NFL Draft Grades 2011: Gosselin, Kiper & Co Weigh In On Cowboys Draft
Grading a draft a mere hours after after the last pick is generally frowned on by the more hardcore football fan who knows that drafts can't really be graded until three to four years after the fact. But like the site of an accident, many people also find it hard not to look once such a grade is published.
If the review is good, you cling to it and hope that it will carry over onto the field when the season starts. If it is bad, you can simply shrug it off and say it doesn't matter anyway and post-draft grades are for the weak-of-mind.
Regardless, what the grades do is - to some extent - they capture the general feeling about a draft immediately after it is over. In this post, we'll look at four writers who have submitted their grades for the Cowboys and others already. Rick Gosselin gives the Cowboys a solid "B" and gives the Cowboys the best grade in the NFC East. Charean Williams from the Star-Telegram gives the Cowboys a "B", Mel Kiper hands the Cowboys a "B-", Pete Prisco from CBSSports has the Cowboys with a "B-" and Adam Caplan from Foxsports grades the Cowboys with a "C+".
Rick Gosselin of the DMN gives the Cowboys the best marks in the NFC East: "B"
"The Cowboys had a superb third day of this draft. Harris is a Kelvin Martin clone and the arrival of Arkin and Nagy will help Smith make the offensive line deeper and more competitive. Murray can solve a running back riddle."
Charean Williams of the Star-Telegram thinks the Cowboys should have addressed more needs: "B"
"Move over, Marc Colombo, Keith Brooking and Marion Barber. The future has arrived. Smith, 20, is the youngest player in the draft and will start from Day 1. Carter, because of his knee injury, has steal potential. Murray is one of the draft's top kick returners, and Harris can return kicks, too, filling a big need. But the Cowboys didn't get a DE or a S, arguably their two biggest needs."
ESPN's Mel Kiper gives the Cowboys an overall grade of "B-" for their 2011 draft. Kiper hands out a 'needs grade' and a 'value grade,' then combines them for the final grade. The Cowboys get a B- for filling needs, and a C+ for value.
"Summary: While I thought Dallas might trade down off No. 9 and get more value at the tackle position a little later in Round 1, Smith made a lot of sense at No. 9, and the Cowboys showed conviction with the pick. He could be the solution for them at left tackle if he develops, or perhaps gets moved to the right side for now.
After that, it got a little confusing for two rounds. Dallas went linebacker and running back in Rounds 2 and 3 before targeting more pressing needs at corner and guard in the following two rounds. Dallas got good value later, but never took a player that seemed like a steal at the position. Harris is a guy who might continue to develop at wideout."
ESPN's Todd McShay also has a few choice comments about the Cowboys draft, but doesn't hand out a grade:
"Best move: Tyron Smith in the first round: The Cowboys stayed put at No.9 overall and got the best available player at one of their top need positions in OT Tyron Smith, who can step in on the right side and be an upgrade over Marc Colombo from Day 1. Smith has the tools to play left tackle but would need time to adjust his footwork on the left side, so this works out perfectly for the Cowboys and Smith."
"Most questionable move: Bruce Carter at No. 40 overall: Where Dallas got Carter is not the issue. The problem trying to find a fit in the 3-4 scheme of new defensive coordinator Rob Ryan. To me, Carter is the classic 4-3 weakside linebacker and it's hard to figure where he will play in a 3-4. Is he a weakside inside linebacker' Adding to the questions is the fact that Dallas took LB Sean Lee in the second round a year ago."
ESPN's John Clayton doesn't offer an overall grade but thinks the Cowboys made the best move in the NFC East:
BEST MOVES: The NFC East was starting to become Jurassic Park for offensive linemen. The Redskins and Cowboys let their offensive lines get too old and paid the price. The Giants are on the verge of doing the same. The Cowboys made the best moves, taking Tyron Smith, the 6-5, 307-pound offensive tackle from Southern Cal in the first round, and Missouri State guard David Arkin in the fourth. Smith’s selection was the best. Outsiders thought the Cowboys would jump at the chance to fix last year’s problems at cornerback, but Jones rightfully looked at 2010 as off seasons for talented cornerbacks Terence Newman, Mike Jenkins and Orlando Scandrick. Whether Dallas plays Smith at left tackle or right is irrelevant. The Cowboys are younger at tackle with Doug Free, their top priority for re-signing, and Smith.
