What "exactly" is a NEED?
If you talk to my wife, a need is anything she desires. According to her, she "needs" a new pair of shoes - esp. whenever she happens to pass in front of a shoe store and sees something she likes. Instantly, she has a need - even though she already has more shoes than either of us would dare to count. I don't think I wanna know about just the black shoes or boots she has.
Dallas Cowboys fans are like my wife - just more needy. We as fans want to win the Superbowl next year and care little about the cost associated. We all want this guy because of his pass rushing ability, or that guy because of his cover skills, etc. We're always looking for the next Ware, Deion, Woodson, Allen or Lett. As we should...
But what are the Cowboys needs - really? What specific holes might the Boys have come draft time? Of course, it's too early to tell as there is still a free agency period to go through as well as the combine, etc. Plus, most assuredly, some highly touted prospect will self denigrate himself by poor decision making (like Dre Kirkpatrick already has).
From looking at the roster and counting ONLY those players who will be on contract next year (assuming Spencer is not re-signed and Newman is cut), the biggest needs are clearly: Safety, Left Outside Linebacker and Cornerback. These are the bona-fide needs - not improving these areas will leave each position substantially undermanned and with little talent.
Additionally, there are always positions on the team that could use upgrading - some positions need more drastic improvement, while others would be really nice if the talent were better but the incumbent playing now is adequate. Those positions in dire need of upgrading are: Offensive Guard, Center, Wide Receiver #3 and #4 and Defensive End. There are players in these positions that played substantial minutes last year, but their play was less than average in production.
Those which would be nice to improve (or increase depth) would be: Nose Tackle, Quarterback and Tight End. These are mostly depth needs as the incumbent is fairly decent and the primary backup is average.
Now, filling those needs can come from multiple sources - not just the draft. In fact, it's my opinion that there are substantial needs that can be filled via free agency.
For cornerback - I suggest Terrell Thomas.
Terrell Thomas Giants 2010-2011 Highlights|| HD|| (via xXxThatStarxXx)
He's a 6'1", 202 lb, 27 yr old CB drafted in the 2nd round (by the Giants) from USC. His stats are fairly decent in that he's accounted for 5 INTs in both 09 and 10 to go along w/ 4 forced fumbles and playing some free safety. He's not a top tier CB but could easily be a #2 CB or very good #3. He is, however, injury prone. All this considered, he's not expected to be too pricey.
Also via free agency, I would lock up Laurent Robinson. Yes, this is a no-brainer but will still cost a considerable amount of money (around $5 mil / year) that I don't think fans want to dedicate to him. He's worth it in my opinion as neither Harris, Olgetree, Radway nor Holley project to be able to produce in any way close to what Robinson has already shown us this past season. Robinson has proven to standout with 2 separate NFL teams already (San Diego) and whenever you get something proven, you stick with it.
With CB #2/3 and WR #3 secured, that will probably take up about $7-9 mil in cap per year. Therefore, the other needs will need to be met via the draft (to keep costs down and to reduce greater loss of investment). In particular, I suggest drafting an OG (DeCastro), then LOLB (Curry) and free safety (Martin) in that order. In this manner, Dallas will be on its way to righting the ship. It may not produce a Superbowl next year, but the proper way to build is to make steady improvements each year. If the improvements are made correctly, the winning will take care of itself.
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
26 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
How are we going to steal Thomas from the Giants?
Especially after they went so far…
Melvin Ingram...
I don't he'd come to Dallas
1) he’ll probably wanna stay with the team he is on now. Has he expressed any dissatifaction with the giants organization?
2) not many players would want to leave and play for a divisional rival.
3) the giants made a run close to the Super Bowl which means he will want to stay with them even more ~ see point 1
4) teams don’t want to play for teams that they don’t view as contenders ….
Thats why Nnamdi didn’t reunite with Rob Ryan in Dallas…
Better off going younger and out of the division via free agency. Find an unappreciated solid guy on a bad team and get him for cheap, a Carlos Rogers type but younger
Brandon Carr or Cortland Finnegan are ideal fits.
