apr 23, 2011 1:45 AM CDT up reply actions
Nice write-up ScarletO
Here’s to starting a trend of succesful drafts!
To this day I have no idea what that woman was singing about. Like, literally no idea. I don’t know what a hollaback girl is. But I have to imagine it is a foul, disease ridden thing that wears too much make-up just to cover up the fact that it is a forty-seven year-old fish dog. – Family guy
by BlueNSilverBlood on Apr 23, 2011 12:07 AM CDT reply actions
And yet, and yet-look in the archives at how many defended that 2009 draft!
“We upgraded our special teams!!”
That really was the argument at the time. Unbelieveable.
Terry was 1st in line, by the way.
Pessimists say the cup is half-empty, while optimists say it's half-full. Well, isn't it both? Realist Larry, 2009
Well remember the previous year before that, our special teams was abysmal...
The hiring of Joe Decamillas and the Special teams draft of 2009 was at the time a good idea.
F**** establishing a culture, we need to establish dominance...
It's more an indictment of Jerry and his merry men in the War Room
The draft failures of this team are becoming epic in nature.
"You can't live a perfect day without doing something for someone who will never be able to repay you."
- John Wooden (God rest his soul)
Epic?!
Oh no, Moses wandered 40 years in the desert and still didn’t get to the Promised Land. Saw it, but never got there. Died. See what no sense of direction gets ya, Jerral?
40 – 15? Wake me in 24 years.
Weltschmerzen.
My $.02's worth $.00.
One good thing about Garrett is...
He is a well connected man. Meaning he knows some of the best in the college ranks.. Saban, Miles, Butch Davis etc. Let just hope he uses them to get us some well coached talent in here. That is something Wade didnt have to use as an advantage. That is why I am so glad Wade is gone, he never won anything and never associated with winners.
by dcsince77 on Apr 23, 2011 7:04 PM CDT via mobile reply actions
Wade is still one of the best DCs in the NFL
just bc last season went downhill isn’t all on his shoulders. Jerry put in a lot of rules on how hard to work the players during TC & the amount of time they spent being on tour like some circus was a joke.
hopefully Jerry changed his ways
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth!
Clearly for the past couple of years.......
The plan for Cowboys has been to sign FAs for offense and draft defense. I believe that Jerry himself has even made mention of this a couple of times. This problem with this plan though is when you miss on defensive picks ico 2009 draft (all those players were/are a wash save maybe for Butler)………….My thoughts are that now we need to change the trend and get some solid offensive players. And the best place for solid /not great offensive players is on the O-line. In the trenches you need not be an all-pro to be effective. If we can get a group of smart players that are willing to work together they will always win out over an O- line with one or two all pros without any cohesiveness. Free fits this profile…Kosier fits the profile……Colombo (before his melt down the last 17 games) fit this profile…….Gurode can fit the profile……….in this draft I believe that Castonzo fits the profile as does Moffit……..but these as just my thoughts…………
Wade Phillips never really had a plan
I believe Jason Garette does
by AustonianAggie on Apr 25, 2011 10:27 AM CDT reply actions
it was always Jerrys plan & Wade was just the goat
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth!
There really is no point rehashing the 2009 draft. I'm over it...
I realize that that draft was a basic wash. The good news is we can start from this year and right the wrong. We realize that drafting for all special teams is a bad idea. We should have gone in with the philosophy of drafting players that can contribute to special teams but can eventually start. Lesson learned. I know things where bad, but trust me, would you rather we be in this situation looking for a RT with this draft or looking for a QB in this draft like Cinci might or Arizona, Minnesota, or Buffalo. Ill take the Cowboys small problems over the bigger ones like Cinci who would rather have a QB retire, than set foot in that stadium again. That is when you know you have problems.
F**** establishing a culture, we need to establish dominance...
FA is not the problem
The use of FA’s is not the problem. You only need to look at NE that takes a whole team approach. Everyone says they do great in the draft, but they take the BPA in the draft according tp their board (at times with an eye toward need), then they go after the UDFA’s that they feel can help thier team. With that said they are major players in the FA market .From 2005 to 2010 they took 49 free agents with the only down year in 2010 when the took 3 due to the changes from 4 to 6 years in the CBA that gave everyone a limited frre agent market. They have also done a few (3 I think) trades during this time for players the recieved and traded a number for draft picks.
I do not think the use of free agents is the problem, it is not using all tools available to build your team.
I disagree with Wade being one of the best DC's around.
His teams have a history of short term success, and monumental collapses. And when I say monumental I mean….like worst of all time.
I’d rather have a steady B grade than a the mercurial A+ followed by F- minus of a collosal sort.

by 