Pete Prisco from CBSsports is not a fan of the DeMarco Murray pick: "B-"
"Best pick: I like the pick of Bruce Carter in the second round. He is coming off an ACL injury, so he might be limited in 2010, but he has star potential if on the field.
Questionable move: Taking DeMarco Murray in the third round was a strange move with all the other needs they have.
Third-day gem: Sixth-round pick Dwayne Harris is a steal. He will make their team and be a good slot receiver.
Analysis: They added a starter in tackle Tyron Smith and then filled in some holes, though I think they could have gone in another direction when they picked Murray."
Adam Kaplan from Foxsports echoes a popular sentiment and thinks the Cowboys should have addressed more needs: C+
Analysis: The Cowboys might have gotten a steal with Carter in the second round. He’s still coming back from ACL surgery, but should help the team more in his second season. They failed to address their weaknesses at safety and cornerback.
Before the draft everybody was saying the Cowboys need to get back to BPA. The Cowboys, by their own accounts, followed their board and now everybody is up in arms about the Cowboys not drafting for need.
Funny how those things go.
46 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Adam Kaplan doesn't know we drafted a CB?
And that this safety class sucked?
Say that to Scandrick...
The team has shown that they can pick DBs in the 2nd day.
Arnold, almost 5 years of good memories, you'll be missed.
Viva México! Go Cowboys!
+1
We are 3 deep at CB as it stands. The need at CB was to improve depth. . . . . I am pretty sure that we did that. There were other players I would have liked, but when Ras I Dowling and A. Williams got picked before we got to #40, no need to force a pick there if the value didn’t match.
Also, pretty glad we didn’t take a Safety, it was a really bad Safety class, both in terms of talent and depth.
Not an analyst who pays attention to detail
Kaplan has to make many short points on a lot of subjects so he’s not in the business of doing detail analysis eventhough he’d probably say that’s his job. On an NFL Network fantasy football show, for the longest time, he kept referring to Miles Austin as Austin Miles. Week-after-week and he never took the time to look it up.
I stopped reading his stuff shortly after Fox "promoted" him.
He’s a pale imitation of Jay Glazer and Chris Mortensen…without the deep list of contacts. I can find his information at any number of sites and usually sooner than he breaks it.
Rabid and luvin' it
Maybe he should stop talking then
I don’t know why someone like that would keep giving their opinion, when he obviously didn’t take much time to formulate one.
I guess...
Same reason ESPN is paying Calvin Watkins.
And when you figure out that reason, please tell me because I’d really like to know.LOL
Rabid and luvin' it
yeah, pretty lame analysis by Kaplan.
I am excited we addressed the OL which was a huge hole for us. I think Carter is going to be an outstanding addition once he gets healthy. I had a premonition we’d take Carter, though I had never heard of him, so I read up a lot on him prior to Thursday. Murray fills another huge hole for us by replacing Barber, who went from a physical, exciting Earl Campbell-type of RB (without his size) to a east-west dancer who fell down when a defender sneezed near him. I think JJ has finally surrounded himself with good personnel people who he is listening to.
U.S. Marines - Forged on the Anvil of Discipline
I believe that this was one of the more pragmatic Cowboy draft since the Landry days.
What’s more plausable than picking to fill an urgent need in the 1st round; and taking the most talented athlete available in ensuing rounds.
It appears to be a GREAT draft for Dallas! (B = GREAT)
Wharter
We won't really know the answers till 3 years from now.
see how many guys are starting or contributing in some way.
if it’s 3 or 4 then it was a good draft,more then it was a great draft.
