clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

How the Cowboys graded their 2022 draft picks - and what that could mean for their future in Dallas

A review of the many leaked draft boards and what they could mean for this year’s Cowboys draft class.

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

COLLEGE FOOTBALL: SEP 25 Southwest Classic - Texas A&M v Arkansas Photo by Matthew Pearce/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images

The Cowboys, God bless their generous hearts, managed to leak their draft board for the fourth time in 12 years. Apart from confirming what we already knew - the Cowboys are a circus, and some might even say a clown show - there are some takeaways from those four boards that are worth looking into a bit deeper, especially in the context of this year’s draft.

But before we go there, let’s first take a look at the first 34 names on this year’s draft board, with a hat tip to a bunch of enterprising Twitter Cowboys for the first 16 names, and a huge hat tip to Jon Machota of The Athletic for the remaining 18 names.

First-round Grades
Rank Player College POS Pick Team
1 Kayvon Thibodeaux Oregon DE 5 NYG
2 Evan Neal Alabama OT 7 NYG
3 Aidan Hutchinson Michigan DE 2 DET
4 Garrett Wilson Ohio St. WR 10 NYJ
5 Ahmad Gardner Cincinnati CB 4 NYJ
6 Derek Stingley Jr. LSU CB 3 HOU
7 Travon Walker Georgia DE 1 JAX
8 Kyle Hamilton Notre Dame S 14 BAL
9 Ikem Ekwonu NC State OT 6 CAR
10 Drake London USC WR 8 ATL
11 Jordan Davis Georgia DT 13 PHI
12 Charles Cross Miss. State OT 9 SEA
13 Lewis Cine Georgia S 32 MIN
14 Jameson Williams Alabama WR 12 DET
Second-round Grades
Rank Player College POS Pick Team
15 Chris Olave Ohio St. WR 11 NO
16 Tyler Smith Tulsa OT 24 DAL
17 Devin Lloyd Utah LB 27 JAX
18 Daxton Hill Michigan S 31 CIN
19 Breece Hall Iowa State RB 36 NYJ
20 Kenyon Green Texas A&M OG 15 HOU
21 George Karlaftis Purdue DE 30 KC
22 Zion Johnson Boston College OG 17 LAC
23 Treylon Burks Arkansas WR 18 TEN
24 Kyler Gordon Washington CB 39 CHI
25 Tyler Linderbaum Iowa C 25 BAL
26 David Ojaba Michigan DE 45 BAL
27 Jahan Dotson Penn State WR 16 WAS
28 Jermaine Johnson II Florida St. DE 26 NYJ
29 Kaiir Elam Florida CB 23 BUF
30 Arnold Ebiketie Penn State DE 38 ATL
31 Trent McDuffie Washington CB 21 KC
32 Quay Walker Georgia LB 22 GB
33 Devonte Wyatt Georgia DT 28 GB
34 Logan Hall Houston DE 33 TB
35 - -
36 - -
37 - -
38 - -

Before we delve into the specifics of the board, here is what we already knew before the board was deciphered:

  • At the end of March, Jerry Jones said, “Famous last words: We’ll get [an offensive lineman] unless Lamb or Parsons is there.” Which is exactly what they did.
  • Two days before the draft, perhaps trying his hand at some subterfuge, Stephen Jones said the Cowboys had 14-16 first-round graded players on their board. After the first round, Stephen Jones clarified that number and specifically mentioned 14 first-round grades. Which is exactly the amount they had.
  • In the press conference after the first round, Jerry Jones flashed the draft board and explained that the Cowboys had Tyler Smith ranked 16th, and the two guards (Green & Johnson) ranked below him. We now know this to also be true.

