FanPost

It's a copycat league, so I'll copy Dawn and paste my response into this post, All time 53


It's pretty simple for me

QB 1 : Tony Romo, Aikman had the poise and wins, Staubach was just great, Meredith was far ahead of his time, but Romo is just better all around than any of them.
QB 2: Danny White, If he had been the starting QB for all his years instead of a punter/back up, I think he’d have untouchable records and multiple championships.

RB 1: Herschel Walker, No doubt in my mind he is and was the greatest running back to ever play professional football. He could do it all, better than anyone else.
RB 2: Emmitt Smith, I was never a personal fan of him. But it is hard to deny what he did. His durability may have been his best trait of all.

WR 1: Michael Irvin, He was one of the most physical receivers to ever play the game. His passion was unequaled.
WR 2: Jimmy Smith, Who? The guy we let go after 2 injury plagued seasons that went on to be a top 5 all time receiver!
WR 3: Dez Bryant, As long as he stays in Dallas, he will eventually become the all time leading receiver.
WR 4: Bob Hayes, He was like a bolt of lightning in his time. His speed was astounding.

TE 1: Jason Witten, He is the best tight end to ever play the game.
TE 2: Jay Novacek, Billy Joe Dupree, Mike Ditka, Doug Cosbie, none of them were as versatile as Jay. They were all decent, but he is my #2.

FB 1: Daryl Johnston, He was actually one of the best ever. His all around game was amazing.
FB 2: Walt Garrison, this was tough for me, as I feel Don Perkins fulfilled the role of a fullback better after being moved late in his career. Robert Newhouse would actually be my # 2

OT 1: Tyron Smith, He does not have the years of proof yet, but his game is undeniable.
OT 2: Rayfield Wright, If you asked Demon Deacon Jones, he was the best tackle to ever play the game, he actually may have been.
OT 3: Flozell Adams, Here was a guy that was deaf in his right ear playing left tackle. That in itself was amazing, but he was damn good too.
OT 4: Erik Williams, If it wasn’t for his car accident, he most likely would have been one of the top 3 tackles to ever play the game.
Honorable mentions : Pat Donovan, filling Wrights shoes after converting from a defensive lineman was no easy task, but he sure was great.
Mark Tuinei, He was the definition of a lunch pail guy. He played his heart out for 60 minutes win, lose or otherwise

OG 1: Larry Allen, Just the greatest offensive lineman to ever play the game regardless of position.
OG 2: Nate Newton, Maybe the widest guy to ever play the game. He had amazing agility for such a huge man.
OG 3: Ralph Neely, One of the NFL’s most under appreciated players, he was one of, if not, the 1st lineman to pull and block at the 2nd level.
OG 4: John Niland, He was actually even better than Neely at pulling, but Neely spent a lot of time at tackle.

C 1: Mark Stepnoski, I consider him one of the best to ever play the game. Undersized or not, he used leverage better than anyone.
C 2: Tom Rafferty / Ray Donaldson, Sure Ray played 2 seasons for big D, but he was one of the best. Tom could have played anywhere.

And for Defense

DT 1: Randy White, He was the meanest SOB to ever play the game. Anyone that played against him was afraid of him.
DT 2: Bob Lilly, Mr. Cowboy, not just the 1st pick ever, but damn good at his position too.
DT 3: Jethro Pugh, He was a constant menace through the middle for many many years.
DT 4: La’Roi Glover, Although his career was short in Dallas, he was extremely dominant for being "undersized" while here.

DE 1: Harvey Martin, 23 sacks in 14 games. Nothing more needs said. NO ONE has ever come close to that.
DE 2: Charles Haley, His skill as a rusher was second to none at the time he played.
DE 3: Ed Jones, 6’9" he was a monster! He was a very agile man with great balance and strength for being so tall.
DE 4: Jim Jeffcoat, Often overlooked for how good he really was. He was always a ball hawk and followed it better than most.

OLB 1: DeMarcus Ware, I think he would of had better numbers as a 4-3 DE for his whole career.
OLB 2: Chuck Howley, If you don’t know why he’s my number 2, don’t ask.
OLB 3: D.D. Lewis, Admit that you all are going "Who?". He is the guy that coined the phrase "Texas Stadium has a hole in the roof so God can watch his favorite team play" That alone puts him on my list!
OLB 4: Ken Norton Jr., What could have been if he never left….although he seemed to be injured as much as he played.

ILB 1: Lee Roy Jordan, His career was overshadowed by the fact that there were many very good inside linebackers on other teams when he played.
ILB 2: Eugene Lockhart, Had he played on better teams he would have been a multiple All Pro.
ILB 3: Bob Breunig, Mr. consistent. Granted he was made good by Landry’s flex defense, but he still produced over and over.
ILB 4: Sean Lee, He could be number one if he ever finds a way to stay healthy, which I never expect.

CB 1: Deion Sanders, Please, if you think anyone has ever been better, go smoke some more.
CB 2: Mel Renfro, This list seems redundant, as I think most have the same guys.
CB 3: Everson Walls, He ran 4.8 on a good day. Anyone this slow that made plays like he did was awesome. Imagine if he was athletic.
CB 4: Dennis Thurman, Thurmans Thieves, that saying is enough for me to add him, but he lived up to the billing.

S 1: Darren Woodson, I personally think he was one of the best to ever play and should be a Hall of Famer.
S 2: Cliff Harris, If he isn’t on everyones list, you have no idea what a good player truly is.
S 3: Mel Renfro, The only player I have in two positions.
S 4: Bill Bates, He may have been a special teams guy, but he was the best one ever.
Honorable Mention: Charlie Waters. He was my first ever favorite player.

LS 1: Dale Hellestrae, He was one of the most consistent ever at his position. 11 seasons with Dallas and he had 15 different kickers.
LS 2: L.P.LaDouceur, He has never had a bad snap since taking over in 2005
LS 3: Jeff Robinson, sure he played 2 seasons in Dallas, but he also scored 4 TD’s on 4 receptions as a goal line TE.

K 1: Rafael Septien, I wanted to make Bailey my number one, but he needs more time to win me over
K 2: Dan Bailey, He has a chance to oust Boniol for the best 3 years to start in Dallas

P 1: Mat McBriar, While with Dallas he was also one of the best in the NFL
P 2: Mike Saxon, He was almost as much of a mainstay as Septien.

Another user-created commentary provided by a BTB reader.