clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Cowboys Draft 2019: Pick 58 is great spot for the Cowboys to grab a safety

The Cowboys are interested in this year’s safety class and their first pick, in round two, might be the perfect spot.

NCAA Football: Senior Bowl Chuck Cook-USA TODAY Sports

An important attribute shared by the NFL’s best drafting teams is the ability to identify and maximize the value of each pick. For instance, last year the Cowboys felt like offensive line and receiver depth stretched a little further than linebacker. They picked up the linebacker first and then found tremendous value in their day two selections. Identifying a “sweet spot” at a position is a key component to draft success and something the Cowboys are most definitely aware of.

Heading up to the draft, we’re going to identify the positions of interest for the Cowboys and when the right time to strike will be.

(Here is a chart of 15 safeties entering this year’s draft with various round projections. We’ll include all pre-draft visitors. All rankings are based of CBS’ Draft Scout prospect rankings.)

JOHNATHAN ABRAM, SS MISS. STATE 30 1-2 4.44 195 15.5 3 2 10
NASIR ADDERLEY, FS DELAWARE 33 1-2 4.53 226 1.5 1 10 31
JUAN THORNHILL, SS VIRGINIA 39 2 4.42 208 12 1 13 26
DEIONTE THOMPSON, FS ALABAMA 43 2 4.42 112 4.5 3 3 7
C. GARDNER-JOHNSON, FS FLORIDA 48 2 4.48 161 15.5 0 9 12
TAYLOR RAPP, SS WASHINGTON 49 2 4.69 168 8.5 2 7 6
DARNELL SAVAGE, FS MARYLAND 68 2-3 4.36 182 9 0 8 13
AMANI HOOKER, SS IOWA 82 3 4.48 125 3.5 0 6 9
JAQUAN JOHNSON,SS MIAMI 138 4 4.69 252 7.5 6 8 7
SHELDRICK REDWINE, FS MIAMI 161 5 4.44 167 6 4 5 10
WILL HARRIS, SS BOSTON 163 5 4.41 225 7.5 1 5 7
MARQUISE BLAIR, FS UTAH 216 6-7 4.48 106 5 1 2 4
KHARI WILLIS, SS MICH. STATE 274 7-FA 4.52 189 7 2 3 13
MIKE EDWARDS, FS KENTUCKY 285 7-FA 4.51 317 21 2 10 23
EVAN WORTHINGTON, SS COLORADO 348 7-FA 4.63 128 10 1 4 11

Some of these names might be familiar to you as several of them are pre-draft visitors. In total, six of the Cowboys’ 30 pre-draft visits are safeties, four of them are projected to be drafted in the second or early third rounds. Safety is shaping up to be a pretty good good bet for the Cowboys first selection at 58th overall. Which of the options above are the best fit for Kris Richard’s defensive secondary?

Let’s focus on four guys that have the best chance to be available when the Cowboys pick. We’ll do a little mini-scouting report on each of them to identify strengths and weaknesses.

Juan Thornhill

JR -Virginia HT: 6'1 WT:195 PROJ. RD: 2



Very impressive in coverage w/ outstanding feet

A+ Versatility for Zone & Man, excellent timing

Great Ball skills tracks well & high points ball

Strong football instinct, elite vision & anticipation

Acceleration average at best

Wingspan & length are a concern

Tackling improved but still needs work

Lack of flexibility in hips needs to turn & mirror

Can look stiff at times

Juan Thornhill is on the Cowboys radar because he checks all the boxes in terms of versatility. Xavier Woods is part of the Cowboys future plan and has played both single-high and down in the box, and even got play slot cornerback as a rookie. Thornhill is very comfortable playing an interchangeable role but his best fit might be out deep in coverage. Thornhill isn’t the most trustworthy tackler, though he was much better in 2018. His abilities in coverage alone make him a solid addition to this Dallas defense and he does have 13 interceptions in three seasons.