Davie Wilson
"how bout them cowboys"!!!
by scotscowboyfan on May 1, 2011 9:37 AM CDT up reply actions
I think ppl
are going to forget about what a questionable call it was to take Murray once they see what he does for our offense. I think this kid is going to open up a lot of new wrinkles in a similar way that Felix did.
Furthermore, while they are both very very fast and threats to take it to the house on any down, Felix and DeMarco are different kinds of backs. Where Felix is quick and can waterbug his way in and around defenders in traffic, Murray is more of a banger.
Watch some highlight clips and you will see plenty of stiffarms, spins out of tackles, running thru armtackles, and helmets rolling around on the field that don’t belong to DeMarco.
Additionally, Murray is an outstanding pass blocker and receiver out of the backfield. I read that he caught 70 passes last year, many of them were on receiver routes. This kid may have the receiving potential that Thurman Thomas of the Bills brought to the table years ago.
Bruce Carter will help this year and terrorize next year when he and Lee are starting. Someone on here has already coined a nickname for the tandem…Bruce Lee. I have also seen Rush Hour used (like the movie).
I think we got an immediate starter on the OL and future All Pro while adding depth and potential starters in 2-3 years at those positions as well.
Watch the front office interviews for Day 1, 2, and 3 at the Mothership and you will feel better I think.
I Wall of Text like it's the in thing to do
"...and just things really starting to unravel now for Utah..." Herbie, BSU vs. Utah, 22 Dec 2010
i dont have a huge problem with the RB pick but was Murray the best option at #3?
i did have a small problem with taking a RB that early in the draft (not named Ingram or Willams) when we had a ton of other positions that needed to be filled with the talent & value still on the board. one other thing that concerns me about Murray is his upright style of running in the NFL. it seems that OU tried to coach him up about pad level but it just effected his playmaking ability so he needs some time with Houck for sure. he runs physical & if he remains healthy i’m sure most people won’t be complaining when he makes a few big plays. on potential he could be the most talented RB on the Cowboys roster & if he can remain heathy he will earn more snaps as the season progresses bc this guy was a leader & went hard every play.
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth! Garrett & Ryan working as a team should create a physical environment at Valley Ranch that shows up on gameday.
Show me another 2 or 3 RBs with his production
and with his hands and route running ability (I say that based on 100+ catches combined during his last two years) and then I’d agree that we should have gone in another direction in the 3rd.
Otherwise (and this is what I believe) I think Murray was a one-of-a-kind in the draft, and he fits the mold we want for our 3rd back. And since we wanted him, we needed to take him instead of playing games and hoping for the best in the 4th.
So long Marion…
+1
Murray had crazy college production, better than AP, and the Cowboys and Pats started the run on RBs, meaning they got the pick of the litter. SOme would say Murray is a steal in the 3rd.
in any case, i think it also reveals that not only barber, but CHoice are also fighting for a spot. Murray is debatably the best pass blocker in the rookie Rb class, and best route runner (also played in the slot). I wouldn’t be shocked if Garrett considered him the best (or at least top 3) RB in this draft that fit his system. Murray should win the 3rd Rb spot his rookie year and could then even press Felix for the starting job in 2012.
At first I questioned the pick, then realized Garrett didn’t think as highly of CHoice as I did, and thus filled a big hole on his offense with a lot of talent.
"I am a true believer. Anthony Spencer will have 7 or more sacks in 2011 and Stephen Bowen can ball!" - Kegbearer
"Football is an incredible game. Sometimes it's so incredible, it's unbelievable."
- Tom Landry
I coined the Phrase "Rush Hour" for Bruce Carter and Sean Lee
"The tone is business," Garrett said. "Let's get to work. The Giants are going to be at the Meadowlands on Sunday at 4:15. They're an awfully good football team. We have to get ready for them."
by Rohpuri on May 1, 2011 4:07 PM CDT via mobile up reply actions
HAHAHAHA
Carter and Lee – Rush Hour – LOVE IT!