Chris Canty and Stephen Bowen
had no problem doing it. And with the CBs and FSs there at NY (Roll, Webster, Ross, Amukamara, etc.), I can’t see any reason for a tremendous hometown discount.
by Tyrone Jenkins on Jan 21, 2012 9:51 PM CST up reply actions
Ehh
I just don’t see it, nobodies gushing over playing for the cowboys. They’ll take a paycut if the team is contending. But if they got one of them they’d want a big payday and it’s a risk because there is no garuntee he’ll workout.
by bitterlyhonest on Jan 21, 2012 11:40 PM CST up reply actions
I hear you
but given that link of thinking, it seems as if the Boys wont’ be able to sign anyone in FA. No Robinson, no Nicks, etc. Dallas has always been able to sign FAs in the past – what is different about this year?
I refuse to believe the draft is the ONLY place Dallas can acquire talent. SOMEONE who wasn’t wearing a star last year will be wearing one next year.
by Tyrone Jenkins on Jan 22, 2012 8:58 AM CST up reply actions
I see
I think if they can sign a guard in free agency like Nicks, it will really help the draft.
by bitterlyhonest on Jan 22, 2012 11:13 AM CST up reply actions
i think Dallas has way more need at CB then what T.Thomas can provide
he sounds more like a luxary bc he cant stay healthy & would be like rolling the dice. also if the Giants let a cheap solid player walk that probably tell ya everything you need.
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth. Sean Lee is a welcomed addition at ILB & Kegabear's prediction about Spencer looks spot on so far.
Don't get the statement that no one is gushing over playing for the Boys.
Why wouldn’t players want to come here? The coaching staff is excellent and JJ loves his players.
Wish you were here and comfortably numb.
And they lose. Alot .
Jerry is the end all in Dallas.
by football mensa on Jan 22, 2012 1:51 PM CST up reply actions
Exactly
Not many high profile players are gonna wanna play for the cleveland browns of the league. If the cowboys have won just one playoff game in the last 15 years than players will look at that when they weigh out their options. Of course money is a big thing but players wanna play for contenders.
Will a player want to spend his best years playing in Dallas if they don’t believe they can win a ring?
by bitterlyhonest on Jan 22, 2012 2:27 PM CST up reply actions
Perhaps you're right
and that is why Dallas has serially overpaid its FAs…
I don’t know. FAs go to all kinds of teams – some much worse than the Cowboys. The Lions signed quite a few. Stephen Jackson stayed in St Loius. Even the Bills plucked a couple of B rated guys…
I’m not saying we’re trying to draw Peyton Manning. Carl Nicks really shouldn’t be that much of a stretch if Dallas is willing to pay him what he asks (which is probably going to be 6-8 mil / yr).
by Tyrone Jenkins on Jan 22, 2012 4:35 PM CST up reply actions
good post
"The tone is business," Garrett said. "Let's get to work. The Giants are going to be at the Meadowlands on Sunday at 4:15. They're an awfully good football team. We have to get ready for them."
by Rohpuri on Jan 21, 2012 6:13 PM CST via mobile reply actions
This is something I often ponder
The bottom line is, no matter how much we have to spend this year, we are still on the hook for some 20mil+ in bad contracts FROM 2 YEARS AGO. As much as I would love to see all the big name free agents here, I don’t want to ever be in this situation again. We have been smart about our contracts the past few years, and I think we need to keep it going. Even the recent extensions, while questioned by some, are still “cap friendly”.
Just imagine, sans those crappy contracts, we could have up to 40 MIL to spend this year… thats just crazy.
We need to remain frugal, at least for this year, building the team with reasonably priced FA’s and good talent from the draft (unless you can steal a blue chipper, but even then you have to structure the contract favorably).
With Stephan Jones manning the controls of the paychecks (that’s the only explanation I can come up with to explain the stark change in contracts the past few years) I have high hopes for our future.
You are right to an extent. Sign younger FAs not old, tired, past their prime retreads.
Wish you were here and comfortably numb.
I like your premise
But your explanation is confusing. You list our “biggest needs” as Safety, LOLB and CB and our “dire needs” as OG, C, WR3, WR4 and DE. And follow up with “nice to haves” as NT, QB and TE.
