Offseason Priorities
The challenge for Jerry Jones, or any general manager, is living within parameters. One parameter is the salary cap. Another is the free market where free agents can decide where to go. Another parameter is the likely football lifecycle of key players, like Tony Romo. Jerry Jones and every other GM can't control those parameters. Rather, it's a matter of what to do about them.
For the Cowboys, those parameters mean having to define your priorities. After all, we can all see areas of need. We need to shore up the interior of the offensive line. We need to get more pressure on the QB. We need better play from our defensive backfield. If all of our free agents left, we would have some additional areas of need, including wide receiver, TE, OLB, and so on.
Then there's the very big question of how the core players will perform next year. Is Witten on the decline? Will Austin shake the injury bug? Will Bruce Carter step up? Will Lissemore become a bigger force on the defensive line? Can McGee be a legit number 2? Can Phillips fill the void left by the departure of Bennett?
So what would your priorities be if you were Jerry Jones?
More after the jump.
Yes, many of us would make getting a new GM priority number one. But here's the deal. That's not an available parameter. We're stuck with Jones.Our defense has so many holes, it's hard to imagine it going from mediocre to great in one season. Also, this team isn't going anywhere without Tony Romo, and right now, our offensive line is putting him at risk. A smashed hand because of an all-too-common collapsed pocket was key to the season-ending loss to the Giants. I'm not saying the Cowboys would have won if Romo had been 100 percent healthy. But, really, who thought we had a chance after seeing Romo's hand that day? For the Cowboys to beat the Giants on the road, Romo was going to have to play the game of his life.
And let's not forget the cracked rib earlier in the year. Or his broken collar bone last year. Mostly, let's not forget that Romo will be 32 next year and age will make him less mobile, less quick, and more susceptible to pressure.
For all of those reasons, I'd make offensive line the highest priority. With upgrades there, the Cowboys have a legit chance to be elite offensively, especially if they resign Robinson. Yes, Phillips will have to step up at TE (if Bennett is not resigned, which seems unlikely). And Free will have to be a lot more like the player we saw in 2010 than the one we saw last year. More time in the pocket would mean a lot more vertical passes, which will open up the soft underbelly of the defense for Murray and Witten, in particular.
And let's not forget about the impact of better offensive line play on the running game. The Cowboys have the makings of a powerful one-two punch in Murray and Jones. With bigger holes, those guys could take a lot of pressure off Romo, too, and make the play action pass, which Romo is great at, a much better weapon. So I say let's go all in and sign Nicks. I might even use the #1 on another guard. I'm sorry, but I want to see what would happen if Romo had all day to pass the ball and his running backs actually had holes to run through, instead of getting stopped in the backfield.
The next highest priority for me is pressure on the QB. Pressure there will make whomever is playing CB or safety better. My thought is to keep Spencer and find a beast at DE who can bring pressure. (I just don't buy the idea that those guys can't get sacks in the 3/4).
Right after that I'd make signing Robinson a priority. Unless they feel someone like Radway is going to be able to step up, it seems to me that signing Robinson is part of a plan for having a high octane offense. You can't pay him starter money but he's got a chance to be an elite #3 receiver, especially if Romo has more time to throw.
The next priority would be cornerback. There's no way Newman's coming back and so the Cowboys HAVE to get a third CB, even if it's only a stop gap solution.
Next on the priority list would be safety. No one is ready to replace Elam. I wouldn't be surprised to see him resigned, even if he is Just a Guy.
Next would be help at ILB. We all hope Bruce Carter will step up and form a great tandem with Sean Lee but there has to be some back up there. Brooking and James are not likely to be resigned (and shouldn't be, from what I could see).
I'm guessing that Phillips will be able to replace Bennett. Unlike some, I have a feeling Bennett will catch a lot of passes as some other team's number one TE. And I have this really bad feeling that Witten is slowing down and we'll all be griping about letting Bennett get away in a couple of years. If he ever gets a coach that tells him how to use his body and fight for the ball, he could be a real beast, especially in the end zone, jumping over smaller CBs. But I've been thinking that for several years now and can't take the chance of putting so much money into a position that will be less a factor because of more 3 receiver sets next year.