"I am a true believer. Anthony Spencer will have 7 or more sacks in 2011 and Stephen Bowen can ball!" - Kegbearer
"Football is an incredible game. Sometimes it's so incredible, it's unbelievable."
- Tom Landry
Draft Grades are A Joke
Have you ever looked at draft grades a few years ago and see how they would be graded today? Taking the three years many say you need to see how things turned out. I remember one team getting ripped in the 2008 draft for reaching for a player at a position, they kept investing in. Most experts gave them one of the lowest grades. What would the grade be today for the Titans and their three time pro bowler " Chris Johnson".
I don’t know how the Cowboys draft will fare and neither does anyone else. I would have gone in different direction in the 2nd and 3rd round, but I am curious to see how the Cowboys plan to use these picks.
I think the draft was solid and encouraged because I finally see a plan in place. Let’s see what the coaching staff can do with these players and in three years who is right or wrong.
My favorite semi pro teams are the Eagles and Giants
by RealAlbertEinstein on May 1, 2011 9:37 AM CDT reply actions
the auther clearly states that in the beggenning
just for fun and discussion.
by Musiccitynorm on May 1, 2011 9:50 AM CDT up reply actions
Carters speed is going to be utilized nicely in Ryans exotic defensive schemes. Few teams truly run a classic 3-4 or 4-3 the majority of the time. With all of the base packages and exotic sub packages, versatility is key. Much can be done with Carters explosiveness. After all, you simply can’t coach speed.
Murray may be the Cowboys attempt to broaden the abilities of the offense other than just pure rushing. If Murray can become a respected threat receiving out of the backfield, it’ll allow Garrett and Romo even more ways to carve up an opponent.
Ty Smith? Well, there’s no doubting his physical tools. At 20 years old, his ceiling is somewhere above the 20th floor if he can grasp the nuances of the NFL game. Seeing that he is bright, from a good background with a good work ethic, I see no reason for him not to be able to marry his physical abilities to his mental ones on the pro level.
Arkin looks as if he can be a missing piece in the center of the line. He states that he grew into his body at a late age. If that is the case, he may not have peaked yet and still have room to become better,. At the very least, his athleticism is not in doubt and he should benefit greatly from a professional strength and training regimen. C’mon folks, it’s not as if he went to OU or another top flight program. He still has untapped potential that hasn’t been fully mined yet.
Thomas seems to be slotted to be a special teams demon. With the chip he carries on his shoulder, it’s clear he is willing to fight for playing time. I look for him to push the corners in front of him playing time and not take no for an answer.
I am excited about the drafting of Nagy and Chapas as it makes me wonder if the ‘Boys are about to attempt to devlop a version of a power run game up the middle. It’sbeen sorely lacking for some time. It would be nice to have the option on 3rd and short to pound for short yardage instead of reying on pitch outs, draws and short passes.
It seems that many of the picks are achievers. Hard working, character guys that should fit Reds idea of good team mates. Another draft or two like this and we should see a transformation of the current roster of superstars who too often seem to quit into a gritty team that claws and scracthes to last seconds of the game.
Good job Jason and Jerry. This is clearly no longer Wades team. There’s a new sheriff in town and it looks like he’s got a plan that’s more than just flash and superficiality.
by Jes2red on May 1, 2011 10:01 AM CDT reply actions 1 recs
IMO Thomaas will get a lot of playing time with RR's schemes this year. A lot of exotic, extra CB formations,
rushing the QB, etc. And potentially will be Newman’s replacement lined up for next year.
i think Carter plays more of an OLB role in Ryans scheme.
he’s that 3-4 ILB/4-3 DE type of guy thats not going to have alot asked of him bc he clearly lacks instincts you cant like in a 3 down player & he’s not at his best in run support (kinda finese) so he sounds like a pass rusher first then maybe they get him involved in some coverages.
he’s also coming off knee surgery so he could even start the season on IR (reported at espn/dallas) which is never good but with the new strength coach they might have more faith in Lee then we know which made them think this guy could be factor come next season when.
