clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

2016 NFL Mock Draft Database 3.0: What The Wisdom Of 50 Mocks Says About Who Cowboys Will Pick

We leverage the mother of all mock draft databases to get a better feel for what the Cowboys will do with their top pick in the 2016 NFL draft.

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

In our first mock draft database of the season, published the day before the Senior Bowl on January 29, we took a look at 30 different mock drafts. A week later, we upped that number to 37 different mock drafts. Today, our tally has reached 50 mock drafts.

In 2004, James Surowiecki published a book titled "The Wisdom of Crowds: Why the Many Are Smarter Than the Few and How Collective Wisdom Shapes Business, Economies, Societies and Nations." As you'd expect from the uber-long title, the central argument is that the aggregation of information from a large group of people can provide better results than from any single individual.

Using our 50 draft analysts as our sample crowd, their aggregated wisdom suggests Myles Jack (30% of the vote) or Jalen Ramsey (20%) will be the Cowboys pick in the 2016 NFL draft, though we may not have needed 50 mock drafts to figure that out. Similarly, 80% of the mocks seem to agree that the Cowboys will not be picking a QB with their No. 4 pick.

Here's who the 50 mocks have the Cowboys picking.

Mock Draft Database 3.0 - Who do the draft analysts have the Cowboys selecting at No. 4?
Analyst Site Cowboys pick at No. 4 Position School Last Update
Drafttek Team DraftTek Jalen Ramsey
CB/S Florida State 2/19
Alpha1 Alpha Football Expert Myles Jack
LB UCLA
2/19
Kevin Hanson EDS Football Joey Bosa
DE Ohiao State
2/19
Mel Kiper ESPN Jared Goff QB California 2/18
Lance Zierlein NFL.com Jalen Ramsey
CB/S Florida State 2/18
Staff Draftseason Paxton Lynch
QB Memphis 2/18
Matt LaPan Draftbreakdown Jalen Ramsey
CB/S Florida State 2/18
Eric Edholm Yahoo Sports Jalen Ramsey
CB/S Florida State 2/17
Chad Reuter NFL.com Joey Bosa
DE Ohio State
2/17
Walter Cherepinsky Walter Football Myles Jack
LB UCLA 2/17
Chris Burke SI.com Myles Jack LB UCLA 2/17
Eddie Borwn San Diego Union Trib. Myles Jack
LB UCLA 2/17
Paul Banks Sportsbank Myles Jack
LB UCLA 2/17
Tab Bamford Chicago Sportstab Carson Wentz
QB N.D. State 2/17
Daniel Jeremiah NFL.com Myles Jack
LB UCLA 2/16
Dan Kadar SB Nation Myles Jack LB UCLA 2/15
Rob Rang CBS Sports Myles Jack LB UCLA 2/15
Ryan McCrystal DraftAce Myles Jack LB UCLA 2/15
Dane Brugler CBS Sports Joey Bosa
DE Ohio State 2/15
Jon Meoli Baltimore Sun Carson Wentz QB
N.D. State 2/15
Charlie Campbell Walter Football Myles Jack
LB
Ohio State 2/15
Rob Staton Seahawksdraftblog Jalen Ramsey CB/S Florida State 2/14
Steve Serby NY Post DeForest Buckner
DE Oregon 2/13
Charean Williams Fort Worth Star-Telegram Myles Jack
LB UCLA 2/12
NESN Staff NESN Myles Jack
LB UCLA 2/12
Josh Norris Rotoworld NFL Myles Jack
LB UCLA 2/11
Jon Valencia Breaking Football Joey Bosa DE Ohio State 2/11
Hays Carlton Florida Times Union Paxton Lynch
QB
Memphis
2/11
Lou Pickney Draft King Jalen Ramsey
CB/S
Florida State
2/11
Robert Davis Football's Future Carson Wentz
QB N.D. State 2/10
Dan Bilicki Toronto Sun Joey Bosa DE Ohio State 2/10
Eric Galko Sporting News Joey Bosa
DE Ohio State 2/09
Dan Turner NFL Draft Zone Myles Jack LB UCLA 2/09
DJ Boyer Draft Site Myles Jack LB UCLA 2/09
Matt Miller Bleacher Report Joey Bosa
DE Ohio State 2/08
Dan Wilkens The Score Laquon Treadwell WR Ole Miss 2/08
Bob McManaman AZCentral Paxton Lynch
QB Memphis
2/08
Nate Davis USA Today Joey Bosa DE Ohio State 2/08
Robert Judin Campus Insiders Jalen Ramsey CB/S Florida State 2/08
Nick Clopsis Newsday Laquon Treadwell WR Ole Miss 2/08
Todd McShay ESPN (McShay) Carson Wentz
QB N.D. State
2/03
Dave Syvertsen Ourlads Carson Wentz
QB N.D. State
2/02
Steve Palazzolo Pro Football Focus Jalen Ramsey
CB/S Florida State 2/02
Jeff Risdon RealGM Ezekiel Elliot
RB Ohio State
2/01
Scott Wright DraftCountdown Joey Bosa DE Ohio State 1/26
Peter Schrager Foxsports Jared Goff QB Cal 1/26
Bucky Brooks NFL.com Joey Bosa
DE Ohio State 1/17
Jason McIntyre The Big Lead Jalen Ramsey CB/S Florida State 1/13
John Harris Washington Post Andrew Billings DT Baylor 1/13
GBN Staff Great Blue North Jalen Ramsey CB/S Florida State 1/07

Here's a further breakdown of how the players selected have changed since two weeks ago.

Summary results by player
Player POS Jan 29
Feb 5
Feb 19
Myles Jack LB 9 9 15
Jalen Ramsey CB 5 3 10
Joey Bosa DE 6 7 9
Carson Wentz QB 1 9 5
Paxton Lynch QB - - 1 3
Jared Goff QB 1 1 2
Laquon Treadwell WR 1 1 2
DeForest Buckner DE 2 2 1
Andrew Billings DT 1 1 1
Ezekiel Elliott RB - - 1 1
A'Shawn Robinson DT 3 2 - -
Robert Nkemdiche DT 1 - - - -

For the wisdom of crowds argument to work, you have to believe that there are different knowledge levels in a crowd that can be coordinated to provide a more precise result in aggregate. But what if there's no knowledge level in these mocks at all?

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Blogging The Boys Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of all your Dallas Cowboys news from Blogging The Boys