My first confusion/question would be are our biggest needs more dire than our dire needs? Assuming they are, then I would say our biggest, direst, neediest need of all is to protect Romo’s ribs, collarbone, hand, thumb and all his other parts and pieces. I would argue that if you give him time, he will rival Brees, Brady and Rodgers in his ability to pick apart opposing defenses with the receiving corpse at his disposal. By extension, I would then argue that our top need is to solidify the O-line, specifically the interior, by targeting a combination of OG and C in the draft and FA.
I understand your confusion
I probably should have used better vocabulary. But yes, the biggest needs are those that we MUST have because the current player(s) on contract for those positions aren’t starter worthy (being Butler, Church and Newman). Dire needs, in the sense I’ve used the term, are those which need immediate upgrade is needed but there are still players in those positions who have played and were at least “marginal” in production (Arkin/Nagy, Costa, Ogletree/Harris/Radway/ Holley and Coleman/Spears).
And, while I agree w/ the argument of protection, the offense did fairly well w/ the current group of guys this year – all things considered. Romo did play in every game.
The pass rush / defense is the true Achilles of this team.
by Tyrone Jenkins on Jan 22, 2012 4:41 PM CST up reply actions
ILB
I think you have to add ILB to the “need depth list” at the least. I know we have Carter waiting in the wings so to speak. But we dont know what we have with him. Sean Lee still has injury concerns at this point, Bradie is nearing the end of his playing days and I think Brooking is done.
LBs are always need in a 3-4 unless your the 49ers
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth. Sean Lee is a welcomed addition at ILB & Kegabear's prediction about Spencer looks spot on so far.
okay i misread your post also & i agree with the biggest needs being pass rush/OLB & CB.
i still wouldn’t take Decastro with the 14th pick bc theres just to many second tier FAs or mid round draft picks that can fill those holes pretty easy.
finding a Guard isn’t this hard & hopefully with Callahan it doesn’t continue to be a problem but after last season i’d put RRs defense a priority in the draft.
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth. Sean Lee is a welcomed addition at ILB & Kegabear's prediction about Spencer looks spot on so far.
also before i read your post i knew it was going to center around Decastro & "need".
i like Decastro a lot but i’m not sold on drafting any Guard with the 14th pick with so many needs on defense.
no Spencer seems like a bigger need then the OL. i would also put CB (someone better then T.Thomas) as a bigger need. theres noway Dallas can just sign a #1 CB (unless its Finnergan) so taking on in the 1st or 2rd round could give Dallas that top CB they need.
Every team has a great gameplan until they get Punched in the Mouth. Sean Lee is a welcomed addition at ILB & Kegabear's prediction about Spencer looks spot on so far.
I have contemplated this
However, Dallas has already “shown its hand” with respect to CBs and SS. They resigned both Scandrick and Sensabaugh to long term contracts. Normally, you don’t sign slot of CB3s to 6 yr contracts as the chances of acquiring a 4th or 5th round pick in the draft could be just as adequate at 1/3 the cost. Scandrick was signed with the intentions that he would eventually be a #2 CB.
Jenkins is the #1 if he returns from injury in time. If that’s not th expectation, then I could see spending a #1 pick on someone to come in a play on the outside immediately. But, anyone the Boys draft will start out in the slot – if he proves to be better than Scan (or Jenk), then he will be promoted. But, the Boys can find tha guy in the 3rd round; or it could be Thomas (Finnegan will be too expensive).
And, I’ve never been a fan of having that much youth at one position. If another CB is drafted and starts in the slot, that’ll be 2 CBs w/ 2 years experience and a rookie. That’s not the way to cover Cruz, Manningham and Nicks. The secondary needs veteran leadership as well as talent. Thomas provides them both. Don’t like him – fine. But find someone else who can step in immediately and play that isn’t gonna cost MORE than Scandrick.
by Tyrone Jenkins on Jan 23, 2012 10:37 AM CST up reply actions
I would like to see us...
Upgrade NT via FA (Paul Soliai) & draft while solving the DE problem by moving Ratliff over, resign Spencer & Robinson, and sign Carl Knicks. We’d be able to draft CB, Center, WR and whatever else…
God 1st, Family Always & Dallas Cowboys 4 Life!!!!!

by 



