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth! Garrett & Ryan working as a team should create a physical environment at Valley Ranch that shows up on gameday.
I must admit
the picks of Carter and Murray were puzzling to me, especially considering who was on the board then (Brandon Harris and Will Rackley). But I LOVE the other picks, especially Josh Thomas and David Arkin. So, I’m not gonna complain about Carter and Murray and withold judgement on an overall “grade” for the draft until after the season starts. I hope we get Blaine Sumner as a UDFA though. I’d like to see him get a chance with the Cowboys.
I feel the same way about those picks.
A little puzzled, but they seem to have a plan for those guys, so I won’t gripe until it goes bad. hehe. I didn’t like the fact that these guys are dinged up more than anything.
i really liked the David Arkin pick even though i would've loved to taken one earlier
Arkin has played all across the line which gives him more value & looked the part of a big old nasty guard with some athletic ability.
he sounds like the sure thing but this lockout bs has to end so we can get these young kids coached up & in the weight room.
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth! Garrett & Ryan working as a team should create a physical environment at Valley Ranch that shows up on gameday.
i also give this draft a C+ just from some of the players & where they got picked.
outside of T.Smith i didn’t see another potential starter picked & once again we had a face palm slap when they picked in the 2nd & 3rd rounds. i think 9(0% of the people on this board knew Barber was going to be released asap but i thought it was established by some of the writers here & top fan poster picks of the week that a RB was now extinct or how they weren’t worth picking (unless its AP,CJ2K,Ihgram) until later rounds or even undrafted players.
its clear Dallas is looking to make big plays from the backfield & getting the RB/FB combo means a lot of passing plays. Romo is at his best when he’s got a running game working & theres no shame in that, not everyone is P.Manning, Brady, Rodgers but the Saints & Patriots even changed that up this season with NE getting 2.
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth! Garrett & Ryan working as a team should create a physical environment at Valley Ranch that shows up on gameday.
Really?
outside of T.Smith i didn’t see another potential starter picked
It is too early to say, but we could have 1 starter out of this group or we could have as many as 5.
I understand your points, but only time will tell. At this point we seem to have quality coaching in place. It should help our recent Draft picks (last couple years) as well as some of the 3-5 year guys that never really had a decent coaching staff to help them reach their potential.
Giving draft grades this early is like
betting on who will be in the SB in 2013. It’s fun to talk about, but it don’t mean crap.
Lock n Load
by DIRE WOLF on May 1, 2011 12:48 PM CDT reply actions 1 recs
This Draft produced the full range of emotions for me
Ecstatic after the Smith pick, puzzled after Carter and downright pissed after the Murray selection. On Day 3 I settled down and like what we did. The #2 and 3 picks represent high opportunity cost – not for what DAL did get, but for what we passed up. And that’s how they will be judged – against a quality DE, Ijalana, Moffit could-have-been.
Bob Sturm had a great point this AM on the #2 and 3 picks – first he talked about the pressing need issue, then:
‘If you are like me, then you feel that the Cowboys are making picks to make up for previous sins. If previous OL picks could play, then maybe they don’t need to address the OL. If previous cover LBs could play, then Bruce Carter is not a need because Carpenter is in his prime and Jason Williams is entering his 3rd season. If previous RBs were what Dallas needed, then they don’t need Murray.
But, I am not crazy about taking another inside LB with a very important pick for the 5th draft in 7 years…Previous draft disappointments haunt the Cowboys.’
We live life forwards and understand it backwards
Since the days of Jimmy
drafting hasn’t been a strong point for Dallas. We can only hope it turns around, time will tell.
Lock n Load
I have been thinking the same thing
Before the draft everybody was saying the Cowboys need to get back to BPA. The Cowboys, by their own accounts, followed their board and now everybody is up in arms about the Cowboys not drafting for need.
Funny how those things go.
Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.