I'm also guessing McGee can be an adequate #2. I know he'll never be a starter. At least, I hope not, not for the Cowboys anyway (I'm all for him starting for the Eagles or Giants). But he can stand in for a game or two. And, let's face it, if the Cowboys lose Romo for any period of time, they're not going anywhere anyway. QB would be a high priority next year in the draft or possibly the year after, and if what I felt were a franchise QB fell to me in the draft this year, I'd go in that direction but that seems really unlikely.
So there you have it. Tell me what you think the priorities should be?
Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.
12 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I wrote up one possibility
and listed my team in my Possible Plan – Part II. Here was the final roster:
QB – Romo, McGee, Rookie (I don’t like McGee, but would keep him if needed to sign the other FAs)
RB – Murray, F. Jones, Tanner
FB – Fiametta
TE – Witten, Phillips, Rookie
WR – Austin, Bryant, veteran, Radway, Holley/Harris/Holmes (best of)
OT – Smith, Free, Parnell
G – DeCastro, Kosier, Nagy, Arkin, Holland
C – Saturday, Kowalski
NT – Soliai, Brent
DE – Ratliff, Lissemore, Hatcher, Geathers, Spears
OLB – Ware, Spencer, Butler, Albright
ILB – Lee, Carter, Crowder, Lemon
S – Sensabaugh, Martin, Church, McCray
CB – Middleton, Jenkins, Scandrick, Gilmore, Bentley
I would LOVE to have Nicks and DeCastro, but with all the holes we have to fill, I just can’t see it as a viable option. Besides, we do have two young players at guard need to be given the chance to develop and that’s more than we have at positions like CB, S, ILB, WR, NT and OLB so that’s where most of the money should focus on IMO.
Great post btw.
i could live with your team
Don’t disagree that arkin or navy or kowaltski or even Costa might be ready. Like the numbers. Wish we only had to get one starter from the bunch.
Galveston Dave
by jdg4660 on Feb 16, 2012 11:57 PM CST via mobile up reply actions
Agreed
The 2009 draft left huge needs that have really caught up with us. If we had just hit on a couple players that could be solid starters right now we would be in much better shape.
I like that you state OL is the biggest priority because every reason you gave is spot on. Without good blocking, the run and the pass suffers. If you can’t move the ball, your defense will be on the field more and they’ll suffer no matter how good they are. We need Nicks or DeCastro if possible. If DeCastro’s gone (I believe he’ll be there, but we’ll see) we need to get the top linemen in round two.
I’m not sure about your Bennett prediction, but even if he does good, I won’t be sorry we let him go. I think he’d be the same guy he’s always been if he stays here because he’d be behind Witten. Maybe that’s sapping his motivation and he’ll be good for another team, but he’d never been a great producer for the Cowboys IMO.
by The Trenches on Feb 17, 2012 5:33 AM CST up reply actions
Bennett
Yep, we waited years for him to catch jump balls for TDs … Still waiting!
That said, I think he could start for a number of teams and be an ok player.
Can find an inline blocker late in the draft or sign a guy like Pope from KC for a mil.
by DB23 on Feb 17, 2012 7:54 AM CST via mobile up reply actions
NT a miss
I cant see us making a move for a NT all the noises point to Ratliff being our NT next season, our priorities are going be at DB ILB a Vet QB and maybe a Center
by LeedsCowboys on Feb 24, 2012 1:32 AM CST up reply actions
Priorities
Once you cut Newman you’re down to 2 CBs on the roster. I think they draft 2 and maybe sign one, a mid-level guy like Marshall or Lowery that can also play S.
I would like a vet C like Wells from GB. Half the price of Nicks and would really stabilize the middle; let the young guys and Kosier/Montrae compete at the Gs.
In my mind upgradIng LDE is a priority, but not sure how they do it. Lissy? Move Rat over? Sign a cap casualty like Tommy Kelly?
by DB23 on Feb 17, 2012 7:52 AM CST via mobile reply actions
Agreed. Focus FA on shoring up that o line. Im not usually in for exspensive FA but we have a 3 yr window with romo he needs protection. Resign Robinson only if its reasonable. I liked Radway before he got hurt. Then we go bpa in the draft focusing on defense. The D will be young but a solid oline will off set the giants eagles pass rush. it would be so satisfying to have the cowboys be known for a wall of an offensive line. We cant fix it all in one year. FOCUS ON THE TRENCHES!!!