Chauncey Gardner-Johnson

JR -Florida HT:5'11 WT:207 PROJ. RD: 2



Strong burst & twitchy

Explosive change of direction

Naturally gifted athlete

Great footwork

Elite quickness allows him to make play after play

Balance issues in tackling needs to work on technique refinement

Versatility is average still seems uncomfortable in man vs. zone

Has very little experience fighting through WR hands & contesting the ball

Chauncey Gardner-Johnson is a fun player to watch because his attitude is infectious and that motor is something that Kris Richard will appreciate. If the Cowboys are keen on athleticism at the position, he’s your guy. Gardner-Johnson is an explosive player with consistent play speed to make up ground in an instant. He’s a very sudden player and his knack for reading quarterbacks would add a dynamic that the Cowboys don’t really have.

In the past two seasons, Gardner-Johnson has 15 tackles for loss, four sacks, six interceptions, and two pick-sixes. He’s an ascending player but he will take more time to develop as a deep safety because he lacks focus at times. It’s understandable to want to force turnovers but assignments are just as key to a great defender. He gets caught on double moves and can be baited into mistakes. If he is sitting there at 58, he might be too tempting to pass up.

Taylor Rapp

JR-WASH HT: 6'1 WT:195 PROJ. RD: 2



An "ACE" tackler, best in class

Great run defender, closing quickness solid

Anticipation very good & football IQ is good

Extremely competitive, plays w/ forceful attitude

Never quits, determined to make every tackle

Sub-par change of direction & Short-area burst limits usage

Not effective as a deep safety

Slow-footed & timing is off, doesn't play w/ instinct

Rarely makes impact plays in coverage

Not going to produce takeaways

Very linear player with limited athleticism

Taylor Rapp is very good at what he does, so long as you don’t ask him to play out of his position. Rapp’s impact is going to be felt as a strong safety in the box, playing the run, and being involved in every tackle. If you want versatility, it’s best to look elsewhere because Rapp is just not effective playing single-high and was always late to the action in limited action in the deep field. In terms of coverage, he can help with tight end but it would be a mistake to have him run with a receiver, he’s just a bit too slow and will get exposed.

Rapp isn’t going to dazzle you with interceptions but he does a lot of the dirty work. Rapp’s splash plays come in pursuit of the ball-carrier, he’s kind of a throwback to safeties of the past era. It’s going to to take the right team that knows his limitations for him to be successful in the NFL.

Darnell Savage

SR-Maryland HT:5'11 WT:191 PROJ RD:2-3



Incredible burst & makeup speed

He's a closer w/ elite short area agility

Brings the heat as a tackler, takes great

Pure finisher w/ a hit stick

Outstanding ball skills, Threat to return INT for TDs

Needs improvement in single-high

Too jumpy needs patience to not take 1st route

Shows discomfort in man duties, needs to trust himself

Must improve spacing, elite traits but needs discipline

Darnell Savage is one of the more exciting safeties to watch because he has really phenomenal speed. There aren’t a lot of safeties out there that can move like Savage and he’s one of the more well-rounded defensive backs in this class. He struggles to trust his instincts in man coverage and tends to be much more comfortable handling his zones. Savage is a tough-nosed defender and will bring violence and punishment to your defense. However, he still struggles with consistency as a run defender and will need to learn how to play with discipline in the NFL.

Though Savage needs to develop more as a single-high option, he’s still very good in coverage. The level of competition will come into question. Maryland performed poorly against all powerhouse schools and have just one five-point win over the Longhorns to hang their hats on. Still, Savage wins far more matchups than he loses and has shown his value as a playmaker with seven interceptions and two pick-sixes in the past two seasons.

Just processing the players that the Cowboys have brought in would suggest that they are targeting safety as a priority in this draft. Each of these guys have varied strengths and weaknesses so the Cowboys will have to determine exactly which guy can make the biggest impact for their defense.


Which safety would you draft to the Cowboys?

This poll is closed

  • 38%
    Juan Thornhill, Virginia
    (566 votes)
  • 18%
    Chauncey Gardner-Johnson, Florida
    (281 votes)
  • 13%
    Taylor Rapp, Washington
    (199 votes)
  • 29%
    Darnell Savage, Maryland
    (435 votes)
1481 votes total Vote Now

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Blogging The Boys Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of all your Dallas Cowboys news from Blogging The Boys