It is also funny that many people were of the opinion that we couldn’t fill all the holes in the Draft, yet now that is what I hear complained about the most. Relax everyone, we are making strides to be great again.
these grades will all change
when they ship MBIII and choice out for d-line filler.
they bring in nmandi and eric weddle
they re-sign free and move him back to RT and start smith at LT
i expect in future drafts for them to chase LB’s. carter, lee, and ware is going to be a nice trio along with butler who is real solid at pass rushing. brooking is done and james is getting by on his smarts now and i dont expect him to be back because they are going to treat him like greg ellis: can still bring it but dont want to pay you because you are old and we got young guns behind you waiting
The realist keepin it real amongst the surrealists
R.I.P. Big Homey Nate Dogg: "Cuz Iiiiiiiiii have ne-evv-ver met a giiiiiiiiiirrrrrrllllllllllllllllllll tha-at I loved in the whole wide wooorrrlllllddddddd"
by starbury_to_s-jaxci2000 on May 1, 2011 2:47 PM CDT reply actions
we'll see
I’ve ditched my bad feelings and questions on rounds 2 and 3 in favor of trusting Garrett and the staff.
However, all that stuff you just named up there seems like a whole lot of what ifs, we’re the NY Yankees of the NFL, and rookies can own face at some of the toughest positions in the NFL.
That’s an awful lot to hope for.
I Wall of Text like it's the in thing to do
"...and just things really starting to unravel now for Utah..." Herbie, BSU vs. Utah, 22 Dec 2010
what are the real needs
I’m not sure you can call CB a need position. 1. You have to believe Jenkins will bounce back. He and Scandrick could be a terror tandem in Ryan’s defense, with blindside QB sacks. I also think McCann is more than just a body. The guy is fast and seems to have a knack for making plays. Worse case is Alan Ball moves back to corner to provide depth.
Safety is a need but they do have AOA and he might be part of the answer. Plus, there are better fixes short term in free agency, I would think. Obviously, they have a big need on the defensive line but I assume that is another thing they will address in free agency.
The thing you have to keep in mind is that the Cowboys spend more money than any other team on players and Jones is probably pretty savvy about where the agreement is going to end up. My guess is that he figures the Cowboys will not have the current cap constraint next year and will be able to fill some needs in free agency.
I wasn’t thrilled about the Cowboys picking a running back in the third round, and have always thought Choice deserved more touches, but a tandem of Jones and Murray will give the Cowboys a LOT of firepower out of the back field. With a better line, which they should have next year, it’s not hard to see the Cowboys rushing for 2k yards and the running backs getting another 1k yards in passes.
Galveston Dave
Can't disagree with a thing you said
I too, like a ton of others here, question the Murray selection. And it really seems to me that the coaching staff just does not like Choice for whatever reason—he has, IMO, performed well when given the chance. But I am also thinking the Cowboys may have missed the boat entirely with Felix. Five or six RBs, taken in the same draft as he was, have done much better so far in their careers. Maybe Jason and Jerry are seeing the same thing.
Perhaps Murray will come in and out perform all of the RBs currently on the roster.
This draft sucked the eagles draft was better .I wish we had their draft picks. Tyron Smith will b a bust. And just how did we pass on Fairly the best player n the draft. Then do not pick Bowers because he will need knee surgery n the future. And then pick 3 guys who just had knee surgery. Another 1 that is hurt so much his team mates called him Demarco OUCH Murray .
Opinions are like....
And just how did we pass on Fairly the best player n the draft.
The Cowboys were just one of twelve teams which drafted ahead of the Lions who disagree with you.
Then do not pick Bowers because he will need knee surgery n the future. And then pick 3 guys who just had knee surgery.There is knee surgery, and then there is microfracture knee surgery. Many NFL players recover fully from the surgery the Cowboys picks had. Recovering fully from microfracture surgery is far less often the case.
Another 1 that is hurt so much his team mates called him Demarco OUCH Murray.Who were those team mates? He missed four games in four years. Maybe it was Adrian Peterson they mistook Murray for.

by 
