Taken together with what we’ve seen from previous draft boards, there are a couple of key takeaways from this:

  1. The Cowboys don’t lie. When they say they have a player ranked in a certain spot, or above another player, this has been born out by the leaked draft boards repeatedly. In 2016, Jerry Jones said that Ezekiel Elliott had the highest grade of any player on their draft board and that Jalen Ramsey was ranked No. 2 on their board. When we eventually got our hands on the draft board, it turned out to be correct. In 2013, Jerry Jones said their top three picks (Travis Frederick, Terrance Williams, Gavin Escobar) were all in the ‘early 20s’ on their draft board. Jones was initially ridiculed for that, but when we got hold of the draft board a month later, the three players were ranked 22, 23, and 25. This of course has caused some fans to wonder whether the boards were leaked intentionally, and I know that conspiracy fantasies are a big thing right now, but sometimes the simplest explanation is the best: your big dumb team did something stupid again. For the fourth time no less.
  2. What is it that keeps pushing Jerry and Stephen to divulge these details? Is it that they think they are the smartest guys in the room, and they need to show everybody how smart they are? Or is this driven by a deep-rooted insecurity about their football acumen that results in a need to validate themselves by blabbing out internal stuff? Who in their right mind pulls out a draft board at a press conference, and why?
  3. If you ask Bill Belichick why he picked a given player, he’ll tell you “we picked the player because we liked the player.” And that’ll be the end of the discussion.

On to this year’s draft class.

The offensive guard narrative.

To anybody watching the Cowboys last year, it was abundantly clear that the team needed help at guard. And through the miracle of mock drafts and other offseason content, guards were linked to Dallas on an almost daily basis, with the occasional center thrown in for good measure. In many ways that slow drip of mock draft goodness, along with exhaustive draft analysis about Dallas’ interior OL needs, plus the Top 30 invite list conditioned us to expect the Cowboys to pick a guard with their first pick.

Since 2010, the Cowboys have drafted 10 offensive linemen in the first four rounds of the draft, care to take a guess how many of those 10 linemen were guards in college? Here’s an overview:

Year Rnd Pick Player College POS
2011 1 9 Tyron Smith T
2014 1 16 Zack Martin T
2022 1 24 Tyler Smith T
2013 1 31 Travis Frederick C
2018 2 50 Connor Williams T
2019 3 90 Connor McGovern C/G
2015 3 91 Chaz Green T
2011 4 110 David Arkin T
2021 4 138 Josh Ball T
2020 4 146 Tyler Biadasz C

Connor McGovern is the only one of those 10 players to play mostly at guard in college: Two centers were added to the mix, the rest played tackle in college. The Cowboys like to draft tackles which they can then move inside. We should have known this, and we shouldn’t have been surprised that they took a tackle, but a lot of us were.

What Tyler Smith’s second-round grade could tell us.

We now know that Smith had a second-round grade on the Cowboys’ board. We also know that Smith needs some development before he’ll be a starter, inside or outside. But that second-round grade tells us something about what the Cowboys expect from him down the line. And to figure out what that could be, we can take a look at previous Cowboys draft boards and figure out the career arc of other tackles with a second-round grade. The table below summarizes the four players that fit the bill:

Year Player POS Cowboys Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2013 D.J. Fluker OT 2nd 1-11 7 43
2013 Justin Pugh OT 2nd 1-19 9 44
2016 Taylor Decker OT 2nd 1-16 5 33
2016 Jack Conklin OT 2nd 1-8 5 49

That’s quite a peer group! If you’re a tackle and the Cowboys had a second-round grade on you, a long NFL career apparently awaits. Decker and Conklin have been primary starters for their teams in five out of six possible seasons, Pugh has been the starter in every one of his nine NFL seasons, and Fluker notched seven out of nine starter seasons. This augurs well for Tyler Smith.

Where were Williams and Tolbert graded?

The Cowboys have been remarkably tight-lipped (so far) about where they had Williams and Tolbert graded.

We know via Bobby Belt that the team considered both Williams and Tolbert for their second-round pick at 56.