JPH
ah shucks turion22
You guys don’t have to focus on me (well, maybe the posts I do). :)
by The Trenches on Feb 17, 2012 5:24 PM CST up reply actions
3 CBs i thinks dallas can get cheap
1)B. Carr – chiefs just signed Routt and have dwayne bowe to orry about
2) L. Webb – very underrated, ravens are focused on Ray Rice
3) Carlos Rodgers – another underated guy who could be the cheap CB #1 we are looking for
by cowboys fan living in new york! on Feb 23, 2012 6:48 PM CST reply actions
Most disagree but signing NT Paul Soliai is the key to everything.....
1. Free Agency: NT Paul Soliai (6’4" 355lbs) will impact the Rush Defense, Pass Rush, and Pass Defense. If we use a 6 man DL rotation, they’ll be fresh for the entire game. The Dolphins defense used this and allowed 2.9 run avg going into their Dec 17th game.
2. Round 1: OG Decastro will likely be gone but another blue-chipper OL may drop to us. If not, OT Mike Adams (6’7" 323lbs) or OG Cordy Glenn (6’5" 345lbs) should be there; need someone who can play both OT and/or OG. Note: If B. Callahan determines that OT Arkin or OG Nagy have progressed dramatically to play OG, they may even draft Wisconsin (Lineman Univ) Center, Peter Konz. (6’5" 314lbs) to compete with (short-armed) Phi Costa for the starting Center job.
3. Round 2: CB Tramaine Johnson (6’2" 204lbs/4.40 on a good day) is a big CB will be there but he needs to prove his long speed at the Combine. If we want a speed CB to matchup with WR Sean Jackson & other blazers, Asa Jackson (4.30), Brandon Boykins (4.35), C. Judie (4.38) are among several others. And, we still have practice squad CB Mario Butler (6’1" 183lbs) who had a poor Combine last year (4.65) . While he lacks long speed, he’s effective in Zone schemes (but would announce it with his presence on the field).
3a. Round 3: Speed kills in this league. It won’t happen but I’d pull the trigger on one of these proven RBs. Doug Martin (5’9" 219lbs) runs a 4.38 and Isaiah Pead (5’9" 193lbs) can run even faster at 4.32!!! Chris Polk is slightly bigger at 5’10" 224lbs and can run a 4.34!!! We need a RB that can carry the load if Demarco goes down or to tag-team with Demarco like Ahmad Bradshaw tag-teams with Brandon Jacobs. While I personally like Terrance Ganaway (5’11" 241lbs) from Baylor, he’ll probably be available in the 4th RD.
3b. Round 3: They’ll probably pick SS Harrison Smith (6’2" 212/4.46 speed) if he’s there and Elam is not resigned. If not, OLB Jonathan Massaquoi (6’2" 250lbs / 4.66 speed) has serious upside and may be the pick.
Let's start with Spencer
then move on to trenches. I think you all know where the team is going early in the draft. Next is CB then Safety, you know the drill.
Some surprises might be… QB. It sounds to me like Garrett prefers to get someone to compete with Stephen McGee in the draft not a veteran Free Agent.
Let’s talk about a backup QB, probably Orton, McNabb, Flynn and Campbell will be available, not sure about Grossman. Only Flynn would be satisfied with being a backup. Orton or Campbell backing up Romo is certainly a reach. McNabb will hold out for the #1 job somewhere, or at least the chance to compete for it.
Which one is better than your starting QB? Which one is better than your backup? Which one can step in and have playoff success if you lose your starter? Only McNabb has that on his resume and the only way you get him is if he’s available and Romo goes down. The other are more experienced then McGee but more experienced at what losing? Throwing INT’s?
QB Rating – compare career ratings – McGee – 82.4, Orton – 79.4 and Campbell – 82.8.
Rushing – McGee 6.0 avg, Orton 2.5, Campbell 4.9
Situational – last 2 minutes of half in 2011 – McGee 126.4, Orton 46.2, Campbell 113.5
last 2 minutes in 2010 – McGee 128.6, Orton 85.4, Campbell 79.0
Romo/McGee vs Philadelphia – Romo 18-35 – 51.4 – 203 – 66.7, McGee 24-38 – 63.2 – 182 – 83.4
Also, how about ILB, who is going to replace Brooking/Brady and backup Bruce Carter? Who is going to compete with Carter for ILB?

by 

