This suggests the two players were ranked very close to each other (perhaps similar to the Frederick/Williams/Escobar situation in 2013). What we don’t know is whether both players had a second- or third-round grade. What we do know is that

  • in 2010, the Cowboys’ draft board had 24 players with first-round grades, but only 16 players with a second-round grade.
  • in 2013, the Cowboys had 18 players with first-round grades, and 22 with a second-round grade.
  • in 2016, the Cowboys had just 16 players with first-round grades and 24 with second-round grades.

It’s probably just pure coincidence that all three boards have exactly 40 players with first- or second round grades, but it chimes nicely with this year’s draft board.

We know that the list Jerry flashed into the camera contains 38 names, the last four of which are undecipherable. Are there more second-round grades on the next page that Jerry didn’t show, and are Williams and Tolbert part of that group? Or are Williams and/or Tolbert perhaps part of the four undecipherable names? We may never know the answer to these questions, but for now we’ll assume both had second-round grades.

With that assumption, we can again look back at the three previously leaked draft boards and look at the career arcs of defensive ends and wide receivers with a second-round grade on the Cowboys’ board, conveniently summarized in the following table:

Year Player POS Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2010 Jerry Hughes DE 2nd 1-31 8 62
2010 Brandon Graham DE 2nd 1-13 6 56
2016 Ermmanuel Ogbah DE 2nd 2-32 5 32
2013 Margus Hunt DE 2nd 2-53 1 18
2016 Kevin Dodd DE 2nd 2-33 0 2
Year Player POS Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2013 DeAndre Hopkins WR 2nd 1-27 8 71
2010 Demaryius Thomas WR 2nd 1-22 8 69
2013 Terrance Williams WR 2nd 3-74 4 27
2016 Will Fuller WR 2nd 1-21 5 24
2016 Josh Doctson WR 2nd 1-22 2 9
2013 Justin Hunter WR 2nd 2-34 1 9
2016 Laquon Treadwell WR 2nd 1-23 2 8
2016 Corey Coleman WR 2nd 1-15 2 6

For Williams, the second-round peer group looks promising. If Williams’ career arc would follow that of Hughes, Graham, or Ogbah, the Cowboys will have hit a homerun with the pick. Of course, Margus Hunt and Kevin Dodd are stark reminders that not every draft pick pans out, even if they were highly graded out of college.

The risk overall appears to be higher for Tolbert, based on this analysis. There are two bona fide stars in DeAndre Hopkins and Demaryius Thomas on that eight-name WR list, but there are also a lot of misses among the names. We can hope for a DeAndre Hopkins- type trajectory for Tolbert, but more realistically we might be better off expecting a Terrance Williams-type career arc.

Day Three picks.

We didn’t have to wait for a leaked draft board to figure out how the Day Three picks were graded, the Cowboys generously broadcast that information entirely of their own volition. Here’s what was posted on DallasCowboys.com:

They had a fourth-round grade or better on five of the six selections. Tight end Jake Ferguson, offensive tackle Matt Waletzko, cornerback DaRon Bland, linebacker Damone Clark and linebacker Devin Harper had fourth-round grades. Clark had a third-round grade and was drafted with the 33rd pick in the fifth round, No. 176 overall.

The only exception was defensive tackle John Ridgeway, who had a fifth-round grade and was selected in the fifth round.

And that gives us a good picture of how this draft class was graded:

Round Player Position Cowboys Grade
1 Tyler Smith OL 2nd
2 De Williams DE 2nd or 3rd
3 Jalen Tolbert WR 2nd or 3rd
4 Jake Ferguson TE 4th
5 Matt Waletzko OT 4th
5 DaRon Bland CB 4th
5 Damone Clark LB 3rd
5 John Ridgeway DT 5th
6 Devin Harper LB 4th

Going back to the idea of peer groups, here’s what Damone Clark’s peer group of third-round graded linebackers looks like:

Year Player POS Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2016 Deion Jones LB 3rd 2-52 5 39
2013 Jonathan Bostic LB 3rd 2-50 5 34
2010 Daryl Washington LB 3rd 2-47 4 34
2013 Gerald Hodges LB 3rd 4-120 1 18
2013 Arthur Brown LB 3rd 2-56 0 3
2010 Sergio Kindle LB 3rd 2-43 0 0

If and how Clark recovers from his spinal fusion surgery will go a long way to determine his future in the NFL, but his draft board peer group suggests there’s a 50/50 chance he turns into a multi-year starter.

Here are the peer groups for the fourth-round graded players:

Year Player POS Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2010 Ed Dickson TE 4th 3-70 7 16
2010 Tony Moeaki TE 4th 3-93 2 10
2010 Clay Harbor TE 4th 4-125 2 7
Year Player POS Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2013 David Bakhtiari OT 4th 4-109 8 80
2010 Vladimir Ducasse OT 4th 2-61 4 21
2013 Dallas Thomas OT 4th 3-77 1 13
Year Player POS Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2016 Joe Schobert LB 4th 4-99 5 36
2013 Kiko Alonso LB 4th 2-46 4 33
2010 Perry Riley LB 4th 4-103 6 30
2010 Donald Butler LB 4th 3-79 5 29
2016 Nick Vigil LB 4th 3-87 4 25
2013 Sio Moore LB 4th 3-66 2 14
2013 Brandon Magee LB 4th UDFA 0 2
2013 Sean Porter LB 4th 4-118 0 0
Year Player POS Grade Pick Starter Seasons wAV
2016 James Bradberry CB 4th 2-62 6 34
2013 David Amerson CB 4th 2-51 4 20
2016 Anthony Brown CB 4th 6-189 3 20
2016 LeShaun Sims CB 4th 5-157 0 11
2010 Dominique Franks CB 4th 5-135 0 6
2016 Cyrus Jones CB 4th 2-60 0 4
2010 Myron Lewis CB 4th 3-67 0 1
2013 Will Davis CB 4th 3-93 0 0

TE Jake Ferguson: At first glance, the TE peer group looks rather weak in terms of weighted AV, but all three guys were starters for their teams (for a while), and at the very least were very serviceable No. 2 TEs. That’s probably a good expectation for Ferguson, who’ll play behind the franchise-tagged Dalton Schultz this year, but might be asked to step up next year if the Cowboys fail to reach a contract extension with Schultz.

OT Matt Waletzko: Waletzko caused quite a stir with Cowboys fans thanks to his freakish size and athleticism (6-foot-7, 9.96 RAS). His peer group contains a multiple Pro Bowl left tackle in David Bakhtiari, a nine-year NFL veteran in Vlad Ducasse, and a guy (Dallas Thomas) who started 26 games at guard over a four-year NFL career. That’s not a bad floor for a fifth-rounder, and certainly an exciting upside.

LB Devin Harper: Linebackers picked in the sixth round usually have to work their way onto the team via special teams. But the fourth-round graded peer group looks more promising: six of the eight players in that group turned into multi-year NFL starters. That’s encouraging, but Harper will have to work his way up through a crowded LB room before becoming a starter.

CB DaRon Bland: Of the eight corners listed in the table above, only three turned into multi-year starters, so the odds are not stacked in Bland’s favor. But one of the guys listed is the Cowboys’ own Anthony Brown, and if Bland can mirror Brown’s NFL career arc that would definitely be a plus for the Cowboys.

DT John Ridgeway: There are only two comparables in Ridgeway’s peer group, and I didn’t include them in the table above. Akeem Spence (2013, 4-100) started 57 games so far in the NFL with four starter seasons, while Josh Boyd (2013, 5-167) started just four games over a three-year NFL career. That can mean everything and nothing. As Cowboys fans we keep hoping for another Jay Ratliff, but more often than not we end up with guys like Joey Ivie or Jordan Carrell.


Given the data above, which draft pick are you most optimistic about?